Review Article
Diabetes empowerment related to Pender’s Health
Promotion Model: A meta-synthesis
Agnes Yin Kwan Ho, rn, mnsc,
1
Ingela Berggren, rn, drpolit
1
and Elisabeth Dahlborg-Lyckhage, rn, phd
1,2
1
Department of Nursing, Health and Culture, University West,Trollhättan and
2
Institute of Health and Caring Science,
Sahlgrenska Academy, Gothenburg, Sweden
Abstract Diabetes self-management is a challenge for both clients and health-care professionals. Empowerment plays
a vital role in helping clients to achieve successful self-management. This study adopted a meta-ethnographic
approach. Nine qualitative studies were synthesized in order to contribute to a deeper understanding of what
clients perceive as being important in an effective empowerment strategy for diabetes self-management. Four
central metaphors that influenced empowerment were identified: trust in nurses’ competence and awareness,
striving for control, a desire to share experiences, and nurses’ attitudes and ability to personalize. The
lines-of-argument synthesis suggested the need for an evaluation system to appraise clients’ diabetes knowl-
edge, health beliefs, and negative emotions, as well as the outcome of interventions. Based on Pender’s Health
Promotion Model, this study emphasizes the fact that health-care professionals need to understand and
address modifiable behavior-specific variables. The study suggests that an effective empowerment strategy
would be to use activity-related affect, as well as interpersonal and situational influences, as a means of
facilitating and enhancing clients’ health-promoting behaviors.
Key words diabetes, empowerment, Health Promotion Model, meta-ethnography, self-management.
INTRODUCTION
Diabetes is a global public health concern for many nations in
the 21st century and ~ 246 million people worldwide have
diabetes, almost 6% of the world’s adult population (IDF,
2006a). About 80% of these clients live in developing coun-
tries and suffer from type 2 diabetes, of whom 46% are in the
40–59 year age group. The eastern Mediterranean and the
Middle East are the regions with the highest diabetes preva-
lence rates. In 2007, India had the world’s largest diabetes
population, followed by China, the USA, Russia, Germany,
Japan, Pakistan, Brazil, Mexico, and Egypt (IDF, 2006a).The
highest prediabetes prevalence is in the European region,
with 9% of the adult population being at significant risk of
developing type 2 diabetes (IDF, 2006b).The escalating dia-
betes prevalence is underpinned by factors such as an aging
population, unhealthy diet, overweight, and obesity, as well as
physical inactivity (IDF, 2009).
Diabetes self-management is a lifelong commitment. An
effective self-care regimen and a multidisciplinary team
approach are required to avoid or delay the serious chronic
complications of the disease. Acquiring diabetes knowledge
through education plays an essential role in diabetes self-
management, as improved knowledge will lead to an effective
change in self-management behaviors (Booker et al., 2008).
In recent years, the empowerment concept has been adopted
in modern diabetes care. Rodwell (1996: 309) defined
empowerment as a helping process “. . . whereby groups or
individuals are enabled to change a situation, given skills,
resources, opportunities and authority to do so. It is a part-
nership, which respects and values self and others – aiming
to develop a positive belief in self and the future”. The em-
powerment process involves client-centered collaborative
partnership, an active client role, shared decision-making,
freedom to make choices, and acceptance of responsibility
for one’s actions (Adolfsson et al., 2008; Booker et al., 2008).
Several approaches, based on the empowerment concept,
have been implemented in diabetes care to facilitate clients’
self-management, with different levels of success. Conven-
tional individual counseling, which focuses on goal-setting
and problem-solving strategies, can encourage clients to iden-
tify realistic diabetes goals and could improve diabetes
outcomes (Corser et al., 2007; Utz et al., 2008). Hence, the
intervention is restricted by clients’ limited knowledge of
diabetes and, thus, inability to make informed choices (Ado-
lfsson et al., 2008). Group education intervention underlines
shared experiences of managing diabetes, highlighting that
empowerment can be facilitated through reassurance from
others in a similar situation (Adolfsson et al., 2008; Booker
et al., 2008). Moreover, interventions that are based on client
expertise, such as lay-led research advisory groups, stress real
world connection and client involvement in health research
Correspondence address: Agnes Yin Kwan Ho, Solgärdesvägen 13, 436 42 Askim,
Sweden. Email: hoykchina@hotmail.com
Received 9 June 2009; accepted 14 January 2010.
Nursing and Health Sciences (2010), 12, 259–267
© 2010 Blackwell Publishing Asia Pty Ltd. doi: 10.1111/j.1442-2018.2010.00517.x