New Insights into the Relationship between Micropore Properties,
Ionic Sizes, and Electric Double-Layer Capacitance in Monolithic
Carbon Electrodes
George Hasegawa,*
,†,‡
Kazuyoshi Kanamori,
†
Kazuki Nakanishi,
†
and Takeshi Abe
‡
†
Department of Chemistry, Graduate School of Science, Kyoto University, Kitashirakawa, Sakyo-ku, Kyoto 606-8502, Japan
‡
Department of Energy & Hydrocarbon Chemistry, Graduate School of Engineering, Kyoto University, Katsura, Nishikyo-ku, Kyoto
615-8510, Japan
ABSTRACT: The effects of the pore properties and the ionic
sizes on the electric double-layer capacitances have been
investigated by using the monolithic carbon electrodes with
different pore properties. The carbon monoliths with high
surface areas which possess homogeneous pore properties in
the whole monoliths were prepared from the bridged-
polysilsesquioxane gels via the nanophase extraction technique.
The detailed investigations of the pore properties of the carbon
monoliths were conducted by the nitrogen physisorption
measurement as well as the mercury porosimetry. The
electrochemical property of each monolithic carbon electrode
was examined by the cyclic voltammetry in the different
aqueous electrolytes in order to investigate the effects of the
ionic sizes. These fundamental analyses have provided new insights into the efficient micropore sizes in each electrolyte for the
superior electric double-layer capacitors.
1. INTRODUCTION
On growing demands for energy storage, porous electrode
materials are attracting increasing attention, and the pore
properties are regarded as one of the most important factors for
the electrode capability.
1-8
In the case of Li-ion batteries, the
pores in the electrode materials help the rapid diffusion of Li
+
ions especially in the materials with poor ionic conductivities,
such as olivine-type materials.
9-11
The pores in the electrodes
play a different role in the case of electric double-layer (EDL)
capacitors,
12-14
in which the electric charge is stored by a non-
faradaic mechanism in the double layer at the electrode/
electrolyte interface. Hence, the capacities of EDL capacitors
are dependent on the accessibility of the electrolyte ions to the
pores in the electrodes and therefore on the effective surface
area. It indicates that the EDL capacitances depend not on the
surface areas of the electrodes estimated by the gas adsorption
techniques but on the relative difference between pore sizes and
the ionic sizes in the electrolytes. In general, it is true that the
electrodes with higher surface areas tend to exhibit the higher
EDL capacitances, and this is why the activated carbons are
mostly used as the electrodes for EDL capacitors.
12-14
In
addition, many researchers have discussed the EDL capaci-
tances in relation to the estimated surface area, i.e., BET surface
area, of the activated carbon electrodes. However, in some
cases, the increase in the estimated surface area does not lead to
the increase of the EDL capacitances because of the pore size
effects.
15-17
The design of the desired pore size in the
electrodes is therefore highly important in order to develop the
superior EDL capacitors. From this motivation, the relation
between pore size and ionic size and the effects on the EDL
capacitances have been energetically studied in the past
decade.
15-25
In most of the studies, the electrodes of EDL
capacitors were prepared as the composite electrodes of the
activated carbons which are in powder form, and the
relationships between the pore properties of the activated
carbon powders and the EDL capacitances were discussed.
However, the composite electrodes are prepared from the
mixture (slurry) of activated carbons, conductive agent such as
acetylene black, and binders which are typically polymers such
as poly(vinylidene difluoride) (PVdF) and polytetrafluoro-
ethylene (PTFE). This means that the pores of the activated
carbons are possibly covered and filled with the conductive
agent and the polymer binders, which prevents the precise
investigation of the effects of the pore properties on the EDL
capacitance.
Monolithic electrodes
26-29
are promising candidates as the
substitute for the conventional composite electrodes. Since a
monolithic material is binder-free and can be used for the
electrode without any additional processes, it is possible to
exploit the completely clear surface for the formation of EDL. It
is therefore expected that the direct information on the effects
of the pore properties of the electrode on the EDL capacitance
Received: September 11, 2012
Revised: December 3, 2012
Published: December 4, 2012
Article
pubs.acs.org/JPCC
© 2012 American Chemical Society 26197 dx.doi.org/10.1021/jp309010p | J. Phys. Chem. C 2012, 116, 26197-26203