30 Letters in Drug Design & Discovery, 2004, 1, 30-34
1570-1808/04 $45.00+.00 © 2004 Bentham Science Publishers Ltd.
Molecular Modeling, Synthesis And Biological Evaluation of Heterocyclic
Hydroxamic Acids Designed as Helicobacter Pylori Urease Inhibitors
E.M.F. Muri, H. Mishra, S.M. Stein and J.S. Williamson
*
Department of Medicinal Chemistry, University of Mississippi, University, MS 38677,USA
Received August 29, 2003: Accepted October 21, 2003
Abstract: A computer-generated homology model of the antimicrobial target
Helicobacter pylori urease was derived, using the x-ray crystal structure of Klebsiella
aerogenes as a template, in order to design novel urease inhibitors. Based on these
computational studies, several heterocyclic hydroxamic acid derivatives have been
designed, synthesized, and examined for their ability to inhibit urease activity.
Keywords: Helicobacter pylori, antimicrobial, urease, hydroxamic acids.
INTRODUCTION
Almost 90% of the human population is believed
infected with the spiral-shaped, Gram-negative bacterium
Helicobacter pylori (H. pylori), making it one of the most
infectious agents known [1]. After numerous studies on the
pathogenic role of this bacterium, it is now widely accepted
that H. pylori is a major causative factor in peptic ulcer
diseases [2]. Antibiotic eradication therapies in the clinic
have been shown to heal gastritis, provide a cure for many
patients suffering from peptic ulcers, and even generate a
remission of MALT carcinomas. While the majority of H.
pylori infections can be controlled by currently available
antibiotic therapies [3], antibiotic resistant strains of the
microorganism are becoming frequent [4]. Infection of the
human gastrointestinal tract, specifically the mucous lining
of the stomach, by H. pylori requires that the microorganism
neutralize or adapt to the otherwise lethally acidic
environment. H. pylori utilizes its own metabolism of urea
to ammonia by the enzyme urease to counteract the harsh
acidic acid environment of the stomach. By analogy,
inhibition of this urea to ammonia catalysis should halt this
vital neutralization mechanism [5]. Molecules designed to
specifically target and inhibit the H. pylori urease offer the
potential of effective and selective chemotherapies.
In general, ureases are inhibited by a variety of agents
including fluorides [6], thiols [7,8] and hydroxamic acids
[9,10]. Several mono-amino acid and dipetide derivatives
containing hydroxamic acid moieties have been synthesized
and found to be potent and specific inhibitors of H. pylori
urease [11]. In order to explore the structural parameters
associated with these hydroxamic acid inhibitors, we
developed a homology model using the urease crystal
structure from Klebsiella aerogenes [12] (EC 3.3.1.5) as a
template, which we have reported earlier [13]. Through the
utilization of computational design we have now synthesized
a series of heterocyclic hydroxamic acid derivatives. In
addition, we have made an initial determination of the effect
of these derivatives on urease activity using jack bean urease
inhibitor assay.
*Address correspondence to this author at the Department of Medicinal
Chemistry, University of Mississippi, University MS 38677, USA; Email:
mcjsw@olemiss.edu
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Acetohydroxamic acid was docked into the active pocket
of this homology-modeled urease and the most probable
configuration of the enzyme-inhibitor complex was assessed
by molecular dynamics studies. Comparative Molecular
Field Analysis (CoMFA) was then carried out on a variety
of dipeptide hydroxamic acid derivatives. Our CoMFA
model included 24 dipeptide hydroxamic acid derivatives,
using the conformation of structural ligands based on the
acetohydroxamic-enzyme complex as obtained through
homology modeling, docking and finally molecular
dynamics. The predictive value of the model was evaluated
and verified using a test set that was not included in the
original model development. Overlapping the contour maps
derived from the CoMFA model with the amino acids
associated with the enzyme active pocket resulted in a model
that provide an initial conceptualization and understanding
of the steric and electrostatic requirements for ligand binding
to and inhibition of H. pylori urease [13]. Figures 1-2
illustrate the alignment of dipeptide hydroxamic acid dataset
as well as the electrostatic and steric maps used in the design
of our heterocyclic hydroxamic acid derivatives [13]. Based
on these results, we designed and synthesized a series of
heterocyclic hydroxamic acid derivatives. Possessing the
required pharmacophore groups necessary to increase
selective urease binding stability in addition to binding
selectivity, as a hydroxamic acid and ionizable amine
moieties, the structural design was directed at the synthesis
of potential hydroxamic acid inhibitors that are likely to
exhibit increased biological stability as compared with the
dipeptide and amino acid derivatives [14].
Scheme 1 shows the preparation of the imidazole
hydroxamic acid derivatives 7a-b, where the commercially
available imidazole (1) was initially nitrated to yield the
4(5)-nitro-1H -imidazole (2 ) [15]. Alkylation of 2 in the
presence of base has been reported to yield predominantly
the 1,4-disubstituted isomer [16]. The esters 3a-b were
obtained by alkylation with the respective alkylating agent
in the presence of K
2
CO
3
and TBAI as a phase-transfer
catalyst [17]. The next step was the catalytic reduction of the
nitro-ester compounds 3a-b yielding the unstable 4-amino-
imidazoles 4a-b, which were directly protected with a tert-