Refining the relationship between
ingroup identification and identity
management strategies in the sport
context: The moderating role of
gender and the mediating role of
negative mood
Iouri Bernache-Assollant,
1
Raphaël Laurin,
2
Patrick Bouchet,
2
Guillaume Bodet,
3
and
Marie-Françoise Lacassagne
2
Abstract
The aim of this exploratory research was to refine the relationship between ingroup identification
and three classical identity-management strategies: individual mobility, social competition and social
creativity. More specifically, in the particular context of sport spectators’ reactions to their team loss,
we tested the moderating role of gender in differentiating the use of CORFing (distancing) strategy
and the mediating role of negative mood in differentiating the use of social competition and social
creativity strategies. To this end, 173 French physical education students were asked to watch an edited
video clip about a defeat of the French national rugby union team. As expected, and consistent with
past research, results first showed that the amount of team identification is a reliable determinant of
the participants’ choice of an identity management strategy. Highly identified spectators were more
associated with engaging themselves in ingroup-protective behaviors (i.e., blasting and boosting) than
spectators low in team identification who, in contrast, privileged distancing strategies (i.e., CORFing).
Moreover, results revealed that participant’s gender moderates the link between ingroup identification
and CORFing strategy, and that negative mood mediates the ingroup identification–blasting strategy
relationship. Theoretical implications of these moderating and mediating effects are then discussed.
1
University of Franche-Comté
2
University of Bourgogne
3
University of Loughborough
Corresponding author:
Iouri Bernache-Assollant, PhD., Université de Franche-
Comté, Laboratoire de Psychologie, Besançon (EA 3188) 55,
faubourg des Ancêtres, F-9000 Belfort, France.
[email: iouri.bernache-assollant@univ-fcomte.fr]
Article
Group Processes & Intergroup Relations
1–14
© The Author(s) 2010
Reprints and permission: http://www.
sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermission.nav
DOI: 10.1177/1368430210369680
gpir.sagepub.com
G
P
I
R
Group Processes &
Intergroup Relations
Keywords
gender, identity management strategy, ingroup
identification, negative mood, social identity
approach, sport spectators
Paper received 25 June 2009; revised version
accepted 4 March 2010.
Group Processes Intergroup Relations OnlineFirst, published on July 30, 2010 as doi:10.1177/1368430210369680