Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice
2016, Vol. 32(3) 196–204
© The Author(s) 2016
Reprints and permissions:
sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/1043986216656672
ccj.sagepub.com
Introduction
Crime and Punishment
in Asia
Narayanan Ganapathy
1
and Lavanya Balachandran
1
Abstract
The dominance of Western models of crime and criminal justice and the
nascent emergence of “borderless” criminological insights precipitated by forces
of globalization and transnationalization raises serious questions about their
universal applicability to explain crime across time and space. Amidst the dearth of
criminological work on Asia, this introduction to the Special Issue on “Crime and
Punishment in Asia” commits itself to developing and honing the frontiers of an
“Asian criminology” by drawing scholarly attention to the empirical and contextual
specificities of the region. Such an effort is not directed towards demarcating “Asia”
as a socially and culturally distinct geopolitical entity from the “West”. Rather, it is
to critically reflect upon the alleged and actual variances between Asian and Western
societies including the broader differences in social orientation – collectivism vs
individualism and duty-based moral obligations vs rights-based beliefs respectively
as well as documenting the heterogeneity and particularities within Asia. To that
end, crime in South Asian and Southeast Asian contexts and political and economic
changes which have given rise to novel “strains” of crime and newer criminal
opportunities, remain under theorized. Ultimately, the advancement of an Asian
criminological discourse in this special issue is not to merely acknowledge scholarly
attempts that transpose current Anglo-Saxon models onto Asian empirical contexts
or reject them, but transform existing theories and develop regional alternatives
that are validated by and arise from particular empirical investigations into crime and
criminal justice across Asia.
Keywords
crime, process, punishment, criminological theories, Asia
1
National University of Singapore, Singapore
Corresponding Author:
Narayanan Ganapathy, Department of Sociology, National University of Singapore, AS1 11 Arts Link,
04-22, 117570, Singapore.
Email: socng@nus.edu.sg
656672CCJ XX X 10.1177/1043986216656672Journal of Contemporary Criminal JusticeGanapathy and Balachandran
research-article 2016
at NATIONAL UNIV SINGAPORE on September 19, 2016 ccj.sagepub.com Downloaded from