Breast Cancer Research and Treatment 83: 201–210, 2004.
© 2004 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
Report
Energy balance in early breast cancer patients receiving
adjuvant chemotherapy
Michelle N. Harvie
1
, I.T. Campbell
2
, A. Baildam
3
, and A. Howell
1
1
University Department of Medical Oncology,
2
University Department of Anaesthesia,
3
University Department of
Surgery, South Manchester University Hospitals NHS Trust, Manchester, UK
Key words: adjuvant chemotherapy, breast cancer, central fat, resting energy expenditure, weight gain
Summary
Weight gain is a common problem amongst women receiving adjuvant chemotherapyfor early breast cancer. We
undertook a study to determine the causes of this weight gain. Prospective measurements of body mass and compo-
sition (skinfolds, bioelectrical impedance, total body potassium), energy balance (resting energy expenditure
dietary intake, and physical activity), were determined in 17 women during and in the 6 months after com-
mencing adjuvant chemotherapy. Women gained significant amounts of weight (5.0 ± 3.8; p< 0.01) and body
fat (7.1 kg ± 4.5; p< 0.01) over the year. Waist circumference (5.1 ± 4.5 cm; p< 0.01) and abdominal skinfold
(16.2 ± 10 mm; p< 0.01) were also increased but there was a decline in fat free mass (FFM); 1.7 ± 2.5 kg. Women
due to receive adjuvant chemotherapy had a greater resting energy expenditure (REE) compared with healthy sub-
jects (n = 21); 100.5 ± 8.0% Harris Benedict compared to 94.5 ± 8.4% Harris Benedict (p = 0.05). REE declined
by 3% during adjuvant chemotherapy (p< 0.05), and remained depressed until at least 3 months posttreatment.
There were no significant changes in dietary intake or physical activity over the year. Failure of women to reduce
their energy intake to compensate for the decreased energy requirement may account for some of the weight gain.
Treatment of adjuvant chemotherapy causes gain of body fat because of reduced energy expenditure, and the failure
of women to reduce their energy intake to compensate for the decline in energy requirement during and in the 6
months posttreatment. Since weight gain impacts on survival, patients should be counselled to reduce energy intake
and exercise during and after adjuvant treatment.
Introduction
Weight gain is a well-established side effect amongst
women receiving adjuvant chemotherapy, which is as-
sociated with reduced survival [1, 2]. Generally weight
gain is due to an imbalance of energy intake and
energy expenditure but the reasons for the positive en-
ergy balance during and after adjuvant chemotherapy
have not been firmly established.
Three recent studies [3–5] measured components
of energy balance (body weight, food intake and rest-
ing energy expenditure) during chemotherapy for early
breast cancer but the findings were inconsistent. Over
the course of chemotherapy REE was reported to be
increased [4], decreased [3] or unchanged [5]. Energy
intake was reported to be decreased [3] or unchanged
[4, 5] while physical activity was unchanged [4] or
decreased [3, 5]. Interpretation of these studies is
limited by the fact that patients did not put on the
previously reported large amounts of weight, raising
the possibility that intense metabolic monitoring dur-
ing the studies may have affected normal behaviour
and limited weight gain. Since gain also occurs in the
6 months after completion of chemotherapy, there is
also a need to study energy balance in this period as
well as during treatment.
In order to determine the reasons for weight
gain we studied changes in body composition and
energy balance (REE, physical activity, energy in-
take) during chemotherapy, and in the 6 months
after chemotherapy, in patients receiving adjuvant
treatment. A parallel group of controls about to