Isomers and Conformers of H(NH
2
BH
2
)
n
H Oligomers: Understanding the Geometries and
Electronic Structure of Boron-Nitrogen-Hydrogen Compounds as Potential Hydrogen
Storage Materials
Jun Li,*
,²
Shawn M. Kathmann,
‡
Gregory K. Schenter,
‡
and Maciej Gutowski*
,‡,§,⊥
W. R. Wiley EnVironmental Molecular Sciences Laboratory, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Richland,
Washington 99352, Chemical Sciences DiVision, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Richland, Washington
99352, Chemistry-School of Engineering and Physical Sciences, Heriot-Watt UniVersity, Edinburgh EH14 4AS,
United Kingdom, and Department of Chemistry, UniVersity of Gdan ´ sk, 80-952 Gdan ´ sk, Poland
ReceiVed: September 27, 2006; In Final Form: December 23, 2006
Boron-nitrogen-hydrogen (BNH
x
) materials are polar analogues of hydrocarbons with potential applications
as media for hydrogen storage. As H(NH
2
BH
2
)
n
H oligomers result from dehydrogenation of NH
3
BH
3
and
NH
4
BH
4
materials, understanding the geometries, stabilities, and electronic structure of these oligomers is
essential for developing chemical methods of hydrogen release and regeneration of the BNH
x
-based hydrogen
storage materials. In this work we have performed computational modeling on the H(NH
2
BH
2
)
n
H(n ) 1-6)
oligomers using density functional theory (DFT). We have investigated linear chain structures and the stabilizing
effects of coiling, biradicalization, and branching through Car-Parrinello molecular dynamics simulations
and subsequent geometry optimizations. We find that the zigzag linear oligomers are unstable with respect to
the coiled, square-wave chain, and branched structures, with the coiled structures being the most stable.
Dihydrogen bonding in oligomers, where protic H
δ+
(N) hydrogens interact with hydridic H
δ-
(B) hydrogens,
plays a crucial role in stabilizing different isomers and conformers. The results are consistent with structures
of products that are seen in experimental NMR studies of dehydrogenated ammonia borane.
Introduction
On-board hydrogen storage (HS) is one of the major tech-
nological bottlenecks in developing a hydrogen economy.
1-4
Boron-nitrogen-hydrogen (BNH
x
) materials such as ammonia
borane, NH
3
BH
3
, are potentially important candidates for
chemical hydrogen storage because of their high gravimetric
and volumetric densities of hydrogen.
5-11
One of the key
challenges in investigating BNH
x
is to understand the geometric
and electronic factors that govern the stabilities, reactivities, and
inter- and intramolecular interactions. Computational modeling
is uniquely suited to provide a molecular-level understanding
of the electronic structure and stabilities of these materials.
There are many theoretical studies of the gas-phase geometry
and electronic structure of the NH
3
BH
3
(n ) 1) monomer, which
is known to have a staggered structure as the most stable
conformation.
12-15
Due to Pauli exchange repulsion, the eclipsed
gas-phase conformer has a slightly longer B-N distance (∼0.03
Å) and is energetically higher in energy, by a few kilocalories/
mole. From our PW91 calculation, the rotation barrier from the
staggered to the eclipsed conformation is 1.94 kcal/mol, in
excellent agreement with the experimental value of 2.07 kcal/
mol.
16
The H(NH
2
BH
2
)
n
H oligomers (n g 2), which are products
of n consecutive dehydrocoupling reactions involving NH
3
BH
3
molecules, are good starting points for understanding the
structures and stabilities of the partially dehydrogenated material.
There are theoretical calculations on infinite polyaminoborane
(NH
2
BH
2
)
∞
polymers,
17,18
but little is understood of the
structures and the stabilities of the finite BNH
x
oligomers. The
only previous theoretical effort to understand the electronic
structure of these oligomers is a recent study on the properties
of four types of selected linear chain structures.
19
It is not clear
if these structures are the most stable or if other nonchain
structures are stable as well. Therefore, an in-depth theoretical
investigation is necessary to explore the geometries, stabilities,
and electronic structure of these oligomers.
Because of significant differences in the electronegativities
and the number of valence electrons in B and N, the -BH
2
and
-NH
2
groups are electron-deficient and electron-rich, respec-
tively. As a result, the H(NH
2
BH
2
)
n
H oligomers, with the Lewis
structures of H-(H
2
Br:NH
2
)
n
-H, have large dipole moments if
they adopt linear chain configurations. These configurations
would become less stable as the oligomer chains grow longer
because the dipole moment increases as n increases. Isomer-
ization, conformational changes, and ground-state spin crossing
of the oligomers are possible pathways to transform linear chain
oligomers into more stable species with smaller dipole moments.
Here we report a computational investigation of the oligo-
meric molecules H(NH
2
BH
2
)
n
H(n ) 1-6) using DFT methods
with Slater-type and planewave basis sets. In particular, we
investigate the stabilities of oligomers with respect to confor-
mational and isomeric degrees of freedom. In addition to coiling
and branching, we also consider biradicalization via electron
transfer from the negative to the positive charge end of the
closed-shell H(NH
2
BH
2
)
n
H molecule. We probe the energetics
of this pathway via the singlet-triplet energy splitting. We will
show that the oligomers energetically prefer coiled structures,
* Corresponding authors. E-mail: m.gutowski@hw.ac.uk and jun.
li@pnl.gov.
²
W. R. Wiley Environmental Molecular Sciences Laboratory, Pacific
Northwest National Laboratory.
‡
Chemical Sciences Division, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory.
§
Heriot-Watt University.
⊥
University of Gdan ´sk.
3294 J. Phys. Chem. C 2007, 111, 3294-3299
10.1021/jp066360b CCC: $37.00 © 2007 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 02/07/2007