Blind Modulation Identification for MIMO Systems
K. Hassan, C. Nsiala Nzéza, M. Berbineau
Univ Lille Nord de France, F-59000 Lille,
INRETS, LEOST, F-59650 Villeneuve d’Ascq
kais.hassan@inrets.fr
W. Hamouda
Concordia University, Montreal,
Quebec, H3G 1M8, Canada
hamouda@ece.concordia.ca
I. Dayoub
Univ Lille Nord de France, F-59000 Lille,
IEMN, DOAE, F-59313 Valenciennes
Iyad.dayoub@univ-valenciennes.fr
Abstract—Modulation type is one of the most important
characteristics used in signal waveform identification and classi-
fication. In this paper, an algorithm for blind digital modulation
identification for multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) systems
is proposed. The suggested algorithm is verified using higher
order statistical moments and cumulants of the received signal.
A multi-layer neural network trained with resilient backpropa-
gation learning algorithm is proposed as a classifier. The purpose
is to discriminate among different M-ary shift keying linear
modulation types and the modulation order without any priori
signal information. This study covers different MIMO systems
with and without channel state information (CSI). The proposed
classifier is evaluated through the probability of identification
where we show that our proposed algorithm is capable of
identifying the modulation scheme with high accuracy in excellent
signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) range.
Index Terms—Higher order statistics, multiple-input multiple-
output, modulation identification, neural networks, spatial mul-
tiplexing, space-time block coding.
I. I NTRODUCTION
Over the last decade Multiple-Input Multiple-Output
(MIMO) systems have shown a great importance as they
provide a reliable and high-data-rate wireless communica-
tions. Nowadays, MIMO is considered one of the promising
technologies for developing the next generation of wireless
systems. Recently, blind algorithms and techniques for MIMO
signals interception have gained more attention. One essential
step in the signal interception process is to blindly identify the
modulation scheme of MIMO signals.
Modulation identification has its roots in military ap-
plications such as; communication intelligence (COMINT),
electronic support measures (ESM), spectrum surveillance,
threat evaluation and interference identification. Also recent
and rapid developments in software defined radio (SDR) in
the context of cognitive radio (CR) have given modulation
identification more prominence in civil applications.
Many modulation identification algorithms have been devel-
oped for Single-Input Single-Output (SISO) systems [1]. These
algorithms are generally divided into two categories. The first
category is based on decision theoretic approach while the
second on pattern recognition. The decision theoretic approach
is a probabilistic solution based on a priori knowledge of
probability functions and certain hypotheses [2], [3]. On the
other hand, the pattern recognition approach is based on
extracting some basic characteristics of the received signal
called features [4]–[10]. This approach is generally divided
into two subsystems: the features extraction subsystem and the
classifier subsystem. However, the second approach is more
robust and easier to implement if the proper features set is
chosen.
In the past, much work has been conducted on modulation
identification [4]–[10]. The identification techniques, which
have been employed to extract the signal features necessary
for digital modulation identification, include spectral based
features set [4], [5], higher order statistics (HOS) [6], [7],
constellation shape [8], and wavelets transforms [9], [10]. With
their efficient performance in pattern recognition problems
(e.g., modulation classification), many studies have proposed
the application of artificial neural networks (ANNs) as classi-
fiers [5], [10].
In [11], Swami et. al proposed a simple yet very low
complexity method, based on elementary fourth-order cumu-
lants for the classification of digital modulation schemes.
The robustness of this approach comes about not only from
the resistance of HOS to additive colored Gaussian noise,
but also from a natural robustness to constellation rotation
and phase jitter. Also additive non-Gaussian noise can be
handled if its fourth-order cumulants are known, or via simple
preprocessing.
So far, few researches have considered the application of
modulation identification techniques in MIMO systems. For
instance, Choqueuse et. al [12] adopted a maximum likelihood
approach for the blind recognition of the modulation for
MIMO systems using spatial multiplexing (SM). In their work
the authors proposed two Likelihood based classifiers. The first
one, called Average Likelihood Ratio Tests (ALRT), is optimal
in the Bayesian sense but requires the knowledge of the chan-
nel matrix. The second classifier, called Hybrid Likelihood
Ratio Tests (HLRT), approximates the ALRT by replacing the
channel matrix with its estimate. The major drawbacks of these
methods are the high computational complexity and its need
of perfect knowledge of the noise variance at the receiver side.
In this paper we introduce a pattern recognition approach for
modulation identification in MIMO systems. In our approach,
the features extraction subsystem is based on the higher order
cumulants (HOC) and the higher order moments (HOM) of
the received signal. Our proposed classifier is a multi-layer
artificial neural network trained using the resilient backpropa-
gation learning algorithm (RPROP). Modulation identification
is performed without any priori information of the received
signal (e.g. probability functions, noise statistics, etc.). Then,
our proposed algorithm is considered as semi-blind when
978-1-4244-5637-6/10/$26.00 ©2010 IEEE
This full text paper was peer reviewed at the direction of IEEE Communications Society subject matter experts for publication in the IEEE Globecom 2010 proceedings.