American Journal of Plant Sciences, 2012, 3, 346-352
doi:10.4236/ajps.2012.33041 Published Online March 2012 (http://www.SciRP.org/journal/ajps)
The Effect of Herbicides on the Egyptian Broomrape
(Orobanche aegyptiaca) in Tomato Fields
Ibrahim Ghannam, Mohammad Al-Masri, Radwan Barakat
*
Faculty of Agriculture, Hebron University, Hebron, Palestine.
Email:
*
radwanb@hebron.edu
Received June 16
th
, 2011; revised August 20
th
, 2011; accepted November 3
rd
, 2011
ABSTRACT
The Egyptian broomrape (Orobanche aegyptiaca Pers.) is an obligate holoparasitic weed that causes severe damage to
many important vegetable and field crops. In this investigation, three herbicides; chlorsulfuron, triasulfuron and ima-
zaquin were tested to evaluate their efficiency in controlling the tomato broomrape. The herbicides significantly re-
duced the broomrape parasitizing tomato plants growing in pots, irrigated open field and under greenhouse conditions
as foliar spray at the concentrations (0.5 - 10 µg·ml
−1
) without visible injury effect on the plants. In the pot experiments,
triasulfuron increased the dead spikes from 77% to 84%; chlorsulfuron from 51% to 84% and imazaquin from 52% to
84% at the concentrations (0.5 - 5 µg·ml
−1
) compared with the control. In the irrigated open field experiment, the herbi-
cides were less efficient in controlling the broomrape. The dead spikes increased from 10.5% to 29.1% at the concentra-
tions (1 - 5 µg·ml
−1
) compared with the control. In the greenhouse experiment, the herbicides were more effective than
open field and the dead spikes were increased from 30 to 68% at the concentrations 5 and 10 µg·ml
−1
. In conclusion, the
foliar application of herbicides were able to increase the broomrape dead spikes attached to the tomato plants at the
concentrations (3 - 5 µg·ml
−1
) without visible negative effect on tomato plants.
Keywords: Orobanche aegyptiaca; Chlorsulfuron; Triasulfuron; Imazaquin; Broomrape and Tomato
1. Introduction
The broomrape (Orobanche spp.) are obligate holopara-
sitic weeds that cause severe damage to the most impor-
tant vegetable and field crops in the Mediterranean re-
gion and the Middle East [1]. Annual food crop losses
due to broomrape infestation are estimated at about $1.3
to 2.6 billion. Egyptian broomrape (O. aegyptiaca) to-
gether with branched broomrape (O. ramosa) infests
about 2.6 million ha of solanaceous crops mainly in the
Mediterranean area, North Africa, and Asia [2-4]. In Pal-
estine, broomrape is listed as one of the most harmful
weeds and poses a major constraint to crop production.
The control of broomrapes is often difficult for various
reasons and numerous control strategies have been tested
over the years, with limited effectiveness. The control
methods investigated have included changes in agricul-
tural practices such as hand weeding, tillage, deep inver-
sion, crop rotation, trap and catch crops, fertilization and
soil solarization [1,5-8] as well as chemical and biologi-
cal means [3,9-20]. The chemical control of broomrapes
included soil fumigation and herbicide application. Soil
fumigation with methyl bromide effectively controlled
broomrape [18]. Several herbicides were used to control
broomrape, but selectivity to the host plant remained the
main obstacle. Chlorsulfuron applied at 5 g·a.i·h
−1
gave
100% control of emerged broomrape shoots and under-
ground attachments and completely prevent parasite de-
velopment in tomato [21]. The herbicides rimsulfuron
and sulfonylurea effectively controlled O. aegyptiaca in
pots, but in drip-irrigated tomatoes fields, O. aegyptiaca
control was poor [11]. The best results for Orobanche
control in potato was obtained by applications of rimsul-
furon at 12.5 g·a.i·h
−1
followed by three sequential foliar
applications of glyphosate at 100 g·a.i·h
−1
[17]. Split ap-
plication of low rates of imazamethapyr applied on toma-
to foliage or chemigated via sprinkler irrigation achieved
excellent O. aegyptiaca control throughout the growing
season, but caused premature loss of flowers and early
ripening of fruits [20].
During the last few decades, the herbicidal groups
showed promising results in broomrape control; sulfony-
lurea, imidazolinone, and other inhibitors of the enzyme
acetolactate synthase (ALS) or acytohydroxy acid syn-
thase (AHAS) are some examples. Members of these
groups showed some degree of selectivity to broomrape
host plants [3,10,14-16]. Chlorsulfuron, pronamide and
*
Corresponding author.
Copyright © 2012 SciRes. AJPS