47 VOL. 75, NO. 1, SPRING 2016
Human Organization, Vol. 75, No. 1, 2016
Copyright © 2016 by the Society for Applied Anthropology
0018-7259/16/010047-12$1.70/1
“Do you want to see the mine,” asks Harlan? Of course, I
reply. Harlan fetches his boots. Joined by his wife, Edith, we
walk across a farm ield, our trajectory curving slightly with
rows of ledgling Roundup Ready soybeans. At the end of the
ield, we push through several feet of brush before reaching a
ridge that overlooks the open-pit mine. Harlan deiantly hikes
past the thin wooden stakes marking his property line. He
climbs to the edge of the pit, striking the pose of a seventy-
something mountaineer who has just conquered an imposing
summit. I join him but do not ascend as high. Edith remains
a few feet behind as we peer deep into the mine.
We look out at what had once been farmland worked by
their family for generations. For over thirty years, Harlan and
Edith had operated a successful dairy operation with around
forty cows, small and increasingly uncompetitive by today’s
standards. In thirty years, they left their farm for only one
night so that Harlan could stand in a friend’s wedding. They
nurtured their animals and their land with a combination of
hard work and love. “We took care of the cows and the cows
took care of us,” Harlan explains. Nearing retirement in the
Thomas Pearson is Associate Professor of Anthropology at the University
of Wisconsin-Stout. He is currently writing a book about frac sand min-
ing, tentatively titled When the Hills Are Gone: Frac Sand Mining and the
Struggle for Place, Community, and Democracy, and under contract with
the University of Minnesota Press. A Faculty Research Initiative grant
from UW-Stout provided inancial support for the research discussed in
this article. The author wishes to acknowledge Daniel Renfrew, Barbara
Flom, and Stephanie Hintz for providing valuable feedback and support.
Frac Sand Mining and the Disruption of Place,
Landscape, and Community in Wisconsin
Thomas W. Pearson
Driven by hydraulic fracturing, sand mining has expanded rapidly in western Wisconsin, with hundreds of mining operations appearing
over the past several years. Silica sand is extracted from hills and then shipped by rail around the country, where it is pumped under high
pressure with water and chemicals into oil and gas wells. An often overlooked dimension of America’s unconventional energy boom,
the growth of sand mining in Wisconsin has been incredibly divisive, generating wealth for some lucky landowners while creating
new environmental hazards for others. This article documents how people experience mining-related changes and conlicts, drawing
on ethnographic interviews with residents living next to mines, processing plants, and hauling routes. While not everyone experiences
mining equally, I argue that people grappling with a sudden inlux of mining activity suffer signiicant disruptions that erode their sense
of place and belonging. These experiences, however, are rarely taken into account by policymakers, local oficials, or others seeking
to evaluate the costs and beneits of frac sand mining. This omission underscores the need for ethnographic research to deepen our
understanding of how people are impacted by new resource extraction industries.
Key words: natural resource extraction, unconventional energy, social trauma, environment, place
early 2000s, they sold part of their land, along with their
original home and farm buildings, to an aspiring farmer and
then built a new house on their remaining property up the
hill. Ten years later, however, the neighbor was presented
with an offer he couldn’t refuse: an out-of-state investment
irm wanted to purchase the land at six times the going rate
to harvest sand from the property. He sold, signed a nondis-
closure agreement, and retired out of state. The town lacked
zoning and, at that time, regulatory ordinances addressing
mining, and few knew that multiple mining interests were
buying up land in the community.
Now the land is gone, swallowed by a massive hole in
the ground. We watch as a solitary construction excavator sits
amid a sea of sand, patiently waiting for a dump truck to ap-
proach. The truck will haul the sand to a processing plant and
then to rail cars. One truckload at a time, sandstone bedrock
fashioned by hundreds of millions of years of geological pro-
cesses will be shipped to oil and gas wells around the country
and then forcefully injected back into the earth. Innovations
in oil and gas production known as hydraulic fracturing, or
fracking, have spurred unconventional drilling in several parts
of the country. The surge in oil and gas drilling, however,
has also fueled an unprecedented growth of sand mining in
Wisconsin. Mining companies extract a special type of silica
sand unique to western Wisconsin, ship massive quantities of
this so-called frac sand around the country, and then pump
truckloads of it, along with water and other chemicals, into
oil or gas wells. Deep underground, the granules prop open
splintered shale bedrock, releasing valuable hydrocarbons.