238 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. 44, NO. 1, JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2008
Multicell High-Current Rectifier
Eduardo P. Wiechmann, Senior Member, IEEE, Pablo Aqueveque, Student Member, IEEE, An´ ıbal S. Morales,
Pablo F. Acu˜ na, and Rolando Burgos, Member, IEEE
Abstract—A multicell rectifier (MC) structure with N + 2 re-
dundancy is presented. The topology is based on power cells im-
plemented with the integrated gate commuted thyristors (IGCTs)
to challenge the SCR standard industry solution for the past
35 years. This rectifier is a reliable, compact, efficient, nonpolluting
alternative and cost-effective solution for electrolytic applications.
Its structure, based on power cells, enables load shedding to en-
sure power delivery even in the event of power cell failures. It
injects quasi-sinusoidal input currents and provides unity power
factor without the use of passive or active filters. A complete eval-
uation based on IEEE standards 493-1997 and IEEE C57.18.10
for average downtime, failures rates, and efficiency is included.
For comparison purposes, results are shown against conventional
systems known for their high efficiency and reliability.
Index Terms—Electrorefining, electrowinning, high-current
rectifiers.
I. INTRODUCTION
T
HE COPPER ELECTROWINNING (EW) and electrore-
fining (ER) metallurgical processes use high-current recti-
fiers to produce electrolysis. These converters are implemented
using thyristor (SCR) phase-controlled rectifiers that feature
high efficiency and reliability, and as such, have become the
preferred choice for the mining industry. These converters have
continuously improved their performance thanks to the signifi-
cant advancements on thyristor technology, presenting a mini-
mum conduction voltage drop of 1.3 V for EW and ER applica-
tions rated 40 kA (and 300 V dc) [1]. Harmonic distortion, on
the other hand, is usually addressed by paralleling 12-pulse con-
verter structures. The four-star (FS) and double-bridge rectifiers
with interphase reactors (DB) are the configurations of choice
in the mining industry [2]. Both topologies present an intrinsic
high reliability due to their parallel configurations and the use
of thyristors. These rectifiers inject very low current distortion
into the system throughout their operational range. Despite this
low distortion injection, they consume high reactive power. For
Paper PID-07-03, presented at the 2006 IEEE Industry Applications Society
Annual Meeting, Tampa, FL, October 8–12, and approved for publication in
the IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS by the Mining Industry
Committee of the IEEE Industry Applications Society. Manuscript submitted
for review October 31, 2006 and released for publication August 19, 2007.
This work was supported by the Chilean Fund for Science and Technology
Development (CONICYT) under Project 1060902. This work made use of
the Engineering Research Center Shared Facilities supported by the National
Science Foundation under NSF Award EEC-9731677 and the CPES Industry
Partnership Program.
E. P. Wiechmann, P. E. Aqueveque, A. Morales, and P. Acu˜ na are
with the Department of Electrical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Uni-
versity of Concepci´ on, Concepci´ on, Chile (e-mail: wiechmann@ieee.org;
pablo.aqueveque@ieee.org; animorales@udec.cl; pabloacuna@udec.cl).
R. Burgos is with the Center for Power Electronics Systems, Department of
Electrical and Computer Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State
University, Blacksburg, VA 24061 USA (e-mail: rolando@vt.edu).
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TIA.2007.912728
example, a single EW rectifier draws up to 4 MVAR at 32 kA.
It is important to point out that an EW plant may use up to
eight rectifiers; hence, the total reactive power consumption of
a plant is a critical factor for the industrial distribution system.
Moreover, EW and ER plants are usually located in remote
areas being fed by relatively weak systems. The preferred so-
lution for the elevated reactive power demand of SCR rectifiers
is the use of sequentially connected tuned passive filters. These
are essential for their operation since, otherwise, voltage reg-
ulation and current increments would significantly impair the
power conversion efficiency. This solution, however, presents a
number of drawbacks, namely the introduction of system res-
onances, which degrade the overall system reliability, and the
need for the large physical space required to install the filters
(5000 ft
2
). These factors negate this solution and open a window
of opportunity for technological breakthroughs in high-current
applications [3]–[6].
From the previous discussion, it may be concluded that a cost-
effective solution should replace phase control, eliminating the
need for reactive power compensation. The elimination of these
filters would additionally simplify industrial maintenance and
increase reliability, since the power system would no longer
suffer from the large transients introduced by the sequential
connection of the tuned-filter stages. System reliability could be
further improved if N + K redundancy is somehow applied to
the power converter structure.
It should be borne in mind that for mining applications, any
equipment failure related to the high-current rectifier results in
very high revenue losses, as the rectifier controls the electrol-
ysis itself and the production of copper. Moreover, the remote
location of mining sites, in general, delays any service or major
maintenance required, further aggravating the loss of produc-
tion and revenues. It has been shown that these business factors,
related to the rectifying system reliability, are, by far, more
important than any initial investment cost on the rectifiers [14].
Generally, the evaluation of high-current rectifiers has been
based on power factor and harmonic current distortion. How-
ever, industrial experience shows that reliability and efficiency
are more relevant issues. Following this trend, multicell high-
current converters have emerged having the capability to be
designed maximizing their reliability and availability. This type
of converter architecture is compatible with N + K redundancy
and eventually with hot swappability, that is the capability to
replace cells for scheduled maintenance or replacement without
stopping the electrolysis and the production of copper. Multicell
rectifiers, therefore, improve availability and reduce possible
downtimes with consequential economic benefits.
This paper proposes a multicell rectifier for EW and ER
applications with N + 2 redundancy based on independent
but paralleled pulse width modulation (PWM) rectifier cells.
0093-9994/$25.00 © 2008 IEEE