DOES AEROBIC AND STRENGTH EXERCISE SEQUENCE
IN THE SAME SESSION AFFECT THE OXYGEN UPTAKE
DURING AND POSTEXERCISE?
JOSE
´
VILACXA ALVES,
1
FRANCISCO SAAVEDRA,
1
ROBERTO SIMA
˜
O,
1,2
JEFFERSON NOVAES,
1,2
MATTHEW R. RHEA,
3
DANIELLE GREEN,
4
AND VICTOR MACHADO REIS
1
1
Research Center for Sport, Health, and Human Development, University of Tra´s-os-Montes and Alto Douro (UTAD), Vila Real,
Portugal;
2
School of Physical Education and Sports, Rio de Janeiro Federal University, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil;
3
RACE Rx
Academy of Exercise Sciences, Logan, Utah; and
4
A.T. Still University Human Movement Program, Mesa, Arizona
ABSTRACT
Vilac xa Alves, J, Saavedra, F, Sima ˜ o, R, Novaes, J, Rhea, MR,
Green, D, and Machado Reis, V. Does aerobic and strength
exercise sequence in the same session affect the oxygen
uptake during and postexercise? J Strength Cond Res 26(7):
1872–1878, 2012—Concurrent training is a strategy employed
in both general fitness and sports conditioning. The purpose of
this study was to compare the responses of
_
VO
2
in different
combinations of strength exercise with aerobic interval exercise.
Eight men (23.6 6 4.2 years, 178 6 6.3 cm, 77 6 7.9 kg,
7.67 6 1.95% body fat) completed 3 combinations of strength
training (ST) and aerobic training (AT) in a randomized order
with a 7-day recovery period: AT before ST exercises, AT
between 2 blocks of ST exercises, and AT after ST exercises.
The ST comprised 4 exercises performed in 3 sets of 10 reps
and 2 exercises, abdominal crunch and lumbar extension,
performed in 3 sets of 30 and 20 reps, respectively. The AT
consisted of a 20-minute interval cycling. There were no
significant differences in the values of absolute or relative
_
VO
2
,
in the heart rate (HR) and in the respiratory exchange ratio
(RER) when the 3 sessions (during + postexercise measure-
ments) were compared (values are mean 6 SD). Analyzing only
ST in each session, differences were detected in the RER
values (F = 4.714; p , 0.05; h
2
= 0.308) between AT before
ST and AT in the middle of ST (1.01 6 0.97 vs. 1.11 6 0.07,
respectively). In all sequences, there was a significant increase
(p , 0.05) in the values of relative and absolute
_
VO
2
and HR,
and a significant decrease in RER values (p , 0.05) from the
first to the second part of the ST session. The values of absolute
or relative
_
VO
2
, HR, and RER did not vary significantly among
the 3 sessions as compared with the AT after ST. These data
support the hypothesis that ST and AT, when performed in
sequence in the same session, do not seem to affect the overall
oxygen consumption during the exercise session. Therefore,
training sessions may incorporate both modalities without
apparent impact on aerobic exercise.
KEY WORDS cardiovascular exercise, resistance exercise,
energy expenditure, concurrent training
INTRODUCTION
T
he acute metabolic demands of strength training
(ST) exercise have been investigated by previous
studies, and their results have shown significantly
larger increases in oxygen uptake (
_
VO
2
) and energy
expenditure (EE), during and after exercise, depending on
variables, such as muscle mass (24), lifting velocities (14),
number of sets (13), number of repetitions (31), workload
(38), training volume (16), rest intervals (31), or exercise
order (7). Similarly, research on the use of aerobic training
(AT) exercise showed increases in exercise
_
VO
2
, which are
concomitant with increases in exercise intensity (26,34) and
are larger when AT is preceded by ST exercise (17).
Additionally, studies have shown that when performing
intermittent aerobic exercise (20,23) and when performing
at high and supramaximal intensities (20,30), a significant
increase in postexercise oxygen consumption (EPOC) is
present.
The combination of AT and ST in the same-session
training is very common in physical fitness training
programs (1) and athletic programs (5,29) because of time
constraints and convenience. However, training including
aerobic and strength exercises performed in a single session,
known in the literature as concurrent training, presents
a specific challenge, especially among different populations
(21). Fatigue generated from one mode of exercise may
negatively influence the quantity and quality of exercise in
the other mode (21).
Few studies have addressed the sequence of ATand ST in
the same session and its influence on
_
VO
2
during (27) and
Address correspondence to Jose ´ Vilac x a Alves, josevilaca@utad.pt.
26(7)/1872–1878
Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research
Ó 2012 National Strength and Conditioning Association
1872 Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research
the TM
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.