A WAVELET-BASED APPROACH FOR THE EXTRACTION OF
EVENT RELATED POTENTIALS FROM EEG
M. Fatourechi
1,2
, S.G. Mason
2
, G.E. Birch
1,2
and R.K. Ward
1
1 Dept. of Electrical & Computer Engineering, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada
2 Neil Squire Foundation, Vancouver, BC, Canada
ABSTRACT
Event Related Potentials (ERPs) are of interest to many
researchers seeking knowledge about the functions of the brain.
ERPs are low-frequency events that are usually obscured in
single trial analysis. To visualize these signals; most of the
reliable solutions at the present time use the ensemble averages
of many single trials. In this paper, a wavelet-based method
called Statistical Coefficient Selection (SCS) is used for the
extraction of ERPs from EEG signals. Unlike other wavelet-
based denoising methods, the current method does not focus on
the wavelet coefficients of the signal itself. Instead, it selects the
coefficients based on the statistical study of trials from training
data set. Simulation results show the superiority of the proposed
SCS method in extracting ERPs in comparison with other
filtering approaches.
1. INTRODUCTION
Event Related Potentials (ERPs) are parts of the EEG signal that
are time-locked to a sensory, motor, or cognitive process and
therefore provide an electrophysiological window onto brain
function during cognition. They have a characteristic pattern that
is more or less reproducible under similar experimental
conditions [1]. The origin of an ERP might be an external
stimulator (for example a flash light) or it can be initiated
internally such as a result of making a movement. In the
literature, two significant applications make use of ERPs:
diagnosing neurological disorders [2] and development of brain-
computer-interface (BCI) systems [3]. For both applications,
many methods that extract ERPs from the background EEG have
been explored. The main problem of ERP extraction is that the
amplitude of an ERP is much smaller than that of the
background EEG. This makes its detection very hard in single
trial analysis. Instead of extraction of ERPs from single trials
many methods have focused on the extraction of ERPs from
ensemble averages of several single trials (i.e. data segments
including the pre- and post-stimulus activity are averaged).
Since ERPs are time locked to the stimulus, it is assumed that
their contribution during the averaging process will add up while
the ongoing EEG and unrelated components are attenuated. This
will result in higher Signal to Noise Ratio (SNR).
Since ERPs are non-stationary, time-invariant approaches
such as Fourier Transform are not likely to give acceptable
results. On the other hand, the joint time–frequency resolution
obtained by the wavelet transform makes it a good candidate for
the extraction of the details as well as the approximations of
time-varying, non-stationary signals [4]. For the effective
extraction of ERPs from the background EEG using wavelet
transform, we need a strategy which 1) chooses the coefficients
associated with the ERP and, 2) considers the fact that ERPs
vary significantly from time to time [5].
Several methods have been proposed for extracting ERPs
from the background EEG with various success. Many
researchers use level-dependant thresholding schemes by
defining a criterion for the selection of the threshold of each
level [6-7]. For example, in [6], the authors apply a level
dependant threshold based on the median absolute deviation of
wavelet coefficients in each level. In [7], the authors report good
noise reduction in ERPs simply by discarding three upper level
bands.
Many researchers manually select the wavelet coefficients
assumed to be associated with an ERP [8-9]. For example in [8],
the authors select Visual Evoked Potentials (VEPs) based on a
single wavelet coefficient in the delta band of the EEG. Also in
some approaches the wavelet coefficients are selected based on a
similarity criterion between the coefficients associated with the
waveform and the coefficients associated with the grand
ensemble average of all the test waveforms [10].
The main problem with the methods that select coefficients
manually is their vulnerability to the human error. These
methods also do not take the time varying property of ERPs into
consideration. On the other hand, methods based on the
threshold selection or a measure of similarity with the grand
ensemble averages cannot filter the coefficients associated with
the background EEG effectively, because many of these
coefficients lie in the same frequency spectrum of ERPs.
Therefore, the proposed selection method should not only
consider the energies of the coefficients which are attributed to
ERPs, but it should also consider their variations throughout the
time.
This paper proposes a new scheme, which selects the
individual coefficients associated with an ERP automatically.
The proposed method attempts to overcome the vulnerabilities
of the previously mentioned methods. To be more specific, in
this method, the wavelet coefficients that are sought have high
amplitude values (the ones with high energy in the case of
orthogonal wavelets) and low amplitude variance over many
trials. In other words, the current method does not focus on the
wavelet coefficients of the signal themselves. Instead, it selects
the coefficients based on the statistical study of training data set.
The organization of the paper is as follows: the focus of
Section 2 is on the wavelet analysis. In Section 3, the proposed
II - 737 0-7803-8484-9/04/$20.00 ©2004 IEEE ICASSP 2004
➠ ➡