Optimal Placement of Access Point in WLAN Based on a New Algorithm
S. Kouhbor, Julien Ugon, Alex Kruger, Alex Rubinov
School of Information Technology and Mathematical Sciences
University of Ballarat, Ballarat, Vic 3353
skouhbor@students.ballarat.edu.au
Abstract
When designing wireless communication systems, it
is very important to know the optimum numbers and
locations for the access points (APs). The impact of
incorrect placement of APs is significant. If they are
placed too far apart, they will generate a coverage
gap, but if they are too close to each other, this will
lead to excessive co-channel interferences. In this
paper we describe a mathematical model developed to
find the optimal number and location of APs. To solve
the problem, we use the Discrete Gradient optimization
algorithm developed at the University of Ballarat.
Results indicate that our model is able to solve optimal
coverage problems for different numbers of users.
1. Introduction
The primary goal of Wireless Local Area Network
(WLAN) deployment is to provide total coverage for
all users in the design area. In other words, how and
where to locate the APs, so that the primary goal of
deployment is satisfied. The location of the APs
determines the standard of coverage of the design area.
Coverage is determined by the number of APs that are
placed in the design area. Placing too many APs
increases the cost of deployment and placing a few will
lead to coverage gaps which prevents users from
having access to their data through APs.
The method used by network operators to find the
placement of AP is based on the RF (radio frequency)
site survey. This involves network designer going
around the facility and measuring the RF signal
strengths at various locations using software running
on a laptop or PDA (Personal Digital Assistant). This
software detects places that are suitable for APs to be
installed based on signal strength, noise levels, and
signal quality. These measurements have to be
repeated many times to ensure reliable results.
However, this method is expensive and its results are
not very reliable due to characteristics of the building
and location of the users that can change with time [1].
Another approach that is used by researchers [1-13]
to find the optimal placement of APs is through the use
of optimization techniques. Most of the authors [1-8]
use discrete mathematical models to find the position
of APs. In this case, the design area is divided into
rectangles (grids). APs are only allowed to be placed in
the centers of the rectangles. To obtain satisfactory
results, the size of the grid must be sufficiently small.
However, in this case, the dimension of the problem
can be very high. For this reason some authors [9-11]
prefer continuous mathematical models. Others [12,13]
have tried to compare their results using both methods.
The model investigated in the current paper is also
based on applying continuous optimization techniques
with no restrictions on the position of APs.
It should be noted that there are different
approaches to solve optimization problem in hand. In
all these approaches there are two types of variables in
the model: integer variables and continuous ones.
Continuous variables describe the location of APs
whereas integer variables describe the membership
degree of receivers to clusters (group of users/receivers
congregating in one area and using the same AP).
Since each receiver can belong only to one cluster,
integer variables can attain values of 0 and 1 only. As a
result we get a mixed integer nonlinear programming
problem. It is well known that such problems are
difficult to solve in many situations. A nonsmooth
optimization approach described in this paper allows
one to exclude integer variables, to reduce significantly
the number of variables in the optimization problem
and to replace the mixed integer nonlinear
programming problem with a continuous nonlinear
programming problem.
This paper is organized as follow: Section 2 shows
the model notation. Section 3 presents the
mathematical model. Method for the solution of the
problems is described in Section 4. The testing method
is described in Section 5. Results and the effect of AP
parameters on coverage are discussed in Section 6. The
Proceedings of the International Conference on Mobile Business (ICMB’05)
0-7695-2367-6/05 $20.00 © 2005 IEEE