Advancements in Estimating
Baroreflex Function
Exploring Different Aspects of Autonomic Control of the
Heart through the Sequence Technique
T
he arterial baroreflex plays a key role in
blood pressure (BP) homeostasis, and
its impairment may result in exaggerated
blood pressure fluctuations and an in-
creased risk of cardiovascular morbid
events [1]. Given its pathophysiological
relevance, arterial baroreflex function,
and in particular baroreflex control of
heart rate, is now widely assessed both in
cardiovascular research and in a clinical
setting [2]. Such an extensive interest has
triggered a growing demand for tech-
niques able to investigate the arterial
baroreflex under different behavioral con-
ditions, with no need of external surveil-
lance or of interventions on the subject
under investigation. Moreover, as the
characteristics of baroreflex control have
been reported to change over time [3], the
increasing need is for methods able to as-
sess such a regulatory function in a dy-
namic fashion.
Over the years, a number of techniques
satisfying the above requirements have
been developed. These techniques pro-
vide dynamic estimates of the gain of
baroreflex heart rate control—usually re-
ferred to as baroreflex sensitivity
(BRS)—through computer processing of
BP and heart rate spontaneous beat-to-
beat variability (Table 1). All these ap-
proaches can be classified as “modern”
techniques, to differentiate them from the
“traditional” techniques which, con-
versely, cannot estimate BRS under con-
ditions of spontaneous behavior, nor can
they yield information on the dynamical
features of baroreflex cardiovascular reg-
ulation (Table 2). Indeed, the “traditional”
approaches have to be employed in a labo-
ratory environment, and these provide
only spot BRS estimates by evaluating the
R-R interval (RRI; i.e., the reciprocal of
the heart rate) reflex response to BP
changes induced by external stimuli. Fur-
ther details on these techniques may be
found in [2].
Among the modern approaches for
evaluating BRS, one of the most fre-
quently employed is the sequence tech-
nique [8]. This method is based on the
computerized scanning of beat-to-beat se-
ries of systolic (S)BP and RRI values in
search of spontaneous sequences of three
or more consecutive heart beats in which
SBP progressively increases and, usually
with a one-beat delay, RRI progressively
lengthens (RRI+/SBP+ sequences) or,
vice-versa, SBP progressively decreases
and RRI shortens (RRI - /SBP - se-
quences). The slope of the regression line
between the SBP and RRI values included
in each sequence is traditionally taken as a
measure of BRS (a scheme of this method
is shown in Fig. 1). A large number of
these baroreflex sequences spontaneously
occurs during daily life activities (approx.
80 per hour [9]), thus providing a detailed
profile of BRS modulation over time.
In this article, we focus on the method-
ological basis of this technique. In partic-
ular, by taking advantage of experimental
data collected over the years, we explore
the characteristics of the SBP and RRI
patterns within each spontaneous se-
quence. This analysis will be followed by
methodological considerations aimed at
clarifying the perspective from which the
sequence technique evaluates BRS, as
compared with other techniques. Finally,
the latest enhancements of the sequence
technique, leading to the quantification of
other aspects of baroreflex function apart
from BRS, will also be described.
Underlying Concepts
and Considerations
Each of the above-mentioned sponta-
neous RRI/SBP sequence is based on the
joint occurrence of concordant monotonic
changes in both SBP and RRI signals. In
March/April 2001 IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY 25 0739-5175/01/$10.00©2001IEEE
©1989-97 TechPool Studios, Inc.
Marco Di Rienzo
1
, Paolo Castiglioni
1
,
Giuseppe Mancia
2
, Antonio Pedotti
1,3
,
Gianfranco Parati
4
1
LaRC, Centro di Bioingegneria,
Fnd. Don C. Gnocchi and Politecnico, Milano
2
Ospedale S. Gerardo,
Monza and Università di Milano-Bicocca
3
Dept. of Bioengineering,
Politecnico di Milano
4
Istituto Scientifico San Luca,
Centro Auxologico Italiano, Milano