Performance of Distributed Space-Time Cooperative
Schemes for Underwater Acoustic Communications
Madhavan Vajapeyam and Urbashi Mitra
Communication Sciences Institute, University of Southern California
3740 McClintock Avenue, Los Angeles, 90089
Email: {vajapeya,ubli}@usc.edu
Abstract— In resource limited, large scale underwater sensor
networks, cooperative communication over multiple hops offers
opportunities to save power when intermediate nodes between
source and destination act as cooperative relays. Herein, protocols
coupled with space-time block code (STBC) strategies are ana-
lyzed for distributed cooperative communication in underwater
channels. Amplify-and-forward type protocols are considered,
in which the relays do not attempt to decode the information.
The Alamouti-based cooperative scheme proposed by Hua et
al (2003) for flat-fading channels is modified in order work
in the presence of multipath. A time-reversal distributed space-
time block code (TR-DSTBC) is employed, which extends the
classical TR-STBC approach from Lindskog and Paulraj (2000)
to a cooperative communication scenario. Furthermore, the
performance of the scheme employing a DFE equalizer at the
destination is analytically investigated in terms of bit error rate
(BER) bounds and achievable spatial diversity.
I. I NTRODUCTION
Underwater sensor networks form an emerging technology
paradigm that promises to enable or enhance several key appli-
cations in oceanic research, such as: data collection, pollution
monitoring, tactical surveillance and disaster prevention [1]. In
such networks, acoustic signaling will be employed to achieve
underwater communication [1], [2].
In addition, the multihop nature of sensor networks provides
several advantages over single hop schemes [3]: a) combating
the severe signal decay over long distances, thus saving trans-
mission power; b) providing signal paths between terminals
which do not have a direct line of sight between them; and c)
providing multiple communication links for applications with
a high data rate requirement which cannot be satisfied via a
single link.
Multihop networks can also provide additional capacity
and/or performance gains through cooperation between termi-
nals, by taking advantage of their inherent richness in spatial
diversity [4]. Hence, a natural way to exploit this diversity is
via Distributed Space-Time Block Coding (DSTBC) originally
proposed in [4]. The goal of a DSTBC-based protocol is to
allow the cooperating terminals to act, from the destination
point of view, as a multi-antenna array employing a well de-
signed Space-Time Block Code (STBC), originally proposed
for co-located antennas in [5]. Several DSTBC schemes have
been recently proposed (e.g, [4], [6] and others).
0
This research has been funded in part by one or more of the following
grants: ONR N-000140410273, NSF ITR CCF-0313392 and NSF OCE
0520324.
The idea that DSTBC schemes could be applied to un-
derwater networks suggests itself naturally. The underwater
acoustic channel, however, poses extra difficulties to the design
of communication protocols. Typical major challenges posed
by underwater channels are [1]: severe range-dependent at-
tenuation, extensive multipath propagation (resulting in severe
intersymbol interference-ISI) and highly variable propagation
delays (due to slow sound propagation).
In this work, we consider the problem of underwater com-
munication between single source (S) and destination (D)
terminals. Data is relayed in a multihop fashion, through
intermediate sensor nodes placed between S and D. Commu-
nication protocols based on DSTBC are considered. The time
reversal STBC (TR-STBC) approach proposed in [7] for co-
located antennas, is extended to a distributed antenna scenario.
We show that, just like in the STBC case [7], [8], TR along
with the orthogonality of the DSTBC essentially allows for
decoupling of a vector ISI detection problem into separate
scalar problems, without loss of optimality (neglecting ”border
effects” [8]) and, therefore, significant complexity reduction.
A performance analysis of the proposed TR-STBC system
is carried out in order to obtain an upper bound on the
BER at high SNR, assuming the receiver employs a standard
decision feedback equalizer (DFE) [9]. Furthermore, the DFE
performance is compared to that of the optimal maximum-
likelihood sequence estimator.
Throughout this paper, the distribution of a complex
Gaussian random variable with mean µ and variance σ
2
will
be denoted by CN (µ, σ
2
).
II. SIGNAL MODEL
We first consider the discrete-time signal model for a
scenario with a single source terminal (S) communicating to a
destination terminal (D) via a stage of two wireless relays as
depicted in Figure 1. Since the channels between the multiple
links contain ISI, we will employ discrete-time filter notation
to represent them. To exemplify the notation, for a generic
input u(t) and channel filter a(q
−1
) - with q
−1
denoting the
delay operator - the output v(t) is given by
v(t)= a(q
−1
)u(t)=
Lc
X
i=0
a
i
u(t − i), t =1,...,N (1)
where L
c
+1 is the number of channel taps and N is the
block size. Denoting the time-reversed input and output by
© 1-4244-0357-X/06/$20.00 2006 IEEE
This full text paper was peer reviewed at the direction of IEEE Communications Society subject matter experts for publication in the IEEE GLOBECOM 2006 proceedings.