PHASE II STUDY OF PSYCHOTHERAPEUTIC
INTERVENTION IN ADVANCED CANCER
MARCO J.DE VRIES, JOHANNESN.SCHILDER, CORNELISL.MULDER, ADRIANA M.E.VRANCKEN,
MARGOTE.REMIE and BERTGARSSEN*
The Helen Dowling Institute for Biopsychosocial Medicine, PO Box 25309, 3001HH Rotterdam, The
Netherlands
SUMMARY
The effect of psychosocial counseling on tumor progression was studied in 96 cancer patients, who were no longer
amenable to regular medical treatment. Patients were offered 12 session of individual experiential-existential
counseling, each sessions lasting 1.5 to 2 hours. In addition patients participated fortnightly in group counseling
meetings. In five out of 35 evaluable patients, tumor growth became stationary during or immediately following
therapy. In four patients this stationary period last 3–9 months, and in one patient 2 years. Natural Killer cell
activity, self-reported loneliness, depression, purpose in life and locus of control showed no change from pre- to
post intervention. © 1997 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Psycho-Oncology 6: 129–137, 1997.
No. of Figures: 1. No. of Tables: 4. No. of Refs: 42.
INTRODUCTION
Several studies have found an effect of psychoso-
cial counseling on progression of cancer. Two
prospective, randomized studies have shown that
group counseling may prolong survival of cancer
patients (Spiegel et al., 1989; Fawzy et al., 1993).
Richardson et al. (1990a), in a randomized,
controlled study observed an association between
patient education and improved survival, also
when controling for improved compliance. How-
ever, a prospective, randomized study using indi-
vidual counseling in late-stage patients with dif-
ferent types of cancer has been negative (Linn et
al., 1982). This negative finding may be due to the
relatively short follow-up period of 12 months.
Spiegel et al. found no differences in survival until
18 months from study entry in their breast cancer
patients. Also, in the study of Fawzy et al., no
differences in survival were apparent in the first
15 months from study entry. Finally, in one study
using matched controls no effect on survival of a
particular type of support groups (so-called
exceptional cancer patients (ECaP) groups) was
found (Gellert et al., 1993).
The purpose of the present study, which started
in 1987, before the results of the study by Spiegel
et al. were known, was to investigate in a phase II
study the effects of a psychosocial counseling
program on progression of advanced cancer. The
program was a combination of the existential
(Yalom, 1980; Spiegel and Bloom, 1983; Spiegel
and Spira, 1991) and the experiential approach
(Coughlan and Klein, 1984). Components of the
program were also chosen on the basis of earlier
studies on spontaneous regression of cancer
(SRC). Through qualitative analysis of interviews
with SRC patients, it was found that these patients
had shown shifts towards personal autonomy,
experiencing purpose in life and more extensive
and/or higher quality of experienced social rela-
tionships (de Vries, 1986; Van Baalen et al., 1987)
and underwent experiences and performed activ-
ities that were essential for them, prior to the first
signs of clinical improvement (Schilder, 1992).
Trying to help patients to experience their needs,
and to realize their aims and potentials in life was
*Correspondence to: Bert Garssen.
Contract grant sponsor: The Josephine Nefkens Foundation.
PSYCHO -ONCOLOGY , VOL. 6: 129–137 (1997)
CCC 1057–9249/97/020129–09 $17.50
© 1997 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. A ccepted 8 November 1996