1 Copyright © 2003 by ASME
Proceedings of IMECE’03
2003 ASME International Mechanical Engineering Congress & Exposition
Washington, D.C., November 16-21, 2003
IMECE2003 – 44600
OVERTURNING THRESHOLDS OF A ROCKING BLOCK SUBJECTED TO HARMONIC
EXCITATION: COMPUTER SIMULATIONS AND ANALYTICAL TREATMENT
Stefano Lenci (Lenci@univpm.it)
Istituto di Scienza e Tecnica delle Costruzioni,
Università Politecnica delle Marche,
Via Brecce Bianche, 60131, Ancona, Italy
Giuseppe Rega (Giuseppe.Rega@uniroma1.it)
Dipartimento di Ingegneria Strutturale e Geotecnica,
Università di Roma "La Sapienza",
via A. Gramsci 53, 00197, Roma, Italy
ABSTRACT
When a rigid block resting on a horizontal rigid foundation is
shaken by a periodic excitation it can topples if the excitation
amplitude is sufficiently high. This question is addressed in this
work by the combined use of numerical and analytical tools.
Numerical computations are first performed aimed at
understanding the overall overturning behavior, and how it is
modified by varying relevant parameters, such as the excitation
phase and the coefficient of restitution at impacts.
Then the problem is addressed from a theoretical point of
view, with the objective of analytically detecting the most
relevant features highlighted by previous numerical
simulations. We succeed in obtaining closed form and
manageable criteria for overturning.
KEYWORDS: Rigid block dynamics, harmonic excitation,
overturning, invariant manifolds.
1. INTRODUCTION
In this work we investigate the overturning of a rigid block
subjected to harmonic base excitation, an issue which deserves
interest in many branches of mechanical and civil engineering.
It is an old topic tracing back to the nineteen century (Milne,
1881; Perry, 1881), which has been largely investigated in the
past from theoretical (Housner, 1963; Hogan, 1989), numerical
and experimental points of view (Wong & Tso, 1989; Fielder et
al., 1997).
Several questions have been addressed, such as the
existence and stability of periodic solutions, multistability,
chaotic dynamics, impulsive, periodic and stochastic
excitations, overturning diagrams, Melnikov analysis of
invariant manifolds, and control. From a practical point of
view, one of the most interesting problems is the possible
overturning of the rest position, which (i) actually motivated
early works, (ii) can arise in many applications and (iii) is the
principal subject of the present work.
In studying overturning from an engineering point of view,
two points are of basic interest. The first is the detection of
analytical criteria permitting reliable estimations of the
occurrence of overturning, and the second is the construction of
overturning charts characterizing the system response in
parameters space.
The first criterion for overturning seems to be the static
one proposed by West (Milne & Omori, 1893) which compares
the momentum of the weight with the momentum of the
acceleration peak. Other criteria are given in the famous paper
of Housner (1963): in the case of constant acceleration, he
assumes that the (energetic) condition for overturning is that
the total work done by the inertial force is equal to the
difference in potential energy between the rest position and the
hilltop saddles. In the case of sine-waved pulse the (kinematic)
criterion is instead that the actual position reaches one of the
hilltop saddles at the end of the pulse: this leads to the same
results previously obtained by Kirkpatrick (1927). Energetic
considerations are also used in the case of earthquake (i.e.,
stochastic) excitations. Criteria for overturning have been
reviewed by Ishiyama (1980, 1982, 1984), where also
sinusoidal (harmonic) excitations are considered.
Numerical overturning charts under harmonic excitations
are obtained, among others, by Spanos & Koh (1984), which
consider both piecewise linear and strongly nonlinear models
but produce diagrams with a scarce resolution. More refined
charts are constructed, e.g., by Fielder et al. (1997), which also
report on experimental overturning charts, for both symmetric
and unsymmetric blocks, and which stress the influence of the
restitution coefficient. In both these works, however, viscous
damping during rocking is not considered.
In recent years, the problem has been addressed also from
a dynamical system point of view, and it has been suggested
that invariant manifolds should play an important role in the
complicated toppling mechanism. In fact, it is just the
penetration of tongues of the basin of the overturned attractor
into the safe basin, driven and bounded by the stable manifolds