Materializing the Eighteenth Century: Dress
History, Literature, and Interdisciplinary Study
Chloe Wigston Smith*
University of Virginia
Abstract
Drawing on an interview with Linda Baumgarten, curator of clothing and textiles
at Colonial Williamsburg, and recent interdisciplinary studies, this article considers
how eighteenth-century scholars use the history of dress in literary history and cultural
studies. It explores how the study of material culture can illuminate and complicate
literary history, but also how dress history comprises its own language and ideas.
In his 1711 address to vain wits, An Essay on Criticism, Alexander Pope
proclaims that “Expression is the Dress of Thought, and still / Appears more
decent as more suitable” (lines 318–19), an analogy that conveys, with brilliant
precision, the conceptual and cultural intersections between words and
clothing during the eighteenth century. From the East India Company to
crumbling sartorial hierarchies and the cotton gin, the role of dress in
eighteenth-century culture has long fascinated literary scholars. Classic
studies such as Terry Castle’s Masquerade and Civilization have taught us that
the study of clothing discloses the inner workings of a period fascinated by
the kinds of dressing up, dressing down, and cross-dressing that violate the
decorum, whether verbal or visual, that Pope encourages. Following Castle,
scholars such as Laura Brown, Felicity Nussbaum, Joseph Roach, and Kristina
Straub, to name just a few, have incorporated the study of clothing into
their discussions of gender, race, and class.
1
In 2005, full-length studies by
Jennie Batchelor and Tita Chico, scholars both based in the field of literature,
have positioned representations of dress, the dressing-room, and gender at
the crossroads of eighteenth-century interdisciplinary work. Contemporary
views, such as Pope’s analogy between words and clothing, suggest how
clothing constitutes a particularly ripe subject for literary inquiry. In this
brief gallop through dress history and some eighteenth-century inter-
disciplinary studies, I consider how the discipline of dress history presents
its own obstacles, as well as cultural riches, for literary scholars by drawing
on an interview with Linda Baumgarten, curator of clothing and textiles at
Colonial Williamsburg.
2
Like the literary canon, the canon of material culture divulges as many
insights into the complicated history of collecting as it yields glimpses of
© Blackwell Publishing 2006
Literature Compass 3/5 (2006): 967–972, 10.1111/j.1741-4113.2006.00369.x