Kinetic Modeling of the Reaction of HCl and Solid Lime at Low
Temperatures
Ana M. Fonseca,
†
Jose ´ J. O Ä rfa ˜ o,
‡
and Romualdo L. Salcedo*
,‡
Universidade Fernando Pessoa, Departamento de Cie ˆ ncia e Tecnologia, Prac ¸ a 9 de Abril, 4100 Porto,
Portugal, and Faculdade de Engenharia da Universidade do Porto, Departamento de Engenharia Quı ´mica,
R. Bragas, 4099 Porto, Portugal
Calcium hydroxide is a commonly used sorbent in the dry-scrubbing of hydrogen chloride from
flue gases. In this study the kinetic parameters for the reaction between gaseous HCl and solid
Ca(OH)
2
have been obtained at low temperatures in a fixed-bed laboratory reactor. The influence
of the operating temperature (323-400 K), HCl concentration (150-1000 ppm), and humidity
(0-11% M) was studied. The experimental results show that in the first few seconds a very
fast chemical reaction occurs, with a reaction rate constant per unit surface area of solid larger
than 10
-3
ms
-1
. This reaction was found to be first order relative to HCl concentration and its
mechanism is apparently independent of the presence of moisture. However, the relative
humidity of the gas has a major impact on the progress of the reaction: when no moisture is
present the reaction stops after a short period of time (2-3 min), with very low maximum solid
reactant conversions (<5%). For the experiments with humidified gas an almost complete
conversion of Ca(OH)
2
was obtained after about 40 min of reaction time. For this case the grain
model with product layer diffusion limitations is in very good agreement with the experimental
results. The diffusion coefficient in the product layer obtained through this model varied from
10
-13
to 10
-11
m
2
s
-1
and the activation energy for this parameter was estimated at ≈19 kJ
mol
-1
for the range of temperatures studied. A simple linear relationship describes well the
effect of relative humidity of the gas on the diffusion coefficient in the solid product layer. In
the presence of humidity, the very high conversions of the solid reactant show a good potential
applicability to continuous dry-scrubbing of HCl at low temperatures.
Introduction
Hydrogen chloride emissions are formed during com-
bustion of fossil fuels such as chlorine-rich coals and in
incineration of many wastes. Recently, due to increas-
ingly severe legal emission limits and high costs associ-
ated with traditional scrubbing processes, there has
been a great effort in research to develop new processes
that are both efficient and cost-effective.
Dry-scrubbing of acid gases is a relatively recent
technology for the removal of toxic acidic components
from gaseous effluents, whereby finely divided dry
powder is injected into the flue gas stream. Calcium
based sorbents are widely used due to their low cost and
high sorbent capacity for removal of SO
2
, HF, and HCl.
According to Weinell et al.,
1
there is a high potential
for dry-scrubbing of HCl using Ca(OH)
2
at low temper-
atures and high humidity levels: their experimental
results show almost full conversion of lime below 420
K in the presence of moisture. Also, the use of dry-
scrubbing at low temperatures allows the recovery of
energy from flue gases by lowering temperatures through
heat recovery boilers and economizers to 400 K.
2
How-
ever, the literature data on the reaction of HCl with
Ca(OH)
2
below 400 K is scarce.
The kinetics of the reaction
was studied by Karlsson et al.
3
in the temperature range
420-670 K in a fixed-bed laboratory reactor where the
solid particles of Ca(OH)
2
were dispersed in a sand
layer. Their results reveal a high HCl removal ef-
ficiency but the Ca(OH)
2
conversions were lower than
40%, thus indicating a poor utilization of this reactant.
These authors propose a first-order reaction relative to
both reactants. Carminati et al.
4
conducted experiments
in a pilot-plant with injection of an aqueous suspension
of Ca(OH)
2
in a hot flue gas containing HCl (“spray-
dryer” process). Their acid removal efficiencies were
higher than 75% for the lowest temperature (450 K)
with feed ratios Ca(OH)
2
/HCl between 7 and 8 times
the stoichiometric ratio. These authors suggest a
complex reaction order relative to HCl, presumably
higher than one. Weinell et al.
1
achieved almost
complete conversions of Ca(OH)
2
in a differential fixed-
bed reactor at low temperatures (330-420 K) in the
presence of humidity (4-15% M). According to these
authors, the reaction was governed by diffusion in the
solid phase, and the high conversions observed in the
presence of humidity were due to the formation of a
partially liquid product phase. Recently Duo et al.
5
suggest that the rate-limiting step for this reaction is
altered with the reaction progress, changing from
chemical reaction control to product layer diffusion
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. Phone:
+351 2 2041644. E-mail: rsalcedo@fe.up.pt.
†
Universidade Fernando Pessoa.
‡
Faculdade de Engenharia da Universidade do Porto.
Ca(OH)
2
(s) + 2HCl(g) f CaCl
2
‚2H
2
O(s)
4570 Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1998, 37, 4570-4576
10.1021/ie980320f CCC: $15.00 © 1998 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 11/12/1998