Using Comic Strips with Reading Texts: Are We Making a Mistake?
Roya Khoii, Zahra Forouzesh
Islamic Azad University, North Tehran Branch, Iran
roya_kh, zforouzesh{@yahoo.com}
Abstract
This research examined the effect of using reading
passages with comic strips on the development of young
learners' reading comprehension. The study was
conducted on 62 homogeneous female Iranian beginner
EFL learners divided into two experimental and control
groups. The learners in the experimental group used
texts accompanied with comic strips in order to develop
their reading comprehension ability, whereas those in
the control group used the same texts without the comic
strips. All of the participants received instruction in
reading for three months, and at the end of the
treatment the same post-test was given to both groups
in order to compare their gains in reading
comprehension. The result of a t-test for independent
groups at the 0.05 level of significance revealed that
there was no significant difference between the mean
scores of the two groups. Therefore, it was concluded
that using reading passages with comic strips does not
have any significant effect on the learners’ progress in
reading comprehension.
1. Introduction
Reading, according to cognitive systems, is the
process by which individual words are identified from
their printed and written forms, and by which we
combine these words into simple ideas or propositions
in order to be able to form a mental model of the text
based upon the inferences that take us beyond the given
information.
According to Grabe [10], the last decade, in
particular, has been a time of much first and second
language research resulting in many new insights for
reading instruction. This expansion has contributed
significantly to several factors: the efforts to address the
needs of many different learner groups, the recognition
that reading is probably the most important skill for
second language learners in academic contexts, and the
challenge to explore and understand basic
comprehension processes.
Scholars and teachers agree that having a high level
of motivation is crucial in language learning. One well-
known way to motivate foreign language learners to
learn and to arouse their interest in this process can be
bringing something extraordinary and new into the
language class. Comic strips can be used efficiently for
this purpose especially among teenagers and young
adults because it brings a cheerful atmosphere into the
class [5]. EFL and ESL teachers often give students
reading materials accompanied by visuals such as
pictures, cartoons, or comic strips to make reading more
enjoyable and comprehensible.
Researchers like Levie and Lentz [13]; Levin,
Anglin, and Carney [14] have outlined the five major
functions of visuals in reading:
• Representation : visuals repeat the text’s content.
• Organization : visuals enhance the text's coherence.
• Interpretation: visuals provide the reader with more
concrete information.
• Transformation : visuals target critical information
in the text and recode them in a more memorable
form.
• Decoration: visuals are used for their aesthetic
properties or to spark reader's interest in the text.
In the meta-analysis of the effects of visuals all but
the decorative function facilitate memory. These
functions are, in order of importance, transformation,
interpretation, organization, and representation. The
representational function overlaps with the other three
(i.e., transformation, interpretation, and organization)
because visuals always repeat part of the text's content,
either the details or the relationships between the
details.
In general, it can be claimed that comic strips are
not only used for fun in a language class, but there are
Literacy Information and Computer Education Journal (LICEJ), Volume 1, Issue 3, September 2010
Copyright © 2010, Infonomics Society