Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine x Vol. 78, No. 11 x November 2007 1029
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Breath-Hold Time During Cold Water Immersion:
Effects of Habituation with Psychological Training
Martin J. Barwood, Avijit K. Datta,
Richard C. Thelwell, and Michael J. Tipton
B ARWOOD MJ, D ATTA AK, T HELWELL RC, T IPTON MJ. Breath-hold
time during cold water immersion: effects of habituation with psy-
chological training. Aviat Space Environ Med 2007; 78:1029–34.
Introduction: The loss of the conscious control of respiration on
whole body cold water immersion (CWI) can result in the aspiration of
water and drowning. Repeated CWI reduces the respiratory drive evoked
by CWI and should prolong breath-hold time on CWI (BHmax
CWI
). Psy-
chological skills training (PST) can also increase BHmax
CWI
by improving
the ability of individuals to consciously suppress the drive to breathe.
This study tested the hypothesis that combining PST and repeated CWI
would extend BHmax
CWI
beyond that seen following only repeated CWI.
Methods: There were 20 male subjects who completed two 2.5-min,
head-out breath-hold CWI (BH1 and BH2) in water at 12°C. Following
BH1, subjects were matched on BHmax
CWI
and allocated to a habitua-
tion (HAB) group or a habituation plus PST group (H 1PST). Between
BH1 and BH2 both experimental groups undertook five 2.5-min CWI on
separate days, during which they breathed freely. The H 1PST also re-
ceived psychological training to help tolerate cold and suppress the
drive to breathe on immersion to extend BHmax
CWI
. Results: During
BH1, mean BHmax
CWI
( 6 SD) in the HAB group was 22.00 (10.33) s and
22.38 (10.65) s in the H 1PST. After the five free-breathing CWI, both
groups had a longer BHmax
CWI
in BH2. The HAB group improved by
14.13 (20.21) s, an increase of 73%. H 1PST improved by 26.86 (24.70)
s, a 120% increase. No significant differences were identified between
the groups. Conclusion: Habituation significantly increases BHmax on
CWI, the addition of PST did not result in statistically significant im-
provements in BHmax
CWI
, but may have practical significance.
Keywords: drowning, head-out immersion, psychological training.
B
REATH HOLDING is the conscious suppression of
the drive to breathe. This drive can come from vari-
ous sources including the desire for respiratory move-
ment, an increase in blood hydrogen ion concentration,
or a decrease in the oxygen tension of the blood (5,8,30).
Sudden cooling of the skin, in particular to the torso (3),
during cold water immersion (CWI) can also evoke a
powerful drive to breathe as stimulation of peripheral
cold receptors initiates the “cold shock” response (9,21).
During head-out immersion, most individuals are un-
able to suppress this drive to breathe and their maxi-
mum breath hold time (BHmax) is significantly reduced
compared with that achievable in air (17,21). This re-
sponse is potentially hazardous, representing a precur-
sor to the aspiration of water and drowning (24).
The diminution of BHmax on CWI (BHmax
CWI
) is a
potential problem for those at daily risk of accidental
immersion (e.g., helicopter pilots) and has led to the
provision of protective clothing (25,29) and equipment
(23,28). For those without such protection, the possibil-
ity of extending BHmax
CWI
by physiological means re-
mains the only option. In theory, BHmax can be extended
by reducing the drive to breathe or improving an indi-
vidual’s ability to consciously suppress that drive. It is
well established that as few as five 3-min CWI can re-
duce the respiratory responses by about 50%, and this
reduction remains, in part, for at least 14 mo (26). Tipton
et al. (22) showed habituation occurred centrally to the
peripheral cold receptors and the role of central brain
structures has been further supported by animal and
human studies (7,10). Assuming that the relationship be-
tween BHmax
CWI
and respiratory drive is linear, reduc-
ing the respiratory drive during CWI should increase
BHmax
CWI
. However, the habituation of BHmax
CWI
has
not been studied.
With regard to improving the ability of individuals to
suppress the drive to breathe on CWI, Barwood et al. (2)
have recently reported that psychological skills training
(PST) improved BHmax
CWI
by an average of 80%. In
theory, therefore, BHmax
CWI
can be increased by one of
two means: by decreasing the afferent drive to breathe
(habituation); and/or by increasing the ability of indi-
viduals to tolerate that drive (PST). This characterizes
habituation and PST as independent processes, the
combination of which has the potential to increase
BHmax
CWI
beyond that of habituation alone. This
study tested the hypotheses that repeated CWI would
significantly extend BHmax
CWI
by reducing the car-
diorespiratory component of the cold shock response
and that the increase recorded in BHmax
CWI
would be
greater when repeated immersion (habituation) was
supplemented by PST.
Department of Sport and Exercise Science, University of Ports-
mouth, Portsmouth, UK.
This manuscript was received for review in March 2007. It was
accepted for publication in July 2007.
Address for correspondence: Dr. Martin Barwood, Dept. of Sport
and Exercise Science, Spinnaker Building, White Swan Road, Uni-
versity of Portsmouth, Portsmouth, Hants. PO1 2ER, UK; martin.
barwood@port.ac.uk
Reprint & Copyright © by Aerospace Medical Association, Alexan-
dria, VA.
DOI: 10.3357/ASEM.2100.2007