978-1-4799-0059-6/13/$31.00 ©2014 IEEE.
Root Cause Analysis on Changes in Chiller
Performance Using Linear Regression
Jun Okitsu
R&D Department,
Hitachi Asia Malaysia Sdn. Bhd.,
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
jokitsu@has.hitachi.com.my
Ken Naono
R&D Department,
Hitachi Asia Malaysia Sdn. Bhd.,
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
knaono@has.hitachi.com.my
Mohd Fatimie Irzaq Khamis
Property Management & Maintenance,
Universiti Teknologi PETRONAS,
Tronoh, Perak, Malaysia
fatimieirzaq@petronas.com.my
Shaharin Anwar Sulaiman
Department of Mechanical Engineering,
Universiti Teknologi PETRONAS,
Tronoh, Perak, Malaysia
shaharin@petronas.com.my
Mohd Amin Abd Majid
Department of Mechanical Engineering,
Universiti Teknologi PETRONAS,
Tronoh, Perak, Malaysia
mamin_amajid@petronas.com.my
Abstract—Gas District Cooling (GDC) plants, designed to be
environmentally efficient, require frequent maintenances, in order to
avoid corrosions or leakages from the chemical reactions in Steam
Absorption Chillers (SACs) of the plant. However, most of the plant
experts face difficulty that the positive and the negative effects from
the SAC maintenances are not clear. This is because there are
various metrics to indicate GDC SAC performance, but they don’t
have enough information to describe chiller internal conditions. The
paper describes a method to detect the root cause of the GDC SAC
performance changes. Specifically, (1) the chiller performance is
modeled by linear regression on the performance related sensor data,
and (2) the root cause is determined by time series analysis of the
sensor contribution ratios to the performance in accordance of the
concept of theory of constraints (TOC). Evaluations in Universiti
Teknologi PETRONAS (UTP) GDC plant showed that the method
determined the root cause correctly in 3 cases out of 4 problem cases.
Because the method determines the root cause only from the plant
operation historical data without any inspections, it is generalized to
detect component failures and other plant anomalies.
Keywords—chiller; performance degradation; maintenance;
linear regression; root cause analysis;
I. INTRODUCTION
Gas District Cooling (GDC) provides electricity and chilled
water to facilities with relatively low running cost and as a
potential to reduce CO
2
emission [1]. Steam absorption chiller
(SAC) is the key component of the GDC because SAC
generates chilled water with low running cost by making use of
waste heat and chemical reactions.
The SAC has difficulty that corrosions and leakages in the
system greatly affect its performance because of the chemical
reactions. Thus, it is required for the SAC maintenance to
detect and resolve the problems immediately. To realize it,
plant experts were engaged to observe the SAC performance
metrics, such as chilled water supply rate, COP and steam rate
with sensors in the plant. However, it would be difficult for the
metrics to detect the root cause of the problem immediately
because the metrics do not have enough information to
determine chiller internal conditions.
Methods to detect root cause of plant abnormally were
studied [2, 3]. As a consequence, detecting root causes of non-
linear factors, such as control valves with excessive static
friction, oscillating and sensors faults, can be solved
satisfactorily [3]. However, detecting root cause of linear
factors, such as performance deterioration due to aging and
corrosion, still remains open research question [3]. Since the
deterioration proceeds gradually, presence of noise and further
factors makes it difficult to detect the root cause.
The research objectives are (1) to develop a method to detect
the root cause of a chiller performance deterioration caused by
corrosions and leakages in the chiller, and (2) to evaluate the
method through a root cause analysis on the SAC performance
degradation in Universiti Teknologi PETRONAS (UTP) GDC
plant.