IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON GEOSCIENCE ELECTRONICS, VOL. GE-17, NO. 3, JULY 1979
Surface-Based Scatterometer Results of
Arctic Sea Ice
ROBERT G. ONSTOTT, STUDENT MEMBER, IEEE, RICHARD K. MOORE, FELLOW, IEEE,
AND W. F. WEEKS
Abstract-Radar backscatter measurements were made of shorefast
sea ice near Point Barrow, AK, in May 1977, with a surface-based FM-
CW scatterometer that swept from 1-2 GHz and from 8.5-17.5 GHz.
The 1-2 GHz measurements showed that thick first-year and multiyear
ice cannot be distinguished at 10-70° incidence angles, but that un-
deformed sea ice can be discriminated from pressure ridges and lake ice.
Results also indicate that frequencies between 8-18 GHz have the
ability to discriminate between thick first-year, multiyear, and lake ice.
Cross polarization was found to be a better discriminator than like
polarization. In addition, at these latter frequencies the differential
scattering cross section a0 was found to have an approximately linearly
increasing frequency response.
I. INTRODUCTION
T he fact that radar is especially well suited as an operational
remote sensing tool for the polar oceans, because of its
all-weather, day-night capability, and its ability to sense large
expanses of terrain, has been recognized for years. For example,
side-looking airborne radar (SLAR) imagers have proven to be
useful aids in sea ice reconnaissance and mapping. Neverthe-
less, development of the full potential for the application of
radar-to-polar oceanography is hindered by a general lack of
fundamental knowledge of the interaction of microwaves with
the various types of sea ice. Clearly, to obtain the greatest
utility from such sensors, careful study must be made of the
physical phenomenon of radar return from sea ice. This
knowledge should then be used in selecting the optimum param-
eters for future designs of polar reconnaissance and mapping
radars.
The potential application of SLAR to sea ice research and
reconnaissance was recognized in 1962, when the U.S. Army
Cold Regions Research and Engineering Laboratory utilized a
U.S. Air Force AN/APQ-56 K-band SLAR in sea ice experi-
ments conducted during April and August [1]. This study in-
dicated that various important sea ice features could be
identified on the K-band imagery, and that the SLAR system
provided the capability of obtaining good-resolution image
maps of large expanses of ice, independent of the incident
light and weather conditions.
Since that time, radar has been used extensively to monitor
sea ice by Rouse [2], Johnson and Farmer [3], Glushkov and
Manuscript received January 15, 1979; revised May 1, 1979. This
work was supported by the Office of Naval Research under Contract
N00014-74-C-1 105.
R. G. Onstott and R. K. Moore are with the Remote Sensing Lab-
oratory, University of Kansas Center for Research, Inc., KS 66045.
W. F. Weeks is with the U.S. Army Cold Regions Research and En-
gineering Laboratory, Hanover, NH 03755.
Komarov [4], Ketchum and Tooma [5], Parashar et al. [6],
Dunbar [7], Dunbar and Weeks [8], Gray et al. [9], and
Ketchum [10]. These studies have primarily been made at
2- and 3-cm wavelengths, although a few studies were made
at 25-cm wavelengths. Most SLAR flights have used angles
of incidence near grazing. These studies tended to agree that
with some reservations, the ability to detect and interpret ice
age, ice drift, ice surface topography such as pressure ridges
and fractures, and to evaluate sea ice conditions, was very
good.
The first attempt to expand the knowledge of the parametric
response of radar systems sensing sea ice began in 1967 when
the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA),
Navy Oceanographic Office, U.S. Army Cold Regions Research
and Engineering Laboratory, Arctic Institute of North America,
and the University of Kansas, Lawrence, undertook a study of
the ability of a 2.25-cm wavelength (13.3-GHz) scatterometer
(a calibrated instrument designed to measure the differential
scattering coefficient a' as a function of incidence angle [ 11 ] )
to identify different ice types [2]. The results demonstrated
that a vertically polarized scatterometer operating at this fre-
quency could indeed be used to discriminate ice types. For
instance, multiyear returns were higher than thick first-year ice
returns at all angles of incidence.
In April 1970, another joint experiment was conducted by
NASA, the Naval Oceanographic Office, and the University of
Kansas, in which systematic radar backscatter measurements
of sea ice were made at 400 MHz (HH, W, VH, and HV
polarizations; H
=
horizontal, V =
vertical; the first letter
identifies transmitted polarization and the second letter
identifies received polarization) and 13.3 GHz (W polariza-
tion). The results showed that multiyear ice gave the strongest
return at 13.3 GHz, while first-year ice and open water gave
the strongest returns at 400 MHz [6]. Discrimination of ice
from open water was possible with both frequencies. Four
polarization 1 6.5-GHz radar imagery were also analyzed. The
results were consistent with scatterometer results in that
0-18-cm, 18-90-cm, and 90-cm ice and open water were
discriminable. Cross polarization appeared to be better in
discriminating sea ice types, but problems with the images
prevented a firm conclusion.
During the winter and spring of 1975-1976, measurements
were made with a multipolarized 13.3-GHz scatterometer in
conjunction with the AIDJEX and Beaufort Sea offshore
programs [9], [15]. Results showed systematic changes in
microwave backscatter which strongly correlated with gross
ice type categories. Multiyear ice showed significantly higher
0018-9413/79/0700-0078$00.75
©
1979 IEEE
78