Analog Realization of Fractional Order Hybrid
Differentiators via Carlson’s Approach
Saptarshi Das
1,3
, Suman Saha
2,3
, Amitava Gupta
1,3
, and Shantanu Das
4
1
School of Nuclear Studies & Applications, Jadavpur University, Salt Lake Campus, LB-8, Sector 3, Kolkata-700089,
India, Email of Author
1
: saptarshi@pe.jusl.ac.in
2
Drives and Control System Technology Group, Central Mechanical Engineering Research Institute (CMERI), CSIR,
Mahatma Gandhi Avenue, Durgapur-713209, India, Email of Author
2
: s_saha@cmeri.res.in
3
Department of Power Engineering, Jadavpur University, Salt Lake Campus, LB-8, Sector 3, Kolkata-700089, India,
Email of Author
3
: amitg@pe.jusl.ac.in
4
Reactor Control Division, Bhabha Atomic Research Centre (BARC), Mumbai-400085, India, Email of Author
4
:
shantanu@magnum.barc.gov.in
Abstract—Rational approximation of fractional order (FO)
elements are now of prime importance for the need of its
hardware implementation in control design and signal
processing. Among the well known analog realizations methods,
the Carlson’s approach has been used in this paper due to its
simplicity of calculation for designing a certain class of FO
differentiators as hybrid filters. Impact of the independent
parameters of the hybrid differentiator on the phase response
has been depicted along with the achievable accuracies for
increasing order of realization for filter design.
I. INTRODUCTION
Fractional order elements are the building blocks for the
fractional order system theory, control and signal processing
[1]. Fractional order differ-integrators show constant-phase
frequency response, thus are also known as Constant Phase
Elements (CPE) [2]. The only problem with FO elements is its
hardware realization due to its infinite dimensional nature. In
practice, FO elements can be approximated as higher order
rational transfer functions which have a constant phase curve
within a certain frequency band. The fractional order elements
can be rationalized as analog filters by various iterative
techniques like Carlson’s, Oustaloup’s, Charef’s method etc.
[3]-[5]. In this paper, the Carlson’s method has been used to
realize a certain class of FO hybrid differentiators, commonly
used in control and signal processing applications. Accuracy
of the Carlson’s approach for approximating FO elements with
increasing level of deviation from semi-integro-differential
operators has been studied extensively in the present paper.
Rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section II
discusses about the theoretical framework of Carlson’s
approach. Section III shows the simulation studies with the FO
differentiators and hybrid filters. The accuracy of this
technique has been illustrated in Section IV. The paper ends
with the conclusion as section V, followed by the references.
II. RATIONAL APPROXIMATION OF FRACTIONAL
ORDER ELEMENTS BY CARLSON’S METHOD
Analog circuit realization of fractance or FO immitance
has been first studied in [6]-[9]. The recursive approximation
of FO elements using the Carlson’s method is discussed next.
If () Gs be a rational transfer function and () Hs be a
fractional order transfer function such that
[ ] () () ,
q
Hs Gs q = ∈ \
(1)
where, q m p = is fractional order of the transfer function
model, then () Hs can be recursively approximated as [3]-[6]:
[ ]
[ ]
2
1
1 2
1
( ) () ( ) ()
() ()
( ) () ( ) ()
i
i i
i
p m H s p mGs
H s H s
p m H s p mGs
-
-
-
- + +
=
+ + -
(2)
with an initial guess of
0
() 1 H s =
. Equation (2) can be
rewritten in a more compact form as:
[ ]
[ ]
2
1
1 2
1
() ()
() ()
() ()
i
i i
i
Gs H s
H s H s
Gs H s
α
α
-
-
-
+
=
+
(3)
where,
( )
( )
1 1
:
1 1
mp p m q
p m mp q
α
⎡ ⎤ - - -
= = =
⎢ ⎥
+ + +
⎣ ⎦
and
1
:
1
q
α
α
-
=
+
(4)
For the simplest case, ()
q
Hs s = , (1) will behave like a FO
differentiator for 0 q > implying 1 α < and like a FO integrator
for 0 q < implying 1 α > . The Carlson’s formula recursively
places interlacing negative real poles and zeros in complex s-
plane so as to meet the constant phase criteria [3]-[5],
corresponding to the FO differ-integration. Also, from (3), it
is evident that all the intermediate poles and zeros lie in the
negative s-plane that enables direct inversion of the filter
transfer functions to obtain a FO integrator, while also
preserving the stability of the model.
60
2011 International Conference on Multimedia, Signal Processing and Communication Technologies
9781457711077/11/$26.00 ©2011 IEEE