JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL ZOOLOGY 289:317–321 (2001)
© 2001 WILEY-LISS, INC.
Influence of Diminished Respiratory Surface Area
on Survival of Sea Turtle Embryos
ANDREA D. PHILLOTT* AND C. JOHN PARMENTER
School of Biological and Environmental Sciences, Central Queensland
University, Rockhampton QLD 4702, Australia
ABSTRACT It has been suggested that fungal presence on sea turtle eggs may impede gas
exchange. To investigate the influence of diminished gas exchange surface upon embryo survivor-
ship, flatback (Natator depressus) and green (Chelonia mydas) eggs were painted with petroleum
jelly. Variable proportions of the egg surface were covered, including both respiratory and
nonrespiratory domains. Embryo survival varied with site inhibited, proportion of eggshell af-
fected, and species of turtle. If fungi on the exterior of the eggshell are able to impede respiratory
gas exchange, their presence on the upper hemisphere (primary gas exchange area in early incu-
bation) will result in the highest embryo mortality. Large eggs are likely to demonstrate a higher
survivorship than small eggs, due to their larger available respiratory area and/or to variation in
weight or stage-specific embryonic metabolic demands. Interspecific differences in egg size may
therefore be a contributory factor to observed mortality rate differences in the natural presence of
fungi. J. Exp. Zool. 289:317–321, 2001. © 2001 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
Grant sponsor: Centre for Land and Water Resource Management,
Central Queensland University; Grant number: JRXWG-131.
*Correspondence to: Andrea D. Phillott, School of Biological and
Environmental Sciences, Central Queensland University, Rock-
hampton QLD 4702, Australia. E-mail: phillota@cqu.edu.au
Received 24 May 2000; Accepted 23 October 2000
Microbes have been isolated from the exterior
and/or embryonic tissue of unhatched eggs of log-
gerhead, Caretta caretta (Ragotzkie, ’59; Wyneken
et al., ’88; Peters et al., ’94), green, Chelonia mydas
(Bustard and Greenham, ’68; Solomon and Baird,
’80; Whitmore and Dutton, ’85), leatherback,
Dermochelys coriacea (Whitmore and Dutton, ’85;
Solomon and Tippett, ’87; Chan and Solomon, ’89;
Eckert and Eckert, ’90), olive ridley, Lepidochelys
olivacea (Mo et al., ’90; Acuna-Mesen, ’92), hawks-
bill, Eretmochelys imbricata (Phillott, unpub-
lished) and flatback, Natator depressus (Phillott,
unpublished) sea turtles. It has not been conclu-
sively determined whether the microbes isolated
are present as contaminants or infectants. Ragot-
zkie (’59) and Peters et al. (’94) considered decayed
eggs to be the result of microbial invasion after
embryo mortality (due to nest flooding). Solomon
and Baird (’80), Solomon and Tippett (’87), Wyne-
ken et al. (’88), and Eckert and Eckert (’90) be-
lieved microbial pathogens to be implicated in egg
failure. Both scenarios appear possible.
In the instance of fungal invasion of the viable
egg, Solomon and Baird (’80) describe three pos-
sible mechanisms for debilitation of the developing
embryo: impeded gas exchange as the hyphae in-
terweave with the porous eggshell matrix; transfer
of fungal spores from the allantois to the embry-
onic tissue; and, calcium depletion of the eggshell
resulting in retarded embryonic development.
Mycoflora have been implicated in a differen-
tial species mortality between green and logger-
head sea turtle nests at Heron Island and Wreck
Island in the southern Great Barrier Reef (Limpus
et al., ’83). Although physical and physiological de-
fenses (e.g., eggshell structure; anti-pathogenicity
of albumen) play an important role in protecting
the turtle egg from the biotic nest environment,
variation in egg size may result in interspecific
variation in response to a similar-sized area of fun-
gal growth and subsequent impediment of respira-
tory surface area.
In order to evaluate embryo sensitivity to in-
hibited respiratory exchange, we progressively im-
peded eggshell surface from its gas exchange role.
Further, to investigate the spatial/regional corre-
lation of the impact of any particular proportion
impeded, the progression was tested beginning at
the top (the “north pole”) of the egg, and at the
bottom (“south pole”). It was hypothesized that
the starting point could be important, as the most
obvious external reflection of the commencement
of embryonic growth in sea turtle eggs is a chalky
white patch (the “white spot”) that appears at the
north pole, then extends downward to encompass