Introduction
!
The maintenance of joint function depends on an
intact structure of its components, especially ar-
ticular cartilage, but also on the functional and
structural integrity of the muscles acting on and
supporting a joint [6,13–15]. Weak muscles are
assumed to reduce joint stability and mechanical
shock absorption [14, 33, 34], and may predispose
a joint to develop osteoarthritis (OA). However, in
a classical point of view, strength deficits or atro-
phic structure of these muscles are usually seen
as a consequence of OA, i.e., an outcome of disuse
induced by articular pain [6,14, 24, 25]. Which
process the other one precedes has not yet been
clarified. The interdependence of OA and altera-
tions of periarticular muscles have especially
been studied for the knee joint and the quadri-
ceps muscle [2,14, 35]. It has been argued that a
weak quadriceps muscle cannot produce enough
strength to stabilize the knee and to prevent
overload during the amortization of the mechan-
ical impact during gait [14, 33,34].
The osteoarthritic hip joint has been less studied
in this respect, but a reduced force of the gluteus
medius muscle (GM) has already been associated
with hip OA [2, 22,30, 31]. However, the biome-
chanical situation around the hip appears more
complicated than that around the knee. In fact,
while the interaction of muscle and joint can be
looked at unilaterally in the case of the knee, the
hip joints and the abductor muscles interact bi-
laterally during gait [8,17, 26,37]. When body
weight gets supported by the hip joint of one side
during gait, the ipsilateral abductors have to sta-
bilize pelvic equilibrium in the frontal plane and
ensure a smooth load transfer by their eccentric
contraction in order to avoid excessive shock im-
pact on the contralateral hip joint [16,17,19,38].
If the hip abductors, especially the GM, are not
sufficiently strong, such will result in the typical
gait pattern, the “Trendelenburg gait” [17,26].
This pattern, with a drop of the opposite hip due
to the abductors’ deficit during unipodal walking,
leads to adduction of the ipsilateral hip, moving
the compressive force laterally to the acetabulum
[28,36]. However, this pelvic drop is frequently
avoided by the patients by bending the trunk,
shifting the body gravity center closer to the load
bearing hip (“Duchenne limping” or “abductor
Abstract
!
In order to understand the role of the gluteus
medius muscle (GM) in hip joint osteoarthritis,
the objective of this study was to analyze the cor-
relation between morphometric data of GM sam-
ples with osteoarthritis scores of ipsilateral and
contralateral hips in 41 patients. GM samples ob-
tained during unilateral hip replacement surgery
were used to evaluate muscle fibers in the cross-
sectional area (CSA) and other features indicative
for muscle aging. Clinical symptoms were as-
sessed by the Lequesne pain score. Hip osteo-
arthritis was graded by the Kellgren score and by
measuring the sum joint space width (sumJSW)
at three different articular locations and minimal
JSW in a. p. radiographs. Varying degrees of GM
muscle atrophy correlated with the pain score;
pain score also correlated with radiographic
signs of osteoarthritis. GM CSA was significantly
correlated with all radiographic signs of the con-
tralateral hip, but only with the sumJSW in the
ipsilateral hip. It can be concluded that a weak
GM may be the result of ipsilateral osteoarthitis,
but may especially predispose the contralateral
hip to develop osteoarthritis. This can be associ-
ated with an impaired GM capacity to avoid the
shock impact in the load transfer during gait.
Muscle strengthening is therefore recommended.
Gluteus Medius Muscle Atrophy is Related to
Contralateral and Ipsilateral Hip Joint Osteoarthritis
Authors A. Amaro
1
, F. Amado
2
, J. A. Duarte
1,3
, H.-J. Appell
3,4
Affiliations
1
Health School, University of Aveiro, Aveiro, Portugal
2
Department of Chemistry, University of Aveiro, Aveiro, Portugal
3
CIAFEL, FADE, University of Porto, Porto, Portugal
4
Physiology and Anatomy, German Sport University, Cologne, Germany
Key words
l
"
hip osteoarthritis
l
"
muscle histology
l
"
muscle fiber area
l
"
Kellgren index
l
"
joint space width
accepted after revision
January 29, 2007
Bibliography
DOI 10.1055/s-2007-965078
Published online May 29, 2007
Int J Sports Med 2007; 28:
1035 – 1039 © Georg Thieme
Verlag KG Stuttgart • New York •
ISSN 0172-4622
Correspondence
Prof. Hans-Joachim Appell
Physiology and Anatomy
German Sport University
Carl Diem Weg 6
50933 Cologne
Germany
Phone: + 49 221 49 82 54 30
appell@dshs-koeln.de
1035
Amaro A et al. Hip Osteoarthritis and … Int J Sports Med 2007; 28: 1035 – 1039
Orthopedics & Biomechanics