The Evolution of Motorola’s Global Financial Supply Chain Strategy
Ian D. Blackman Christopher P. Holland Tim Westcott
Brunel University Manchester Business School Motorola
ian.blackman@brunel.ac.uk chris.holland@mbs.ac.uk tim.westcott@motorola.com
ian
Abstract
This paper charts the progress of Motorola’s
global cash management strategy encompassing
Motorola’s internal factories worldwide, Motorola’s
customers and suppliers, and partner banks in the US,
Europe and Asia. It explains how their financial supply
chain strategy has evolved over a period of over thirty
five years from a relatively simple internally focused
system into a fully integrated global system that
enables the flow of currency and associated foreign
exchange processes to mirror the Just-In-Time (JIT)
flow of products throughout the supply chain. The
performance of the finance systems is analyzed using
detailed statistical techniques including six-sigma. The
strategy is characterized by incremental changes
punctuated by significant shifts in the strategy,
organizational design and information systems. It is
demonstrated that the financial processes that connect
Motorola with its suppliers enable the supply chain to
behave more like a single, cohesive unit rather than a
collection of autonomous organizational units.
1. Introduction
The globalization of markets has attracted
increasing attention in the academic and business
literature and although there is continuing debate into
the extent and nature of globalization in terms of
market behavior and trends, the structure of supply
chains and organization design, it is widely accepted
that all types of businesses must develop their
production and marketing strategies in a global
context. This is particularly true in the high technology
and banking markets, which have been at the forefront
of globalization. In this paper we examine the
globalization process in Motorola’s financial supply
chain. The strategy analysis incorporates theory
elements from the strategy, IS and operational
management literatures. An outline of the relevant
theory concepts is given below.
In his seminal article, Levitt [1] identified the
importance of the globalization of markets, and in
particular the standardization of products to suit global
markets. Although the overarching trend towards
common, global standards and products have been
questioned, and the importance of local requirements
have received more attention, the trends described and
forecasted by Levitt have been of particular importance
in high-technology markets. The Internet, cheaper
travel and the availability of low-cost manufacturing
have all contributed to the homogenization of many
high-tech consumer markets, particularly computing,
mobile phones and software. These market changes
have been accompanied by the emergence of global
organizations, which have defined and shaped their
strategies in order to take advantage of global
standards and increased standardization, whilst also
recognizing the importance of local market
requirements. Other examples of global technical
standards include GSM in the mobile phone industry
and de facto standards defined by dominant market
shares e.g. computer operating systems, Microsoft’s
office productivity software and eBay’s shopping
platform.
The critical element of any global strategy is to be
able to manage and co-ordinate operations efficiently
in order to achieve economies of scale and maintain or
lower their operating costs. Dicken [2] makes a
distinction between the notion of ‘pure’ globalization
exemplified by Ohmae [3] and more complex
developments where geography and local product
design are reflected in the structure and management of
international supply chains. An important analytical
tool that emerges from the discussion of globalization
is the network concept of inter-linked organizations,
typically formed into a supply chain that manages the
flow of raw materials, product assembly,
manufacturing and distribution through shared business
processes and Information Systems.
Multinational organizations have gained huge
benefits from the integration of management processes
within their organizations through the use of Enterprise
Resource Planning (ERP) systems that have been
accompanied by the development of shared
information systems along the supply chain, either by
simple EDI systems or more sophisticated electronic
business standards such as RosettaNet. The supply
Proceedings of the 44th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences - 2011
1 1530-1605/11 $26.00 © 2011 IEEE