Ontology based performance evaluation of public
transport systems
Salima Mnif
1
Sarra Galoui Sabeur Elkosantini
2
Saber Darmoul
2
Lamjed Ben Said
1
mnifsalima@yahoo.fr sarragaloui@gmail.com selkosantini@ksu.edu.sa sdarmoul@ksu.edu.sa lamjed.bensaid@isg.rnu.tn
1
SOIE Laboratory, High Institute of Management of Tunis, University of Tunis, Tunisia
2
Industrial Engineering Department, King Saud University, P.O. Box 800, Riyadh, 11421, Saudi Arabia
Abstract— offering high levels of quality of service (e.g.
punctuality and frequency) and performance (e.g. effectiveness
and efficiency) for users of public transport systems is a great
challenge for governments and transportation authorities.
Various research works have been conducted to develop criteria
to evaluate the performance of Public Transport Systems (PTS).
However, there is still a need to design and develop decision
support tools that both encompass and take advantage of the
increasing number and diversity of the suggested Key
Performance Indicators (KPI) and performance evaluation
methods. The main purpose of this paper is to develop a decision
support system that relies on ontologies to represent, capture,
store and use knowledge to evaluate the performance of PTS. An
implementation of the system is also presented and discussed.
Keywords- Ontology Engineering, Evaluation, Key
Performance Indicators, Intelligent Transport System.
I. INTRODUCTION
Nowadays, governments and transportation authorities have
to face increasing challenges to improve the mobility of
citizens while controlling traffic congestion, guaranteeing
safety and security, and offering high levels of performance
and quality of service. Despite the spread and success of the
implementation of public transport systems (PTS), it is
becoming more and more difficult to guarantee high levels of
performance and quality of service for passengers. This is
mainly due to the size, complexity, and interaction between
subcomponents of a PTS system, and to types, frequency and
size of information, knowledge and decisions that have to be
taken to manage such complex systems.
Therefore, it becomes necessary to implement new
intelligent decision support systems to assist authorities with
the management and improvement of PTS. It is particularly
important to be able to continuously evaluate the levels of
performance and quality of service of PTS regarding different
aspects, including for example punctuality, safety, security,
availability of services, etc. In this context, many works have
been conducted to define performance criteria and to develop
evaluation standards and procedures, including for example the
Transit Capacity and Quality of Service Manual (TCQSM)
used in the USA [1], [2], [3] or the European (UNI EN 13816)
standard for quality of service in public transportation.
However, there is still a need to develop decision support
systems that:
• Encompass the increasing number of Key
Performance Indicators (KPI)
• Take advantage of the diversity of the suggested
performance evaluation methods
• Capture, structure and use knowledge related to
public transport systems
• Able to interact with other information,
communication and control technologies,
intelligent infrastructure and software tools
available to manage PTS
In this paper, we suggest an ontology based evaluation
support system that enables the evaluation of the performance
of PTS with respect to several aspects, including availability,
punctuality, human resources and security. Therefore, the
remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section II
presents a brief literature review on performance criteria
suggested for PTS. Section III introduces the use of ontology in
transportation. Section IV presents our ontology-based system
architecture and finally, the section V presents the
implementation of the systems and used technologies.
II. KEY PERFORMANCE INDICATORS FOR PUBLIC
TRANSPORT SYSTEMS
PTS represent a critical element of urban cities as they
contribute to solve problems of congestion and mobility within
cities. The reliability of PTS is subject to deterioration due to a
wide range of factors [4]. Service reliability is defined as the
ability of a transit system to adhere to a schedule or maintain
regular headways and a consistent travel time [5]. Causes of
unreliability were widely studied and identified in the
literature. For example, Cham [6] considers the following four
main causes of unreliability:
1. Inefficient timetables that vehicles are unable to follow
This work was supported by NSTIP strategic program number (12-
INF2820-02) in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The authors would like to thank
all personnel involved in this work
2015 4th IEEE International Conference on Advanced Logistics and Transport (ICALT)
205 978-1-4799-8400-8/15/$31.00 ©2015 IEEE