VOLUME XXII 2009 1 © 2009 by the University of Texas Press, P.O. Box 7819, Austin, TX 78713-7819
A Bayesian Approach to the Orientations
of Central Alentejo Megalithic Enclosures
FERNANDO PIMENTA, LUÍS TIRAPICOS, AND ANDREW SMITH
Fernando Pimenta is a member of the Portuguese Association of Archaeological Research (PAAR). He lectured on statistics at the Instituto
Superior Técnico in Lisbon and is now an electrical engineer specializing in energy and control systems. He worked with Michael Hoskin
on the orientations of two exceptional Neolithic tombs, Matarrubilla and La Pastora, near Seville, Spain.
Luís Tirapicos, also a member of PAAR, is a history of science graduate student at the University of Lisbon. He studied astronomy at Porto
University and currently is part of the Educational Service at the Museum of Science of the University of Lisbon, where he also researches
the history of scientific instruments. His first work in archaeoastronomy was a collaboration with Michael Hoskin on the orientations of
north Portugal megalithic tombs.
Andrew Smith graduated in 1995 from the University of Adelaide with a Ph.D. in high energy astrophysics. He worked thereafter as an
IT consultant specializing in scientific software development for several projects in astrophysics and archaeoastronomy and currently is
part of the Pierre Auger Collaboration, working with the University of Adelaide on software and hardware development related to the
Pierre Auger Observatory in Argentina.
Abstract
In this work we have conducted a study on the
orientations in the landscape of twelve megalith-
ic enclosures in the Alentejo region of southern
Portugal. Some of these sites date back to the
sixth or ifth millennium B.C. and are among the
oldest stone enclosures in Europe. The results of
the survey show a pattern toward eastern rising
orientations. We used dedicated GIS software
from one of the authors to produce horizon pro-
iles and applied a statistical Bayesian approach
in an attempt to check how the data would it
to different models. In particular, we tested our
results for a possible ritual interest in the Autumn
or Harvest Full Moon and discuss previous
studies by Michael Hoskin and colleagues on
the orientations of seven stone dolmens of this
area that have shown the existence of a possible
custom for an orientation toward the sunrise.
Resumen
En este trabajo se realizó un estudio sobre las
orientaciones en el paisaje de doce recintos
megalíticos en el Alentejo (sur de Portugal).
Algunos de estos sitios se remontan al sexto
o quinto milenio antes de Cristo, es decir, se
encuentran entre los recintos de piedra más
antiguos de Europa. Los resultados de la
encuesta muestran un padrón de orientaciones
al oriente. Hemos utilizado un software de
SIG dedicado de uno de los autores para
producir periles del horizonte y aplicamos un
tratamiento estadístico Bayesiano con la
inalidad de comprobar cómo los datos se
ajusten a diferentes modelos. En particular
hemos probado nuestros resultados con un
posible ritual de interés en la luna llena de otoño
o Harvest Moon y discutimos los estudios
previos de Michael Hoskin y colegas, acerca
de las orientaciones de los dólmenes de piedra
de esta zona que han demostrado la existencia
de una posible costumbre de orientación solar.
Despite various attempts to address the orientation
of the megalithic enclosures in the Alentejo prov-
ince of southern Portugal (Alvim 1996–1997, 2004;
Silva 2000), it has hitherto lacked a comprehensive
orientation investigation (Cardoso 2002:235) bring-
ing together all enclosures, including those that have
been completely dismantled.
The Alentejo extends, roughly, from south of the
Tejo River to north of the Algarve, a province on the