Architectural plans are design diagrams that describe
building layout where space is planned according to
design requirements. Style in architecture is generally
characterized as common features appearing in a
particular class of building design. This research seeks
to address how to recognize architectural design style
from a 2D plan diagram. We explore this question in a
computational encoder-analyzer (E-A) model for 2D
plans, where a characterization of 2D style is based on
qualitative spatial representation and information theo-
retic measures. In a preliminary study of a prominent
architect’s plans, we demonstrate the effectiveness of
our approach. We conclude by discussing practical
applications of automated plan recognition and classifi-
cation in design support tools.
Introduction
Research in various domains share problems of formaliz-
ing style. The architectural design domain is no exception, and
in most cases, “style” is difficult to determine formally. In all
visual domains, style is commonly used to describe consisten-
cies among artifacts that are the product of an individual,
culture, period, or region. In this way, the concept of style in
architecture acts as an ordering principle, allowing building
designs to be structured or categorized, providing order within
an otherwise apparently chaotic domain (Knight, 1994).
The style of a building can be based on a number of dif-
ferent representations and evaluated using a variety of at-
tributes. Here, two principal aspects concern us: (a) the visual
representation, which can be two (2D) or three dimensional
(3D); and (b) the physicality, which can encompass a vari-
ety of perceptual primitives. For the former aspect, we have
chosen to focus our attention on 2D representations and
utilize plan diagrams as our analytical vehicle. While
acknowledging alternative approaches to architectural style,
we limit our scope to 2D plan diagrams and consider this
mode of design representation and communication as a
significant artifact upon which to consider the problem of
characterizing architectural style. For the latter, our
approach to physicality distinguishes two criteria: (a) shape
elements and (b) their spatial relationships, which Shapiro
(1961) considered significant for the characterization of
style. Thus, both open and closed shapes as well as relations
describing contact and organization can be recognized visu-
ally from 2D contours.
Using this approach to representation as our foundation,
we present an encoding-analysis model capable of identify-
ing and comparing 2D plan diagrams. Our objective is to
derive both local and global features as stylistic discrimina-
tors. We define stylistic discriminators as those features
which remain approximately invariant within a design, but
which vary between individuals, cultures, periods, or regions.
Specifically, we explore how to formally recognize building
plans, detect features salient to assessing style, apply mea-
sures of both similarity and complexity, and ultimately iden-
tify the design style. We show that 2D plan diagrams contain
both local and global features that are significant in discrim-
inating between and categorizing designs.
The remainder of this article is divided into six sections.
A survey of related work is carried out in Section 2. Qualitative
representation of 2D plans and the information theoretic
tools used in measurement are described in Section 3. The
approach is demonstrated in a study on Frank Lloyd
Wright’s residential building plans over five decades, and
the results are presented in Section 4. Section 5 discusses
various issues of this approach, and Section 6 concludes the
article.
Background
A 2D plan diagram is a primary mode of building design
representation and plays a central role in design communica-
tion. Before buildings are constructed, the problem of space
allocation has typically been explored and solved in a number
of conceptual sketches. The final sketch is then formalized in
a set of technical plans to facilitate construction.
JOURNALOF THE AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR INFORMATION SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, 57(11):1537–1550, 2006
A Qualitative Feature-Based Characterization
of 2D Architectural Style
Julie R. Jupp and John S. Gero
Key Centre of Design Computing and Cognition, G04, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia.
E-mail: {jupp_j, john}@arch.usyd.edu.au
Accepted March 24, 2005
© 2006 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
•
Published online 14 July 2006 in Wiley
InterScience (www.interscience.wiley.com). DOI: 10.1002/asi.20430