Introduction
The rate of muscle pH fall post-slaughter significantly
affects lamb meat quality through its effects on time to rigor
onset and the occurrence of cold-shortening (Chrystall and
Devine 1985). Under conditions of rapid chilling, electrical
stimulation of lamb carcasses is recommended to prevent
muscles from cold-shortening and the associated increases in
meat toughness (Chrystall and Devine 1985). Conversely,
Marsh et al. (1987) reported that electrical stimulation
increased meat toughness in beef carcasses, which exhibited
rapid glycolysis post-slaughter. Pre-slaughter stress in pigs
has also been clearly shown to increase the rate of pH fall
post-slaughter, increase the incidence of pale, soft, exudative
(PSE) meat (D’Souza et al. 1998a, 1998b) and decrease the
tenderness of aged meat (Channon et al. 2000). Pale, soft,
exudative beef muscle has recently been reported (Aalhus
et al. 1998) but it has not been reported in lamb muscle.
There is a perception that lamb carcasses are not susceptible
to PSE. The effects of pre-slaughter stress on lamb meat
quality are frequently attributed to an increased incidence of
dark-cutting high pH meat that occurs when pre-slaughter
stress causes muscle glycogen depletion (Eldridge 1989).
Swim-washing of lambs and herding with dogs before
slaughter increases the toughness of lamb meat relative to
minimal stress, although the effect was not independent of
increased ultimate pH (pH
u
) (Geesink et al. 2001). In
another study, Daly et al. (1995) reported that 20 min of
exercise stress pre-slaughter increased toughness in
electrically stimulated lamb meat. They postulated that
events specifically associated with muscular activity may
affect the tenderness of the meat independent of post-
slaughter pH fall. However, these studies did not include
measures of protein denaturation or water-holding capacity
(WHC) and it is proposed that the loss of tenderness caused
by acute pre-slaughter exercise may be the result of
denaturation of proteases pre-slaughter or early post mortem.
It is also proposed that acute pre-slaughter stress of lambs
will result in a loss in the WHC of the muscle, and any loss
in WHC is economically important to an industry that
primarily trades on weight.
The aim of the current experiment was to investigate
whether the combination of acute pre-slaughter stress and
electrical stimulation would increase toughness and reduce
the WHC in lamb meat.
Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture, 2005, 45, 553–560
0816-1089/05/050553 10.1071/EA03270 © CSIRO 2005
R. D. Warner
A,C
, D. M. Ferguson
B
, M. B. McDonagh
A
, H. A. Channon
A
, J. J. Cottrell
A
and F. R. Dunshea
A
A
Department of Primary Industries, 600 Sneydes Road, Werribee, Vic. 3030, Australia.
B
CSIRO Livestock Industries, FD McMaster Laboratory, Locked Bag 1, Armidale, NSW 2350, Australia.
C
Corresponding author. Email: Robyn.Warner@dpi.vic.gov.au
Abstract. The effects of acute exercise stress and electrical stimulation on lamb eating quality and objective
measurements of quality were evaluated on the Longissimus thoracis et lumborum (LTL) and the Gluteus medius
(GM) muscles. Meat quality attributes were also assessed on the LTL, Semimembranosus (SM) and the Semispinalis
capitis (SC) muscles. Forty-eight Poll Dorset × Border Leicester–Merino ewes of about 6 months old were randomly
allocated to treatments in a 2 × 2 factorial design, with the respective factors being exercise (Ex, 0 v. 15 min) and
post-slaughter low voltage electrical stimulation (control v. ES). In general, exercise reduced the rate of pH fall and
increased the ultimate pH of all 3 muscles (P<0.05). This effect was more pronounced in the SM than in the LTL
and SC. Exercised LTL and SM muscles also had lower surface lightness (L*) values and higher muscle total water
content, indicating an increased incidence of dark cutting meat. Exercised LTL steaks were rated higher for
tenderness and juiciness by the taste panelists and had lower Warner-Bratzler shear force values, as is often observed
with high ultimate pH meat. Electrical stimulation reduced initial pH (pH
0.5
) values, but resulted in a slower rate of
pH fall in the LTL and SM thereafter. Electrical stimulation resulted in an elevation of temperature at rigor in the
SM by 10°C (15 v. 25°C) and in the LTL by 3.1°C (7.4 v. 10.5°C). While no effect of electrical stimulation was
observed with instrumental analysis, electrical stimulation reduced sensory tenderness scores and overall liking for
the GM, and tended to reduce flavour and juiciness of both the GM and LTL. In conclusion, acute exercise pre-
slaughter improved eating quality, but caused dark cutting meat. The negative effect of low voltage stimulation on
the eating quality of the GM was probably due to a high rigor temperature and associated heat toughening.
Acute exercise stress and electrical stimulation influence the consumer
perception of sheep meat eating quality and objective quality traits
www.publish.csiro.au/journals/ajea
CSIRO PUBLISHING