Pharmacology Biochemistry & Behavior, Vol. 31, pp. 149-152. © Pergamon Press plc, 1988. Printed in the U.S.A. 0091-3057/88 $3.00 + .00
The Effect of Lowering Plasma
Tryptophan on Food Selection
in Normal Males
SIMON N. YOUNG,*t 1 SMADAR V. TOURJMAN,* KAREN L. TEFF,t
ROBERT O. PIHL*$ AND G. HARVEY ANDERSON§
*Department of Psychiatry, tThe Div&ion of Experimental Medicine, Department of Medicine
and the SDepartment of Psychology, McGill University, Montreal, Canada
and §the Department of Nutritional Sciences, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada
Received 11 December 1987
YOUNG, S. N., S. V. TOURJMAN, K. L. TEFF, R. O. PIHL AND G. H. ANDERSON. The effect of loweringplasma
tryptophan onfood selection in normalmales. PHARMACOL BIOCHEM BEHAV 31(1) 149-152, 1988.--The effects of a
tryptophan deficient amino acid mixture on food selection were studied using a double-blind counterbalanced crossover
design in normal male subjects. The subjects ingested tryptophan deficient or nutritionally balanced amino acid mixtures in
the morning after an overnight fast. Five hours after the trypotphan deficient amino acid mixture plasma tryptophan was
only 19% of the level found five hours after the nutritionally balanced amino acid mixture. After both mixtures subjects
were allowed to select lunch from a buffet. The tryptophan-deficient mixture was associated with a modest but significant
decline in protein selection with no significant alteration in selection of carbohydrate, fat or total kcal. Our results suggest
that 5-hydroxytryptamine is involved in the control of protein selection in humans.
Tryptophan 5-Hydroxytryptamine Amino acids Protein Carbohydrate Fat
THERE is a large literature concerned with the effect of
altered 5-hydroxytryptamine (5HT) function on feeding in
experimental animals [1, 3, 12]. Results vary somewhat de-
pending on the particular experimental paradigm, but in gen-
eral 5HT acts to suppress food intake. Fluctuations in 5HT
can also, in some circumstances, be involved in the modula-
tion of macronutrient selection, with elevated 5HT increas-
ing protein intake or decreasing the ratio of carbohydrate to
protein in the diet.
The possible involvement of 5HT in macronutrient selec-
tion may help to explain why 5HT is altered by dietary intake
[1, 3, 12]. The rate of synthesis of 5HT depends in part onthe
level in brain of its precursor tryptophan. The effect of acute
dietary intake on brain tryptophan is not what might intui-
tively be expected. Thus, ingestion of protein, which con-
rains tryptophan, lowers rat brain tryptophan and 5HT. This
is because all the large neutral amino acids compete for
transport across the blood-brain barrier. Protein ingestion
increases plasma levels of the other large neutral amino acids
more than tryptophan. This increased competition for the
transport system results in a lowering of tryptophan in the
brain. On the other hand carbohydrate, which contains no
tryptophan, causes an increase in brain tryptophan and 5HT.
This is because insulin enchances uptake of branched chain
amino acids into muscle, thus decreasing their plasma level
and competition at the blood-brain barrier. As protein and
carbohydrate have opposite effects on brain 5HT, and 5HT
may control relative intakes of protein and carbohydrate,
5HT may be part of a system ensuring that an animal takes in
adequate supplies of both these macronutrients.
A possible role of 5HT in food selection in humans has
been studied by giving tryptophan. Tryptophan was given
over a 2-week period to obese subjects with a craving for
carbohydrate snacks. It significantly diminished carbo-
hydrate intake in three of the eight subjects, and increased it
in one subject. It did not significantly modify snacking pat-
terns in the group as a whole [11]. Tryptophan was also
tested against placebo in a double-blind crossover study of
eight refractory carbohydrate-craving obese subjects in a
weight loss program. Weight loss during the six weeks on
tryptophan was not significantly different from the six weeks
on placebo [10]. Tryptophan was also tested against placebo
in a double-blind crossover study in healthy lean men. Tryp-
tophan in doses from 1 to 3 g, or placebo, was given 45 min
1Requests for reprints should be addressed to Dr. S. N. Young, Department of Psychiatry, McGill University, 1033 Pine Avenue West,
Montreal, Canada, H3A IA1.
149