ABSTRACT: In the present study, the probability of packaged
olive oil not reaching the end of its shelf life, P
safe
, was used as a
quality factor to evaluate the time taken for olive oils stored at
various conditions to reach the end of their shelf lives. P
safe
was
used to comment on the activation energy required during the
degradation process per actual or simulated case, and hexanal
was used as the main quality-related indicator. Based on the
month after bottling at which P
safe
reached 70%, the activation
energy of an “equivalent” chemical reaction, representative of
overall quality degradation, was calculated for several storage
conditions. Using the differences between activation energies es-
timated using the above method, we found the most important
factors influencing the shelf life of the packaged olive oil to be
the initial storage period in the dark, the role of elevated temper-
atures, and the presence of light, either continuous or in alternat-
ing patterns, in association with the packaging materials used in
this study. These results were in qualitative agreement with previ-
ously reported experimental observations and simulations, indi-
cating the validity of using P
safe
, and of activation energies calcu-
lated from it, to predict the shelf life of packaged olive oil.
Paper no. J10976 in JAOCS 82, 119–123 (February 2005).
KEY WORDS: Activation energy, flavors, olive oil, oxidation,
packaging, shelf-life prediction.
The type of material (plastics, glass, tin), the storage conditions
(light, temperature), and the storage period can significantly in-
fluence the quality of olive oil (1–5). Plastic bottles are used
extensively for packing and bottling vegetable oils, but they are
not always suitable for this purpose (6). Kiritsakis and Dugan
(7) studied the relative effects of plastic and glass bottles on the
oxidation of olive oil exposed to diffused light. They demon-
strated the role of light and oxygen on the quality of the olive
oil through the evolution of the PV. They also found that olive
oil stored in colorless glass bottles and exposed to diffused light
lost all of the chlorophyll and about 70% of the carotene con-
tent. Another key parameter is the oxygen permeability of the
container, since olive oil kept in bottles permeable to air (e.g.,
polyethylene and polypropylene) should be sold within 4 wk
(8–10). Poly(vinyl chloride) (PVC) bottles with lower air per-
meability can hold olive oil for 3 mon.
The importance of monitoring temperature during oil pro-
cessing, distribution, and storage becomes evident by recogniz-
ing the effect of temperature abuse, which may result in a signif-
icant reduction of the shelf life. The time for a food product to
reach the end of its shelf life (response time) could be established
for a range of temperatures under isothermal conditions. These
data could be applied to the Arrhenius equation, and the activa-
tion energy of the product could be determined. Among others,
the activation energy approach was implemented previously to
study the role of temperature on the kinetics of the spoilage
process, e.g., to evaluate the application of an enzyme process-
based time–temperature integrator (11) in the reduction of the L-
ascorbic acid of green vegetables in the temperature range of
freezing storage (12), or for the degradation of antioxidants and
antioxidant activity in tomato products (pulp, puree, and paste)
submitted to accelerated aging (13).
Among the applications used to monitor the quality of
olive oil based on the reaction kinetics during storage were
kinetic studies of the thermodegradation reaction of the oils
conducted by Paz and Molero (14,15). Their results showed
that the oxidizing atmosphere has a negative influence on the
thermal stability of the oils. This work suggested that con-
sumable vegetable oils could be characterized not only by
their thermogravimetrical curves but also by the kinetic data
deduced. The influence of a series of metals (iron, copper, tin,
and lead) on the thermal stability of olive oils of different ori-
gins and refined grades was studied, and the influence of iron
and tin on oil oxidation, compared with copper and lead, was
demonstrated (16). Changes in the degradation rate also were
compared with degradation in the absence of metals, confirm-
ing the negative influence of iron and tin on the oil oxidation
process, regardless of the kind of oil tested. Furthermore, the
pheophytin-A photodecomposition process, at 15, 40, and
50°C and at three different luminous energies, was developed
according to a first-order reaction (16). From the Arrhenius
straight lines, it appeared that the incident luminous energy
did not change the activation energy but increased the reac-
tion frequency factor.
Having recognized that data on the oxidative degradation ki-
netics in packaged olive oil are scarce, in the present work we
applied the activation energy concept to extra virgin olive oil
packaged in various packaging materials and stored under a wide
range of storage conditions. A better understanding of the syner-
gistic effects among oxidation-favoring parameters during stor-
age would allow a valuable quality-predicting methodology to
be introduced for packaged olive oil.
Copyright © 2005 by AOCS Press 119 JAOCS, Vol. 82, no. 2 (2005)
*To whom correspondence should be addressed.
E-mail: frank@ipta.demokritos.gr
Use of the Activation Energy Concept to Estimate
The Quality Reduction of Packaged Olive Oil
Frank Coutelieris
a,
* and Antonis Kanavouras
b
a
National Center for Scientific Research “Demokritos,” 15310 Aghia Paraskevi Attikis, Greece, and
b
Unilever Europe,
Spreads and Cooking Products Category, Nassaukade 3, 3071 JL, Rotterdam, The Netherlands