Abstract Concentrations of butyltin compounds (BTs)
were determined in harbour porpoise (Phocoena pho-
coena) collected from the Turkish coastal waters of the
Black Sea. Total butyltin compounds (∑ BTs) in the liver
were in the range of 89–219 ng/g on a wet weight basis.
The dibutyltin (DBT) residues were higher than those of
tributyltin (TBT), suggesting the degradation of TBT to
DBT in the liver and the metabolic capacity comparable
to other marine mammals. Any sex difference and age-de-
pendent accumulation of BTs residues were not found in
harbour porpoises, but residue levels increased until ma-
turity and then remained constant. When compared with
other marine mammals, the present results indicate that
the Black Sea is also contaminated with butyltin com-
pounds, but to a lesser degree than coastal waters of de-
veloped nations. The biomagnification factor in harbour
porpoises was 0.8, which was comparable with pinnipeds
and lower than cetaceans.
Introduction
The wide application of organotin compounds such as
tributlytin (TBT) in industry and agriculture has been the
subject of concern over the past few decades. These
chemicals have extensively been used as antifouling
paints for vessels and fishing nets and also as herbicides,
disinfectants, biocides for cooling systems and stabilizers
for PVC plastics. With this use, considerable amounts of
organotin compounds have entered the marine environ-
ment and caused toxic effects to aquatic organisms [1].
These compounds are hazardous to a wide range of aquatic
organisms as evidenced by the thickening of shell and
failure of spat in oysters [2], impotence of neogastropods
and gastropods [3–6], reduction of dogwhelk populations
[7, 8], retardation of growth in mussels [9] and immuno-
logical dysfunction in fish [10].
Despite the large amount of toxicological and residue
data of organotin compounds in aquatic organisms, the
monitoring studies of marine mammals have been started
only recently. As the first report, butyltin compounds
(BTs) were detected in various tissues of cetaceans from
the western North Pacific, Bay of Bengal and Japanese
coastal waters and found in significant concentrations [11,
12]. Since these findings, BTs were determined in other
marine mammals, such as bottlenose dolphins from Ital-
ian coastal waters [13] and USA coastal waters [14],
Risso’s dolphins [15], Stellar sea lions [16] from Japan
and Ganges River dolphins from India [17]. However, the
BTs in higher trophic mammals from various parts of the
world, especially Middle East countries, have not been
sufficiently studied yet.
To understand the present status of contamination by
BTs in the Black Sea aquatic ecosystem, an effort has
been made in this study to determine TBT and its deriva-
tives (DBT: dibutyltin and MBT: monobutyltin) in har-
bour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) and its diet. To our
knowledge, no information is available on the accumula-
tion of organotin compounds in any animal from the
Black Sea. Harbour porpoise is a coastal species and in
Bathini Madhusree · Shinsuke Tanabe ·
Ayaka Amaha Öztürk · Ryo Tatsukawa ·
Nobuyuki Miyazaki · Emin Özdamar · Orhan Aral ·
Osman Samsun · Bayram Öztürk
Contamination by butyltin compounds
in harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) from the Black Sea
Fresenius J Anal Chem (1997) 359 : 244–248 © Springer-Verlag 1997
Received: 23 December 1996 / Revised: 15 April 1997 / Accepted: 16 April 1997
ORIGINAL PAPER
Dedicated to Professor Dr. Karlheinz Ballschmiter
on the occasion of his 60th birthday
B. Madhusree · S. Tanabe () · R. Tatsukawa
Department of Environment Conservation, Ehime University,
Tarumi 3-5-7, Matsuyama 790, Japan
A. A. Öztürk
Science and Technology Institute, Istanbul University, Ordu Cad,
No. 200, Laleli, Istanbul, Turkey
N. Miyazaki
Otsuchi Marine Research Center, Ocean Research Institute,
The University of Tokyo, Akahama, Otsuchi-cho,
Iwate 028-11, Japan
E. Özdamar
Technical Cooperation Division, JICA Turkey Office,
Ugur Mumcu Cad. 88/16, Gazi Osman Pasa, 06700, Ankara, Turkey
O. Aral · O. Samsun
Sinop Faculty of Fisheries, Ondokuz Mayis University,
Sinop 57000, Turkey
B. Öztürk
Faculty of Fisheries, Istanbul University, Ordu Cad, No. 200,
Laleli, Istanbul, Turkey