Standardized Assessment of
Concussion (SAC): On-Site Mental
Status Evaluation of the Athlete
Objective: This study investigated the clinical utility of the Standardized Assessment of Concussion (SAC)
in detecting concussion in athletes. Method: Athletic trainers administered the SAC to 568 nonconcussed
high school and college football players prior to the 1995 and 1996football seasons. Thirty-three of these
players experienced concussion and were tested immediately following injury; 28 of the 33 underwent
additional follow-up testing 48 hours after the injury. Results: Concussed players scored significantly
below nonconcussed controls on all SAC measures and significantly below their own pre-injury baseline
performance. Follow-up testing documented return to preinjury baseline. Conclusion: These findings
support the SAC's effectiveness in detecting concussion and tracking recovery in order to determine a
player's fitness to return to play. Key words: brain injury, concussion, mental status, neuropsychologi-
cal tests, sports injuries, Standardized Assessment of Concussion
Michael McCrea, PhD
Head of Neuropsychology Service*
James P. Kelly, MD
Director, Brain Injury Program*
Christopher Randolph, PhD
Associate Professor of Neurology*
Private Practice
Jon Kluge, PT/ATC
Employer and Community Health Services
Leader1
Edward Bartolic, PhD
Assistant Professor of Psychiatry^'
George Finn, ATC
Director of Sports Medicine11
Brian Baxter, BS
Assistant Athletic Trainer*
* Waukesha Memorial Hospital, Waukesba, Wisconsin.
' Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois.
* Loyola University Medical Center, Chicago, Illinois.
f Covenant Medical Center, Waterloo, Iowa.
1] Allegheny University of the Health Sciences,
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
' Bates College, Lewiston, Maine.
* University of Wisconsin-Platteville, Platteville,
Wisconsin.
Address correspondence to M. McCrea, Waukesha Me-
morial Hospital, 725 American Avenue, Waukesha, WI
53188.
RATIONALE AND SIGNIFICANCE
There has been a heightened awareness of
the possible effects of concussion suffered by
athletes in recent years as brain injury in orga-
nized sports becomes the focus of increasing
attention from medical personnel responsible
for the care of athletes, administrative bodies
governing various sports, and the media. Al-
though more research has focused on sports-
related concussion in recent years, there are
few controlled prospective studies in the sci-
entific literature.1 Epidemiologic and retro-
spective studies have documented football as
one of the sports with the highest rates of
concussion,2 with an estimated 100,000 such
injuries annually in organized football alone
(personal communication, John Powell, PhD,
The athletic training staff at the following institutions
are acknowledged for their help in collecting data dur-
ing the 1995 and 1996 seasons: Cedar Falls High
School, Waterloo Columbus High School, Waterloo East
High School, Waterloo West High School, Philadelphia
Roman Catholic High School, Philadelphia Episcopal
Academy, St. Ambrose University, Bates College, and
Colby College. The authors also acknowledge the coach-
ing staff and players at each institution for their coop-
eration and participation in the study.
JHead Trauma Rehabil 1998;13(2):27-35
© 1998 Aspen Publishers, Inc.
27