An International Survey of the Use
and Attitudes Regarding Alternative Medicine
by Patients With Inflammatory Bowel Disease
Patricia Rawsthorne, R.N., Fergus Shanahan, M.D., Neil C. Cronin, M.D., Peter A. Anton, M.D.,
Robert Lo ¨fberg, M.D., Lena Bohman, R.N., and Charles N. Bernstein, M.D.
Departments of Medicine, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada; National University of
Ireland, Cork, Ireland; University of California, Los Angeles, California; and Karolinska Institute,
Stockholm, Sweden
OBJECTIVE: There is a perception of increasing and wide-
spread use of alternative medicine for inflammatory bowel
disease (IBD). We assessed the usage of alternative thera-
pies among patients with IBD, whether there were similar or
contrasting variables that were predictive of such use, and
contrasted the use in four different centers in North America
and Europe.
METHODS: Patients in four IBD centers completed a self-
administered questionnaire regarding alternative medicine.
The centers were in Cork, Los Angeles, Stockholm, and
Winnipeg. Patient demographics, the use of 18 types of
alternative medicine, and attitudes towards alternative and
conventional medicine were compared. A multiple logistic
regression analysis was used.
RESULTS: Fifty-one percent of 289 patients used some form
of alternative medicine. The percentages of use by site were
Cork = 31%, Los Angeles = 68%, Stockholm = 32%, and
Winnipeg = 57%. The six most commonly used therapies in
descending order were: exercise (28%), prayer (18%), coun-
seling (13%), massage (11%), chiropractic (11%), and re-
laxation (10%). Only 7% used acupuncture or homeopathy
and 5% used herbal medicine. The highest odds ratios (con-
fidence intervals [CIs]) for using any form of alternative
medicine were associated with: being single 3.1 (1.7–5.7),
Los Angeles patient 4.4 (2.3– 8.3), Winnipeg patient 2.7
(1.3–5.9), and an increase of alternative medicine use of
2.7% for every M.D. visit (CI, 2–11%/visit). The patient
age, gender, disease diagnosis, or duration of disease were
not predictive of any type of alternative medicine use. Re-
garding attitudes, respondents from Cork were most favor-
able toward alternative medicine use and least favorable
toward conventional medicine. Based on attitudes, subjects
were more likely to use alternative medicine if they were not
satisfied with conventional therapy, viewed hospitals as
dangerous places, thought that alternative medicine practi-
tioners should have a role in hospitals, and felt their medical
situation was hopeless.
CONCLUSIONS: Fifty-one percent of respondents used some
form of alternative medicine. The use was greater among the
North American patients than the European ones. Respon-
dents were more likely to use alternative medicine if they
were single, in a higher income bracket, and an urban
dweller. (Am J Gastroenterol 1999;94:1298 –1303. © 1999
by Am. Coll. of Gastroenterology)
INTRODUCTION
There appears to be increasing attention paid to alternative
medicine use by patients with chronic illnesses (1–3). A
1995 Consumer Reports article reported that sales of natural
herbal remedies alone are growing by an estimated 15%/yr,
and now total $1.5 billion, almost half the amount spent on
regular vitamins and minerals (4). Inflammatory bowel dis-
ease (IBD) is a chronic relapsing illness, which may require
invasive investigations, surgery, and loss of time from work,
and may have an adverse impact on patients’ personal and
professional lives. Conventional therapies can be associated
with adverse effects and, at times, may not be successful at
achieving disease remission or even lesser treatment goals.
Patients may seek alternative medicine for symptomatic
relief and as a novel approach when conventional medicine
has incompletely satisfied their health care needs or failed to
provide them with some sense of control over their illness
(5). For some, it may reflect their disgruntlement with their
physicians or with conventional medicine in general, as it
may be seen as too complex and technologically oriented,
impersonal, costly, inconvenient, unavailable, or inaccessi-
ble (1, 6). At present, there are wide ranging sources of
information regarding alternative medicine available to the
consumer through print and electronic media, including the
Internet (7, 8).
To determine the extent of alternative medicine usage
among patients with IBD, we conducted a multicenter sur-
vey asking patients from four countries about their use and
attitudes toward alternative medicine. In particular, we
sought to determine what factors might encourage a patient
THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF GASTROENTEROLOGY Vol. 94, No. 5, 1999
© 1999 by Am. Coll. of Gastroenterology ISSN 0002-9270/99/$20.00
Published by Elsevier Science Inc. PII S0002-9270(99)00136-7