440
Nonorthogonal solution for thin-walled
members — applications and modelling
considerations
1
R. Emre Erkmen and Magdi Mohareb
Abstract: In a companion paper (R.E. Erkmen and M. Mohareb. 2006. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, 33:
421–439.), three finite elements based on the Vlasov thin-walled beam theory were formulated using a nonorthogonal
coordinate system. Although the associated derivations are more elaborate than in more conventional solutions based
on orthogonal coordinates, the new elements offer more modelling capabilities and flexibility in modelling structural
steel members, a feature that is illustrated in this paper. In this context, the current paper presents four details in steel
construction that were conveniently modelled within the new solution scheme. The applications involve thin-walled
members with coped flanges, rectangular holes reinforced with longitudinal stiffeners, and eccentric supports. Comparisons
with established shell finite element models using ABAQUS suggest the validity of the new solution.
Key words: open sections, finite element analysis, thin-walled members, coped flanges, rectangular holes, eccentric
supports.
Résumé : Dans un article connexe (R.E. Erkmen and M. Mohareb. 2006. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, 33 : 421–
439.), trois éléments finis fondés sur la théorie de Vlasov sur les poutres à parois minces ont été formulés dans un système
de coordonnées cartésiennes orthogonales. Bien que les dérivées connexes soient plus élaborées que celles dans des
solutions plus conventionnelles basées sur les coordonnées cartésiennes orthogonales, les nouveaux éléments offrent plus
de capacités et de flexibilité de modélisation lors de la modélisation d’éléments structuraux en acier, une caractéristique
qui est examinée dans le présent article. Dans cet ordre d’idées, cet article présente quatre détails d’une construction en
acier modélisés dans le nouveau schéma de solution. Les utilisations impliquent des poutres à parois minces munies de
semelles en contre-profilé, de trous rectangulaires renforcés par des éléments de charpente de renforcement et des supports
excentriques. Les comparaisons aux modèles établis d’éléments finis de l’enveloppe dans le logiciel ABAQUS attestent la
validité de la nouvelle solution.
Mots clés : profils ouverts, analyse par éléments finis, poutres à parois minces, semelles en contre-profilé, trous rectangu-
laires, supports excentriques.
[Traduit par la Rédaction]
Overview of companion paper
In the companion paper (Erkmen and Mohareb 2006), three
finite elements were developed based on the Vlasov thin-walled
beam theory (Vlasov 1961). The solutions adopted nonconven-
tional coordinate systems in contrast to conventional formula-
tions in which orthogonal coordinate systems are used
S
x
=
A
x dA = 0, S
y
=
A
y dA = 0
Received 1 December 2004. Revision accepted 6 February 2006.
Published on the NRC Research Press Web site at http://cjce.nrc.ca/
on 2 June 2006.
R.E. Erkmen and M. Mohareb.
2
Department of Civil Engineer-
ing, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, ON K1N 6N5, Canada.
Written discussion of this article is welcomed and will be received
by the Editor until 31 August 2006.
1
This article is one of a selection of papers published in this
Special Issue on Steel Research.
2
Corresponding author (e-mail: mmohareb@uottawa.ca).
S
ω
=
A
ω dA = 0, J
xy
=
A
xy dA = 0
J
ωx
=
A
ωx dA = 0, J
ωy
=
A
ωy dA = 0
Coordinates x = x(s),y = y(s) are those of a point located
on the section midsurface denoted by a curvilinear coordinate
s measured from an arbitrary sectorial origin s
0
on the midsur-
face. The sectorial coordinate ω = ω (s
0
,s) is twice the area en-
closed by the fixed radius Os
0
(where O is an arbitrarily selected
origin point in the plane of the cross section), mobile radius Os ,
and curved sector s
0
s (see Erkmen and Mohareb 2006, Fig. 1).
All integrals are performed over the cross-sectional area A.
The first element, nonorthogonal Vlasov element based on
exact shape functions, with 14 degrees of freedom (NOVEE14),
is based on shape functions that exactly satisfy the coupled form
of the Vlasov homogeneous form of the differential equations
of equilibrium. As a result, it is expected to yield nodal displace-
ments in exact agreement with those based on an exact solution
of the Vlasov equations. The second element, nonorthogonal
Vlasov element based on cubic shape functions, with 14 degrees
Can. J. Civ. Eng. 33: 440–450 (2006) doi: 10.1139/L06-027 © 2006 NRC Canada