Column curves for elliptical hollow section members
Farhood Nowzartash ⁎, Magdi Mohareb
University of Ottawa, Department of Civil Engineering, 161 Louis Pasteur, Room A106, Room A106 Ottawa161 Louis Pasteur Room A106 Ottawa, Ottawa, ON, Canada K1N-6N5
abstract article info
Article history:
Received 17 November 2010
Accepted 30 March 2011
Available online 4 May 2011
Keywords:
Elliptical hollow sections
Plasticity
Residual stresses
Initial imperfection
A thermo-mechanical finite element analysis model is developed to predict residual stress patterns in hot-
rolled sections. The model is first verified against experimental measurements for residual stresses reported
for I-sections reported in the literature. The method is then used to predict residual stresses in elliptical
hollow sections. A sensitivity analysis is then conducted to assess the influence of various input parameters of
the model on the predicted residual stress patterns. The effects of cross-section geometric parameters on the
residual stress distribution are then investigated.
A series of column curves is generated providing the compressive capacity of a column as a function of
slenderness. The column curves are generated based on a) elasto-plastic geometrically nonlinear analyses,
b) including the effect of residual stresses as predicted from thermo-mechanical analyses and c) incorporating
initial geometric out-of straightness according to the fundamental buckling mode as predicted from an elastic
buckling eigen value analysis. Generated column curves are then compared to those in current design codes. A
best fit for the numeric results obtained is conducted to cast them in a format similar to that in the current
codes.
© 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction and scope
Elliptical hollow sections (EHS) have emerged relatively recently
as structural steel members. With their increasing popularity as a
structural option among architects, recent research has focused on
investigating their behaviour and developing design rules. This
includes the lower bound interaction relations for EHS subject to
combinations of axial force, bi-axial bending moments and torsion [1].
Also, upper bound interaction relations were developed for EHS which
included the additional effects of bi-moments induced in EHS at their
fixed ends [2]. The interaction relations developed were based on the
plastic cross-sectional capacity resistance and do not include member
stability effects. In this context, this paper reports an investigation on
the stability of EHS aimed at numerically developing column curves
for EHS, which account for residual stresses, slenderness effects, and
out-of-straightness imperfections. The column curves developed in
the present paper can be used in conjunction with the interaction
relations developed in [1,2] to provide interaction relations which
account slenderness effect, a necessary step towards adopting them in
structural design.
In addition to column slenderness, the compressive capacity of
columns is known to be influenced by 1) material plasticity,
2) residual stresses and 3) initial out-of-straightness. Other factors
such as material variability and load eccentricity can also play a role
[3] on column strength, but will not be investigated within the present
study. A methodology is described and verified against available
experimental results to predict the residual stress in EHS members.
Initial imperfections are determined using elastic buckling analysis.
Given the residual stresses and out-of-straightness predicted a series
of nonlinear load deformation FEA including material and geometric
nonlinearity is to be conducted to generate points on the column
curves.
2. Literature review
2.1. Residual stresses in hot rolled sections
In hot rolled sections, residual stresses are induced by the uneven
cooling within the different parts of the section. I-sections are the
most widely members used in steel construction. Also, they are more
susceptible to uneven cooling compared to closed sections. Hence,
most residual stress investigations in structural steel members were
devoted to I-sections. Residual stresses were measured and reported
in a number of publications (e.g., [4–9]). Galambos and Ketter [10] and
Young [11] proposed a simplified self-balanced residual stress
patterns for I-sections based on curves conservatively fitted to
measured residual stress data. Later on, Szalai and Papp [12] modified
these patterns to additionally satisfy the torsional equilibrium of the
cross section.
The works by Weiner [13] and Landau et al. [14] are among the
earliest attempts to analytically model residual stress in hot-rolled
sections. Given the complexity of behaviour of steel during the cooling
Journal of Constructional Steel Research 67 (2011) 1525–1536
⁎ Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: fnowz064@uottawa.ca (F. Nowzartash), mmohareb@uottawa.ca
(M. Mohareb).
0143-974X/$ – see front matter © 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jcsr.2011.03.026
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Constructional Steel Research