J. Child Psychol. Psychiat. Vol. 27, No. 4, pp. 539-544, 1986 0021-9630/86 $3.00 + 0.00
Printed in Great Britain. Pergaraon Journals Ltd.
© 1986 Association for Child Psychology and Psychiatry.
RESEARCH NOTE: TEMPERAMENT AND BEHAVIOUR IN
SIX-YEAR-OLDS WITH RECURRENT ABDOMINAL
PAIN: A FOLLOW UP
I. S. DAVISON, C. FAULLand A. R. NICOL
Human Development Unit, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, U.K.
Abstract—Dimensions of temperament and behaviour were measured in a group of infant school
children with recurrent abdominal pain and in a control group. Children with recurrent abdominal
pain were temperamentally more difficult than those without, and in particular, girls were found to
have a more irregular temperamental style and boys to be more likely to withdraw in new situations.
Temperamental differences were more persistent than the abdominal pain itself. There was little
difference behaviourally between the groups. It is hypothesized that abdominal pain represents an
interaction between a vulnerable temperamental style and environmental stresses.
Keywords: Abdominal pain, temperament
INTRODUCTION
RECURRENT abdominal pain is a common problem in children. Apley (1975),
defining the condition as at least three episodes of incapacitating pain over not less
than 3 months, found a prevalence of 10%. FauU and Nicol (1986) found a prevalence
of about 25% in their study of a large sample of infant school children, confirming
that prevalence is higher in the early school years. This study is a follow up of a
sample of their population.
Several authors have commented on the strong association of recurrent abdominal
pain with emotional problems and certain personality types. Stone and Barbero
(1970) studied 102 children with recurrent abdominal pain and found many of their
patients to be insecure and sensitive. A typical description of a child by his parents
was "a very good child who tries hard to please and is a constant worrier". Many
children were able to identify points of stress as precipitants for their pain. Apley
(1975) found a raised prevailence of highly strung, fussy and excitable children, and
of anxious, timid and apprehensive children amongst a group of 100 children with
recurrent abdominal pain, when compared with a control group. Liebman (1978)
described 30% of his group of 119 children with recurrent abdominal pain as
'perfectionistic'. It is clear that the psychological aspects of recurrent abdominal
pain require further study (Galler, Neustein & Walker, 1980; Nicol, 1982). Faull
and Nicol (1986) found associations with psychiatric disorder both at home and at
school. There were also associations with social support of the mother, difficulties in
settling into school and status of home ownership.
Requests for reprints to: Dr A. R. Nicol, Nuffield Psychology and Psychiatry Unit, 1 Tankerville
Terrace, Newcastle upon Tyne NE2 3AH.
Accepted manuscript received 26 April 1985
539