Business Management and Computing Research Colloquium (BMCRC) 2016, Raub, Malaysia, 25 May 2016
ISBN 978-967-14020-0-9 ©BMCRC2016
18
Smart Trader: A Simulation Game in
Accumulating Wealth
Nor Aziah Abd Kadir
Faculty of Business Management
UiTM Cawangan Pahang Kampus Raub
27600 Raub, Pahang, Malaysia
aziahkadir@pahang.uitm.edu.my
Khalid Mat Pardi
Academy of Language Studies
UiTM Cawangan Pahang Kampus Raub
27600 Raub, Pahang, Malaysia
khalidmp@pahang.uitm.edu.my
Nurul Afzan Najid
Faculty of Accountancy
UiTM Cawangan Pahang Kampus Raub
27600 Raub, Pahang, Malaysia
nurulafzan@pahang.uitm.edu.my
Abstract — Production is a process of transforming resources
into goods and services that have exchange value. It is a very
tough topic where students need to identify the best production
processes, determine the significant selling price of the product
and services and plan the competitive strategies in order to be
efficient and gain more profit. Students may conclude to
misunderstand the concept and not confident in making business
decision. Too many theories and concepts may hurt students’
concentration and contribute to complexity in their study. The
introduction of Smart Trader game in class as an interactive
learning style may help students a lot compare to the
conventional method such as having lecture and reading
textbooks. In this game, students are divided into three groups.
Each group has been given an envelope consists of different set of
resources. They need to produce paper boxes and sell them to the
trader to get the best selling price. At this stage, students need to
determine the cost of production, set mark-up price and sell the
product to a local market trader with agreed selling price.
Students also have to prepare the financial statement as a
document to disclose the financial activities and position of a
business. Using an experimental approach, this paper compares
the performance of students when they learn through the game
and lecture. The result shows that students can increase their
understanding in production theory and achieve higher grade
when game is applied in the class compare to traditional method
of learning.
Keywords — accumulation wealth; costing; production; simulation
game; trade
I. INTRODUCTION
Production is a common topic discussed in the economics
and accounting subjects. Students often hold misconception
and confusion about this topic as it relates to the business trade
activities. Too many formulas, concepts and theories need to
be memorized in this topic. Since the process of learning all
these seems too complex, lecturers need to find an alternative
way to make it easier and more interesting for the students.
In many business courses, simulation games are becoming
a popular choice of pedagogical technique. Yet, research is
beginning to consider how these simulation games could affect
student's performance. The objective of this paper is to
identify the effectiveness of the innovative learning style using
a simulation game as proposed the ‘Smart Trader Game’
compared to the conventional method such as having lecture
and reading textbooks. The traditional class format, based on
lectures and problem sets are inadequate in meeting the
learning needs of current students [1]. Other previous
researchers [2] also opined that, there should be a paradigm
shift in collegiate teaching where teacher-centered learning
environment seems ineffective for teaching accounting
subject. Hence, they implied that learning-centered approach
should be practiced as a way to encourage students to have a
better learning experience in class, achieve good results and
able to produce significant and lasting change.
Furthermore, every student should be treated as an
individual since they have different levels of motivation,
commitment, ability, and learning styles or approaches.
Because of that they receive and process information
differently [3]. Therefore, educational practitioners need to
find alternatives for the teaching and learning process, so that
it can be delivered effectively. The best learning styles which
suit students’ characteristics may increase their motivation and
lead to better learning experience. The closest alternative that
can be referred to this situation is by adopting the ‘learning
through play’ environment during the teaching and learning
process. This is because everybody does understand the
language of ‘play’ regardless of age, ethnic, economic or
social background [4]. Therefore, games can be a suitable
medium for students to explore and collect information in a
fun and interactive ways.
The Smart Trader Game has been proposed to create an
active and innovative learning as an alternative to the
conventional learning style. This Smart Trader Game is an
improvisation of the Trade Game [5] where in this version the
element of costing is included. The game introduced was easy