International Journal of Basic & Applied Sciences IJBAS-IJENS Vol: 10 No: 06 5
100506-3939 IJBAS-IJENS © December 2010 IJENS
I J E N S
Preparation and characterization of sulfated titania catalysts for the
isomerisation of citronellal
S. N. Aisyiyah Jenie*, Dona S. Kusuma, Anis Kristiani, Joddy A. Laksmono, Silvester Tursiloadi
Research Centre for Chemistry, Indonesian Institute of Sciences-LIPI, Kawasan PUSPIPTEK, Serpong,
Tangerang 15314 Indonesia, Ph. : +62 21 7560929, Fax: +62 21 7560549
Mesoporous sulfated titania xerogels with structural and catalytic properties were prepared by the modified sol-gel method using
surfactant as templates. The sulfate loading of these catalyst materials were varied in the range of 0 to 50 wt% SO
4
2-
. Characterization
of the sulfated titania were evaluated by transmission electron microscopy, N
2
adsorption and X-ray diffraction. The addition of sulfate
has decreased the crystalline size and induces the structural transformation from rutile to anatase. The best sample catalyst was
attained at TS5 containing 5 wt% of sulfate and having equal strength of both Brønsted and Lewis acid site. Sulfated titania show
good activity towards citronellal isomerization at 95°C using toluene as solvent. Conversion of citronellal correlates with the the
surface acidity of the catalyst and the use of toluene as solvent in the reaction, while the selectivity towards (-)-isopulegol depends on
the corresponding acid site strength.
Keywords—catalyst, citronellal, isopulegol, sulfated titania
I. INTRODUCTION
Recently, non-polluting and efficient catalytic technologies
are much required, considering that environmental restrictions
on emissions are covered in several legislations throughout the
world. Solid acids have begun to replace highly corrosive,
hazardous and polluting liquid acids. The substitution of
homogeneous liquid acids by heterogeneous solid superacids
as catalysts is expected to ease their separation from reacting
mixture, allowing continuous operation as well as regeneration
and neutralization of the catalyst [1] and lowering the cost of
process installation and maintenance [2]. Solid acids leading
to better regio- and stereoselectivity have been extensively
studied, which is effected not only by the acid strength but
also the type of acidity (Brønsted or Lewis)[2-4,6].
Sulfated metal oxides have been tested as catalysts. The
most studied sulfated oxides are ZrO
2
and TiO
2
. Sulfated
titania or its mixture with other oxide such as ZrO
2
, has been
found to be efficient catalysts for isomerization, alkylation,
Friedel-Crafts acylation, esterifaction, photocatalytic oxidation
and reduction of NOx [1,2,7-9]. The acid strength for the
sulfated metal oxides is high, stronger than 100% sulfuric acid
[2,4]. It has been reported that for SO
4
2-
/TiO
2
and SO
4
2-
/ZrO
2
,
the Hammet acidity is, H
0
≤ -14.52 and H
0
≥ -14.52
respectively, as compared with that of H
2
SO
4
, H
0
≤ -12 [7].
Sulfated metal oxides has been found to catalyze the
isomerization or cyclisation of citronellal to isopulegol.
Isopulegol is an important intermediate in the manufacture of
menthols (C
10
H
20
O), which have a characteristic peppermint
odor. Of the eight optically active menthols, only (-)-menthol,
derived from the hydrogenation of (-)-isopulegol, possesses
the characteristic peppermint odour and exerts a cooling effect
[6, 10,11]. Previous reports have shown the isomerization of
d-citronellal using sulfated zirconia/ SO
4
2-
ZrO
2
as catalyst
[3,4]. Yadav and Nair (1996) has reported that besides the
Brønsted acid sites are more needed compared to the Lewis
acid site, the pore size of the catalyst should also be taken into
account during the isomerization process [3]. Chuah and
coworkers (2001), on the other hand have reported that active
catalyst are the ones possessing strong Lewis and weak
Brønsted acidity [4]. The sulfated zirconia system has been
studied most comprehensively because of its acidity being the
highest of the sulfate oxides [3-5]. However, previous works
also show that isomerization of citronellal do not require such
high acidity values, which frequently induce side reactions [4].
Therefore in this work, we propose the use of sulfated titania
for the isomerization process.
Besides the acidity properties, the physical properties of
the catalyst are also important. The properties of catalysts
strongly depend on the preparation procedures. The high
porosity and the large specific surface area of materials
prepared by the sol-gel method make them very attractive
from a catalytic point of view [12]. The sol-gel method not
only allows good control of the characteristics of the support,
but also offers the possibility of preparing oxide-supported
metal catalysts from a homogenous solution containing both
the catalytic metal precursor and the support precursor [13]. A
metal alkoxide undergoes hydrolysis and subsequent
condensation in an alcohol solvent, forming a polymer oxide
network entraining the alcohol. For catalytic uses, the liquid
solvent must be removed from the alcogel. In conventional
drying, a liquid-vapor interface forms in the pores and the
corresponding surface tension collapses the oxide network,
thereby reducing the surface area [14]. To prevent the
collapsing of the oxide network, most work usually apply the
removal of solvents by supercritical drying [13,14]. Another
different approach during the removal of solvents is by using
surfactants as a template to fabricate porous materials and to
improve the alcogel properties [13,15]. By immersing the wet
alcogels in surfactant solution before drying, the oxide
network will be prevented from collapsing.
Catalysts prepared using TiO
2
as supports are at least two
or three times more active than the equivalent Al
2
O
3
supported
catalyst, measured on either a surface area, weight, or atomic
basis. However, because of the typical low surface area of
these supports, usually less than 50 m
2
/g, the volume activity
is much lower than that of Al
2
O
3
supports, which usually have
*Corresponding author: S. N. Aisyiyah Jenie (e-mail: siti045@lipi.go.id).