Surfactant-free emulsion electrosynthesis via power
ultrasound: electrocatalytic formation of carbon–carbon bonds
Trevor J. Davies,
a
Craig E. Banks,
a
Bharathi Nuthakki,
b
James F. Rusling,
b
Robert R.
France,
c
Jay D. Wadhawan
a
and Richard G. Compton*
a
a
Physical and Theoretical Chemistry Laboratory, Oxford University, South Parks Road,
Oxford, UK OX1 3QZ. E-mail: compton@ermine.ox.ac.uk; Fax: +44 (0) 1865 275 410;
Tel: +44 (0) 1865 275 413
b
Department of Chemistry, Box U-60, University of Connecticut, Storrs, Connecticut
06269-3060, USA
c
Dyson Perrins Laboratory, Oxford University, South Parks Road, Oxford, UK OX1 3QY
Received 12th June 2002
First published as an Advance Article on the web 25th September 2002
Proof-of-concept of the mediated electrosynthesis of carbon–carbon bonds in totally ‘green’ surfactant-free
emulsion media generated by application of power ultrasound to a biphasic water–organic mixture is illustrated by
reference to three systems, some requiring further activation by light, and each catalysed by vitamin B
12
. The
voltammetry of aqueous vitamin B
12
solutions at an electrode modified with microdroplets of the organic reactant
is employed to gain an insight into the electrocatalytic pathway and readily permits the identification of optimum
reaction parameters, such as starting material ratios and wavelength of light. The latter are employed in
proof-of-concept emulsion electrosynthesis under conditions of triple activation (electron transfer, ultrasound and
light).
1. Introduction
Over the last decade, the environment has become a major focus
for electrochemists offering ‘green’ and socially responsible
solutions in a plethora of areas notably the clean and efficient
production of fine chemicals required for modern society with a
minimisation or elimination of the resulting industrial waste.
1,2
Electrosynthetic processes conducted in emulsion media as
opposed to conventional non-aqueous solvents are thus attrac-
tive, since the formation of an oil-in-water emulsion in which
the reactant is solubilised, provides a significant ‘greening’ of
an otherwise potentially environmentally unfriendly synthetic
route; conventional non-aqueous solvents are problematic since
they can be immiscible with water and can yield poisons on
degradation. Furthermore, since the major component of the
emulsion is water, the electrochemical reaction benefits from
this near-ideal reaction environment; water has both a high
conductivity and polarity. Additionally, product isolation by
extraction or filtration is straight-forward.
1
Following earlier work by Eberson and Helgee,
3–7
Rusling et
al. have pioneered the use of microemulsions as viable and
‘green’ media in which to conduct electrosynthetic processes
for the last fifteen years,
8–14
as they are less toxic and less
expensive replacements for organic solvents. Product yield and
selectivity in these optically clear and stable microheteroge-
neous mixtures of surfactants, oils and water has been shown to
be, inter alia, a function of the type of emulsion used;
bicontinuous microemulsions, in which both the oil and water
phases are continuous, with surfactant residing at the extended
oil–water interfaces, have been shown to be superior in terms of
selectivity and reaction efficiency compared with continuous
oil-in-water microemulsions (where the oil droplets are typi-
cally between 0.01 and 0.1 mm in diameter). By the early 1990s,
efficient dehalogenation of toxic organics such as PCBs and
DDT was shown, and has subsequently been extended to other
organic pollutants.
8,9
Mediated electrosynthesis, in which
electrons are delivered from the electrode to reactants by
employing a chemical mediator, in emulsion media is addition-
ally attractive as the exact composition of the emulsion can
influence the reaction pathway.
9
For carbon–carbon bond
formation with alkyl bromides (RX) as reactants, vitamin B
12
has proved to be useful as a chemical mediator,
15,16
in which a
Co(III) species is ligated to a tetraazamacrocyclic (corrin)
ring.
15–17
For organic synthesis, the seemingly ‘special’ ability
of vitamin B
12
and its derivatives to form alkyl–cobalt bonds,
together with the ease of their homolysis, producing alkyl
radicals, has lead to their use as ‘radical-in-a-bottle’ reagents,
with applications in the synthesis of, inter alia, prostaglandins,
pheromones, and chiral alcohols.
15,18–22
The mediated electro-
synthetic pathway involves the electrochemical generation of a
‘supernucleophile’ intermediate, which in the case of vitamin
B
12
, Co(III)L, is the Co(I)L complex:
9–13,15–17
Green Context
Electrosynthesis has considerable potential for greener
organic chemistry including the manufacture of speciality
chemicals. Electrosynthetic processes conducted in emul-
sion media where the major component is water are
particularly attractive. Here we see described the extension
of this approach through the use of an acoustically-
emulsified biphasic system. The total absence of surfactants
further adds to its green credentials. This preliminary study
suggests that the surfactant-free electrocatalytic synthesis of
carbon–carbon bonds can be achieved in yields of at least
50%. This is believed to be the first paper dealing with
electrosynthesis under triple activation conditions (light,
ultrasound and electron-transfer) nicely illustrating how the
combination of cleaner technologies is often required to
achieve the greenest chemistry. JHC
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2002
570 Green Chemistry, 2002, 4, 570–577 DOI: 10.1039/b205706a