2010 12
th
Electronics Packaging Technology Conference
Force Transmitting Element Fabrication and Characterization for MEMS Tri-axial Force Sensor
Application
Muhammad HAMIDULLAH*
1
, Li Shiah LIM
1
, Shimul Jennifier NOOR
1,2
, Daquan YU
1
, Woo Tae PARK
1
, Lichun SHAO
1
,
Kotlanka RAMAKHRISNA
1
, Hanhua FENG
1
1
Institute of Microelectronics, A*STAR
(Agency for Science, Technology and Research)
11 Science Park Road, Singapore Science Park II, Singapore 117685
2
National University of Singapore
*Tel : (65) 6770 5422 Fax : (65) 6774 5747 Email : muhammad@ime.a-star.edu.sg
Abstract
This paper presented the design, fabrication, and
characterization of force transmitting element for MEMS tri-
axial force sensor application. The transmitting element
consists of two main parts: integrated silicon rod and
mechanical stopper. The advantages of the design are the
simplicity of fabrication process, the ability to detect force in
all direction and to protect the sensing element from excessive
force, thus increase the robustness of the devices.
Introduction
From conversations with experienced vascular surgeons in
minimally invasive endovascular surgery, up to 20% of the
procedures are abandoned due to failed wire traversal. Higher
number of procedures is prolonged due to repeated attempts to
manipulate the guidewire across the lesions. This is because;
current procedure relies mainly on surgeon’s skill in
manipulating the guidewire and determining the location of
the blockage of the vessel lumen. To help resolve above
problems, sensorised guidewires with MEMS tri-axial force
sensor has been designed and currently is being fabricated [1].
The basic structure of the MEMS triaxial force sensor was
demonstrated for bigger dimensions for surgical knife
application [2,3]. In this work, we are leveraging the
knowledge of silicon nanowire force sensors [4], integrated
silicon rod structure and a novel mechanical stopper concept.
Basically, a tactile sensor comprises four layers––a sensing
layer, an electronics layer, a protective layer and a support
layer [5]. Design and material of protective layer is important
because it will also be a part of force transmitting element. For
guidewire application, it will have an important role for the
overall functionality of tactile sensor because it will be in
direct contact with the blood and blood vessel lumen and must
be able to limit the sensing range, therefore it will protect the
sensing element from excessive force and increase the
reliability of the devices.
Elastic polymer is commonly used as protective layer
because it will not reduce the sensitivity of the sensing
element due to low young's modulus and high yield strain
properties [6,7]. However, despite giving a good normal force
transfer to the sensing element, Gábor Vásárhelyi shows that
the ability to transfer shear force could be limited and they
have demonstrated the use of plastic rod structure as force
transmitting element [8]. Significant improvement of shear
force sensitivity is achieved in comparison with direct
elastomer covering without rod structure. However, the
placement of the plastic rod into the hole on sensing element
requires a precise positioning and there is no protection for the
sensing element from excessive external force.
This paper presents the design, fabrication, and
characterization of force transmitting element to achieve
robust structure of the tactile sensor. It will begin with design
requirement continued by the fabrication process and
characterization of force transmitting element. Finally, it will
discuss the possible failure mechanism and summaries the
feasibility for guidewire application in minimally invasive
endovascular surgery.
Design Requirement
For sensorised guidewire application, the final device size
is the important factor. As the device will be placed in the tip
of guidewire, the maximum width of the device must be less
than 360um, which is the diameter size of the guidewire. It has
to be able to sense three dimension forces and must be able to
limit the displacement of sensing element because too much
displacement will break the sensing element. The whole
device must be able to sustain the tip load of guidewire. The
tip load is defined by measuring the buckling load of the
guidewire. The amount of tip load depends on the type of
guidewire, which is mainly categorized on severity of blood
vessel blockage. An example is the commercial guidewire
from Asahi Intecc, which in general has two different type of
guidewire based on the ranges of tip load [9]. For front line
cases, the tip load range is from 0.5 gram to 1 gram and for
chronic occlusion case, the tip load range is from 3 gram to 12
gram. Finally, the biocompability of the material used is the
most important factor for this application.
Figure 1(a) shows the design of the sensorized guidewires
with MEMS tri-axial force sensor and the expected dimension
of the MEMS force sensor chip consist of sensing and force
transmitting element in figure 1(b). There will be two main
part of force transmitting element, the silicon rod and ball
mechanical stopper. Integrated silicon rod structure will
simplify the overall fabrication process as the structure is
integrated with the sensing element. The mechanical stopper
structure will enable the tactile sensor to detect forces in three
dimensions, and at the same time is also functioning as
98
978-1-4244-8562-8/10/$26.00 ©2010 IEEE