Low-dimensional sublattice melting by pressure: Superionic conduction in the phase interfaces
of the fluorite-to-cotunnite transition of CaF
2
Salah Eddine Boulfelfel, Dirk Zahn, Oliver Hochrein, Yuri Grin, and Stefano Leoni*
Max-Planck-Institute for Chemical Physics of Solids, Nöthnitzer Str. 40, D-01187 Dresden, Germany
Received 19 May 2006; published 28 September 2006; corrected 29 September 2006
The pressure-induced phase transformation of calcium fluoride CaF
2
from the cubic-fluorite-type structure
Fm3
¯
m to the orthorhombic cotunnite PbCl
2
type structure Pnma is investigated from transition path
sampling molecular dynamics simulations. Starting from an artificially prepared transformation route connect-
ing fluorite to cotunnite, subsequent trajectory rectification evolved to a distinct picture of the favored mecha-
nism. The latter is characterized by nucleation and growth of the new phase. The overall transformation
mechanism was identified as a symmetry-lowering step from the cubic to the orthorhombic atomic configura-
tion which is caused by the reorganization of one half of the octahedral voids. At the interface between the
cubic and the orthorhombic structure, a pressure-induced local melting of the fluoride sublattice is observed.
This produces defects that allow for the reorganization of the calcium sublattice which eventually leads to the
recrystallization of the fluoride ions fixating one of the stable structures. Variation of the thermodynamic
parameters shows that the mechanism is conserved over the experimentally relevant range, however with an
increasing tendency towards incomplete transformation on lowering the temperature, in accordance with
experiments.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.74.094106 PACS numbers: 64.70.Kb, 02.70.Ns, 07.05.Tp, 61.50.Ks
INTRODUCTION
Transformation processes between liquid and solid phases
are phenomena of central importance in nature. The most
fundamental transition of this kind is represented by crystal-
lization from the melt. While this is one of the main synthetic
pathways in solid state synthesis, a more peculiar phenom-
enon is reflected by superionic conductors, a fascinating
blend of solid and liquid states that arises when only parts of
a compound become liquid. In CaF
2
, the fluoride sublattice is
well known to melt on raising temperature. The present work
is aimed at demonstrating pressure as an important thermo-
dynamic variable governing sublattice melting in CaF
2
. Re-
cently, the tremendous technological potential of ion con-
ducting materials based on distinct transport effects in
interface regions has been reviewed.
1
Inspired by these stud-
ies we decided to explore the possible similarities between
ion conduction in the interface region of CaF
2
-BaF
2
-CaF
2
sandwich structures
1
and phase fronts forming during
pressure-induced structural transformations.
The polymorphism of CaF
2
encompasses two fundamen-
tal structural types, the low pressure face-centered cubic
fluorite structure space group Fm3
¯
m, for which CaF
2
is the
prototype compound, and the high pressure PbCl
2
type for
the orthorhombic polymorph cotunnite space group
Pnma.
2,3
For salt-like compounds of composition AB
2
,
these structures offer an attractive combination of a close-
packed array of A atoms and interstitial sites of different
coordination number available for atom B. In the fluorite
structure the Ca ions are in a cubic close-packed ccp ar-
rangement, the fluoride ions occupy all the tetrahedral inter-
stitial sites. In the cotunnite structure, the array of A atoms is
hexagonal close-packed hcp,
4
half of the fluoride ions ex-
hibit tetrahedral coordination, the other half is placed off-
center in the ideally octahedral voids of hcp, with fivefold
coordination. Ca is eightfold coordinated in the fluorite struc-
ture, while the coordination number increases to nine in the
denser cotunnite structure. The fluorite and cotunnite struc-
tures are also realized by the fluorides of the heavier
alkaline-earth metals Sr, Ba. The series of high-pressure
structures for AB
2
composition is enriched by a plethora of
other phases like EuI
2
, -PbO
2
, on varying the halogen moi-
ety, like in CaCl
2
, or in oxide compounds like ZrO
2
. Despite
the chemical diversity of these compounds, the analogies in
their high-pressure behavior, particularly the reappearance of
the same atomic pattern among high-pressure polymorphs,
hints at common features.
Experimental investigations of the mechanistic details of
pressure-induced reconstructive phase transitions are compli-
cated by the first-order thermodynamics that often causes the
destruction of the crystal. Furthermore, these processes dis-
play a large pressure hysteresis. For CaF
2
, the fluorite-to-
cotunnite phase transition occurs in the range 9.5– 20 GPa,
5
with the cotunnite phase retransforming to the fluorite phase
on releasing pressure. The high-pressure polymorph can be
quenched from higher temperature, 300 ° C, nonetheless the
crystallinity of the obtained material is poor.
3
To shed light on the mechanism of the reconstructive
phase transition we have performed isothermic-isobaric mo-
lecular dynamics simulations within a recently implemented
transition path sampling scheme.
6
The latter allows investi-
gating the transformation at the phase coexistence condi-
tions, and is particularly suited for observing phase nucle-
ation and growth in solid state reconstructive phase
transitions. The performance of our approach has been ex-
tensively demonstrated for alkaline halogenides.
7–10
SIMULATION DETAILS
The simulation scheme as it is described in Ref. 6 requires
modeling of a first transition trajectory which is subsequently
PHYSICAL REVIEW B 74, 094106 2006
1098-0121/2006/749/0941067 ©2006 The American Physical Society 094106-1