Macroscopic description for the quantum Weibel instability
F. Haas
*
and M. Lazar
Institut für Theoretische Physik IV, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, D-44780 Bochum Germany
Received 25 January 2008; published 15 April 2008
The Weibel instability in the quantum plasma case is treated by means of a fluidlike moments approach.
Quantum modifications to the macroscopic equations are then identified as effects of the first or second kind.
Quantum effects of the first kind correspond to a dispersive term, similar to the Bohm potential in the quantum
hydrodynamic equations for plasmas. Effects of the second kind are due to the Fermi statistics of the charge
carriers and can become the dominant influence for strong degeneracy. The macroscopic dispersion relations
are of higher order than those for the classical Weibel instability. This corresponds to the presence of a cutoff
wave number even for the strong temperature anisotropy case.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.77.046404 PACS numbers: 52.59.Hq, 71.10.Ca, 52.65.Kj
I. INTRODUCTION
The field of quantum plasmas has been introduced long
ago 1,2 and is presently attracting renewed attention from a
variety of viewpoints. It was already confirmed that quantum
mechanical effects, e.g., electron tunneling and wave-packet
spreading, play a central role in the behavior of metallic or
semiconductor nanostructures of the next generation elec-
tronic devices 3–5. Some astrophysical compact objects,
such as white dwarf or neutron stars, possess very high tem-
perature and strong quantum effects due to their large densi-
ties 10
6
g / cm
3
6. There have been recent studies in
quantum plasmas involving quantum turbulence 7, quan-
tum analogs for the Harris sheet 8, quantum models taking
into account spin 9,10, stable solitary structures 11, dark
soliton and vortices solutions 12, variational structures for
the quantum Zakharov system 13, as well as application of
quantum hydrodynamic equations for carbon nanotubes 14.
The growing interest on quantum plasmas comes in part
from the recently introduced hydrodynamic equations
15–17, which are simpler in comparison to the kinetic de-
scriptions used in the original developments. However, the
Weibel instability 18 is usually treated in terms of kinetic
descriptions. The Weibel instability is one of the basic
plasma instabilities and is driven by an anisotropic velocity
distribution of plasma particles 18,19. The quantum version
of the Weibel instability has been recently proposed 20–22
on grounds of the dispersion relation for the Wigner-
Maxwell system, which is the quantum counterpart of the
Vlasov-Maxwell system. Therefore, the details of the insta-
bility are dependent on the precise form of the equilibrium
Wigner pseudodistribution function, in a similar way as the
traditional Weibel instability is partially dependent on the
exact form of the classical equilibrium distribution function.
The purpose of this paper is to overcome this condition by
means of a moment description for the quantum Weibel in-
stability. Recently, the classical Weibel instability was inves-
tigated by Basu 23 taking moments of the Vlasov-Poisson
system and the present work follows basically the same strat-
egy. Here, however, the starting point is the linearized
Wigner-Maxwell system. It is also interesting to verify to
what extent a fluidlike approach as the moment method is
able to capture the essentials of the Weibel instability, in the
quantum case. Some peculiar subtleties coming from the
quantum nature of the model equations will show up. The
transition from a kinetic to a fluidlike approach in a quantum
plasma model will be shown to reveal the quantum effects of
a different nature according to the density of the system, as
explained more thoroughly in the continuation.
Classical plasmas frequently have equilibrium distribution
functions anisotropic in velocity space 24 –26. In the con-
text of quantum plasmas, velocity anisotropy can arise at
least for laser plasmas and neutron stars. It is well known
27 that anisotropic heating by resonant absorption can pro-
duce a Weibel-like instability in laser plasmas. Also, there is
experimental evidence of Weibel instability in laser-solid in-
teraction experiments 28. In addition, in tunnel-ionized la-
ser plasmas there can be velocity anisotropy driven by a
varying laser polarization 29. Quantum effects should be
more evident in the next generation of laser-solid interaction
experiments, where the densities are very high. For neutron
stars, it has been conjectured 30 that anisotropic heating
can arise in view of fast rotation, implying a strongly de-
formed neutrino sphere and anisotropic neutrino fluxes.
There are estimates 31 where the pole-to-equator neutrino
flux ratio can assume a value of 2. For these reasons, it is
important to have a better understanding of the Weibel insta-
bility taking into account quantum effects.
As examples of distinct equilibrium Wigner functions for
the quantum Weibel instability, one can have Maxwell-
Boltzmann or Fermi-Dirac functions, both with anisotropy in
velocity space. Using a moment description, there is some
lost of information, but more universal statements are made
available. As for any moments or fluid modeling, an intrinsic
limit of such an approach is in the closure of the equations.
Indeed, one is always faced with a system where the equa-
tion for the time evolution of the velocity moment of order n
depends on the velocity moment of order n +1. In this way
23, it happens that the moment approach is appropriate
only for long wavelength and large temperature anisotropy.
Moment descriptions have also been applied to cyclotron
wave-particle interaction 32.
*
Also at Universidade do Vale do Rio dos Sinos—UNISINOS,
Av. Unisinos 950, 93022–000, São Leopoldo, RS, Brazil.
PHYSICAL REVIEW E 77, 046404 2008
1539-3755/2008/774/0464046 ©2008 The American Physical Society 046404-1