Eur J Nucl Med (1987) 13:213 220
European Nuclear
Journal of
Medicine
© Springer-Verlag 1987
Diagnostic accuracy of rest-exercise first pass ventriculography
with a fast single crystal gamma camera
in detecting coronary artery disease
Study in a group of male subjects without previous myocardial infarction
Raffaele Giubbini, Marco Metra, Paolo Guerra, Giovanni La Canna, Giovanni Bissoli,
Giovanni Arosio, Luigi Niccoli, Odoardo Visioli, and Maurizio Bestagno
Servizio di Medicina Nucleare, Servizio di Policardiografia, Divisione di Cardiologia degli Spedali Civili di Brescia
e Cattedra di Cardiologia dell' Universitfi di Brescia, Italy
Abstract. Rest and exercise radionuclide ventriculograms
were performed in 61 non infarcted, male, patients who
underwent cardiac catheterization for chest pain and in 16
normal control subjects. Studies were performed using the
first pass method with a fast single crystal gamma camera,
which allowed a count rate of 140_+ 19 Kcounts/sec to be
reached during left ventricular filling; the count integral
on left ventricular area was 10.8 _+1.6 Kcounts and the max-
imum count/pixel 155-+ 16. We analyzed sensitivity, speci-
ficity, positive and negative predictive value of global ejec-
tion fraction (EF) and of the regional wall motion in identi-
fying ventricular function abnormalities due to obstructive
coronary artery disease. The regional wall motion was eval-
uated with four functional images: regional ejection frac-
tion (REF), amplitude (A) and phase (PH) from Fourier
analysis and systolic transit times (TT). Sensitivity was near
90 % for EF, REF, A and TT, while PH was less sensitive
(80%); all functional images were more specific (nearly
90 %) than EF (80 %). Both sensitivity and specificity were
lower for the exercise EKG (59 % and 63 %, respectively)
in this patient group. Significant differences between single
vessel and multiple vessel disease were also observed
either for the EF increase/decrease (-1.34+7.4 and
-7.82-+9.96; P<0.05) or for the number of segments
which developed wall motion abnormalities during exercise
(1.22-+ 0.73 and 2.15 _+1.04; P < 0.02). In conclusion, with
our method, a fast single crystal gamma camera is suitable
for obtaining optimal first pass radionuclide ventriculo-
grams with a count density sufficient either for global or
regional left ventricular function evaluation. First pass ra-
dionuclide ventriculography seems to provide very high di-
agnostic accuracy in the detection of coronary artery dis-
ease in non infarcted, male, subjects.
Key words: First pass ventriculography - Coronary artery
disease - 99mTc-DTPA - Cardiac functional images - Four-
ier analysis
Exercise radionuclide ventriculography (RNV) has been
shown to reliably detect abnormalities of left ventricular
(LV) systolic function induced by myocardial ischemia. Re-
Offprint requests to." Dr. Raffaele Giubbini, Servizio di Medicina
Nucleare Spedali Civili, Piazza Spedali Civili, 1, 1-25100 Brescia,
Italia
cently two main techniques have been developed and suc-
cessfully correlated with the results of contrast ventriculog-
raphy (CVG): first pass RNV (FP-RNV) (Schelbert et al.
1975; Schad 1977, 1978) and gated equilibrium RNV (Borer
et al. 1977, 1979).
FP-RNV offers many theoretical advantages: firstly, the
acquisition time is very short (a few seconds) and so this
examination can be easily performed at the end of maximal
exercise while the patient is comfortably still; secondly, mo-
tion of the diaphragm can be eliminated by making the
patient hold his breath during the LV transit of the radioac-
tive bolus; and lastly, FP-RNV allows the use of the right
anterior oblique (RAO) view by which the LV can be more
thoroughly visualized along its long axis (Fig. 1). These
characteristics make FP-RNV the examination of choice
when performed during isotonic exercise, which, as demon-
strated by Bodenheimer et al. (1983), gives more accurate
results in the identification of coronary artery disease
(CAD) than isometric tests.
Until recently, however, the use of FP-RNV has been
limited by the requirement for a multicrystal gamma cam-
era, which could reach the high count rate needed for the
FP-RNV acquisition, but, on the other hand, is very expen-
sive and almost exclusively dedicated.
The recently introduced, fast single crystal gamma cam-
era seems to overcome the main limitation of traditional
equipment, that is its low count rate performance while,
at the same time, it is less expensive and more versatile
than the multicrystal camera. Thus it could allow FP-RNV
to be performed more widely and in less specialized centers.
The aim of this study was to verify the accuracy of
FP-RNV performed with a fast single crystal gamma cam-
era in the detection of the abnormalities of LV systolic
function caused by exercise induced myocardial ischemia
in patients with CAD.
Materials and methods
Data collection and injection technique. The acquisition pro-
tocol for FP-RNV was standardized in order to obtain the
highest count rate and the best reproducibility.
We used a fast digital gamma camera system, LFOV 1,
capable of measuring 200000 cps with 25% loss at 20%
window. It was equipped with a high sensitivity parallel
hole collimator (6.5 x 10 4 FWHM:15 ram); the energy
1 Elscint Apex 415