The InternationalJournal of Nautical Archaeology (1999) 28.2:200-206
Article No. ijna.1999.0228
Refiews ®
Seagoing Ships and Seamanship in the
Bronze Age Levant
SHELLEY WACHSMANN
448 pp., 679 B&W illustrations
Texas A&M University Press and Chatham
Publishing, London, 1998, US $80 and £55,
ISBN 0-89096-709-1 (US) and 1-86176-068-X
(UK)
In Seagoing Ships and Seamanship #7 the Bronze
Age Levant S. Wachsmann takes on a nearly
impossible task: to catalogue and interpret
evidence for seafaring in the Eastern
Mediterranean from archaeological sources.
Copiously illustrated, this volume presents the
rich collection of images and models for the
period as well as more certain evidence from
seagoing and, from Egypt, river boats. Because
only two Bronze Age sites with hull remains
have been excavated in the Mediterranean,
Wachsmann's discussion of ship construction
relies primarily upon iconographic studies and
the recent studies of the c. 1200 BC Cape
Gelidonya and c. 1306 BC Uluburun ship-
wrecks off the Turkish coast with reference to
Nilotic vessels of the Bronze Age.
A variety of archaeological discoveries indi-
cate contact by sea, and contemporary texts,
referred to in translation throughout the discus-
sion, illuminate some aspects of the maritime
world of the second millennium BC. As in L.
Basch's compendium L'mus~e imaginah'e de la
marine antique, Wachsmann also uses 20th cen-
tury ethnographic examples, pharaonic river
craft and cross-cultural observations to support
his arguments for particularistic interpretations
of boat models and representations from the
region's seafaring cultures. As Wachsmann
points out, when we see ships scratched on
temple walls, painted on ancient pots, or, as
carved tomb decorations, 'we see not ships but
representations of ships "refracted" through
the eyes, culture, schooling, mental attitudes,
and skills of their creators'. How much more
1057-2414/99/020200 + 07 $30.00/0
difficult a task, then, to attempt segregating our
own expectations and 'refractions' in such
studies.
Organization of the volume is first by culture
(with about half this section devoted to Minoan
and Aegean cultures) and then by topic, begin-
ning with ship construction and considering
propulsion, anchors, navigation, sea trade, war,
piracy and law. An excellent glossary by F. M.
Hocker provides invaluable and precise defi-
nitions for ship components and associated
terms. The bibliography is extensive, as is the
fine index. The tight focus of this book will
appeal particularly to those already familiar
with the names and locations of islands,
countries ancient and modern, shipwrecks and
cities. All readers, however, could benefit from
a comprehensive map in addition to the three
simple examples in the navigation chapter that
includes some of the harbours and shipwrecks
mentioned in the text.
Beginning in Egypt and working counter-
clockwise around the eastern Mediterranean
basin, appropriately concluding with those
nomadic seafarers called 'Peoples of the Sea' in
Egyptian inscriptions, Wachsmann takes us on
a journey designed to present an exhaustive
survey of data that may be brought to bear on
the questions when, how, where, and why did
Bronze Age peoples go to sea. Much of the
evidence is familiar, and benefits from the large
format presentation of photographs and line
drawings, many of the latter redrawn by the
author from original publications. Detailed
discussions by specialists are valuable addi-
tions. For example: T. G. Palaima reviews the
Linear-B (Mycenaean Greek) rowing tablets
from Pylos; John Lenz contributes a detailed
analysis of Homer's epithet 'curved' as it
applies to ships; and, an appendix provides
recent translations of documents related to
seafaring found at Ugarit by J. Hoftijzer and
W. H. van Soldt.
The perils and pitfalls Of iconography are
many, and it is to his credit that the author
carefully points out many potential sources of
inaccuracy in ancient works, from technique to
© 1999The Nautical ArchaeologySociety