Journal of Intellectual Disability - Diagnosis and Treatment, 2015, 3, 35-42 35
E-ISSN: 2292-2598/15 © 2015 Lifescience Global
Functional Measurement of Special Education Teachers’ and
Students’ Expectations Toward Job Training for Persons with
Intellectual Disability
Guadalupe Elizabeth Morales-Martinez
1,*
, Ernesto Octavio Lopez-Ramirez
2
,
Maria Guadalupe Villarreal-Treviño
2
and Yanko Norberto Mezquita-Hoyos
3
1
Research Institute for the University and Education, Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico, Mexico
City, Mexico
2
Department of Psychology, Universidad Autonoma de Nuevo Leon, Monterrey City, Mexico
3
Department of Psychology, Universidad Autonoma de Yucatán, Mérida City, Mexico
Abstract: Persons with intellectual disability (PWID) have fewer opportunities for enrolment in school programs and
post-school employment than do their peers with typical development. Evidence suggests that attitude toward PWID is a
main factor in either promoting or limiting better life conditions for this population. In this paper, the goal was to
determine the cognitive information integration rules underlying the expectations of 174 special education teachers and
students with regard to job training for PWID. In order to accomplish this goal, four factors (Gender, Severity of disability,
Type of task, and Emotional traits) were orthogonally combined to implement a cognitive algebra study design. We
obtained 48 experimental conditions, with each one presented as a scenario describing a PWID in a work training
situation. Participants read these scenarios and were asked to judge the probability of the success of PWID with regard
to learning the skills needed to complete the required work. Patterns of response allowed us to identify low, moderate,
and high viewpoints with regard to participants’ judgments of predicted success. Personal factors (Emotional traits and
Severity of disability) and the Type of task factor were considered the most important in influencing the participants’
judgment. These factors seemed to be integrated in a complex systematic cognitive pattern. Implications from this type
of result with regard to PWID and work training are discussed in this paper.
Keywords: Intellectual disability, attitudes, special education teachers, work training, cognitive algebra.
To many adults, the idea of getting a job is a
meaningful aspect of our basic life expectancy.
Generally speaking, paid employment is not only a
well-evaluated social concept associated with wealth,
health, economic benefits, and good use of time [1] but
it is also associated with psychological dimensions like
self-esteem and self-concept [2,3], and strengthens
both identity and the sense of self-value [4,5].
Moreover, paid employment seems to be associated
with life satisfaction [6] and, even more importantly, it
imposes a sense of purpose on people’s daily
experiences [7].
Unfortunately, not all people have the opportunity to
gain dignified, paid work. This is frequently the case for
people with intellectual disability (PWID), many of
whom are underemployed or, as a worst case scenario,
jobless [8]. Compared to typical individuals, the PWID
population is three to four times less likely to obtain a
job [9].
Usually, PWID face tremendous problems regarding
job inclusion as well as maintaining employment.
*Address correspondence to this author at the Instituto de Investigaciones
Sobre la Universidad y la Educación, UNAM. Circuito Cultural Universitario,
Coyoacán 04510, D.F., México; Tel: (55) 5622 6986/95; Fax: (55) 5665 0123;
E-mail: gemoramar@hotmail.com, moramar24@yahoo.com.mx
Academically speaking, not much is known about the
nature of factors determining this phenomenon (e.g.,
moving from school to job inclusion [10], job selection
[11], getting and maintaining a job [9], PWID job
experiences [12], employers’ experiences with hiring
PWID).
Overall, previous research addressing this topic has
pointed out that the employment-related variables of
PWID (e.g., job preferences [13], personal preferences
[14], employee demographic profiles [13], motivation
and expectations about job attributes [9]), as well as
contextual factors (family composition during formative
years, school-based staff, early employment
experiences, and the community’s rehabilitation culture
[14]) affect their job opportunities.
In addition, some research suggests that the
expectations of PWID with regard to having a job in the
future have a profound impact throughout their lives on
their rights to access job opportunities, as well as their
job conditions. For instance, Doren, Gau, and
Lindstrom [15] suggested that parents’ expectations
about job inclusion significantly predict the capacity of
PWID to be independent and that that, in turn, predicts
achievement after graduation from school (e.g.,
obtaining a well-paid job). Complementary research by