APPLIED NUTRITIONAL INVESTIGATION
Dietary Oils High in Oleic Acid but With Different
Unsaponifiable Fraction Contents Have Different
Effects in Fatty Acid Composition and
Peroxidation in Rabbit LDL
Julio J. Ochoa, PhD, Jose ´ L. Quiles, PhD, M. C. Ramı ´rez-Tortosa, PhD; Jose ´ Mataix, PhD,
and Jesu ´s R. Huertas, PhD
From the Institute of Nutrition and Food Technology, the Department of Physiology, and
the Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, University of Granada,
Granada, Spain
OBJECTIVE: We investigated the influence of different edible oils high in oleic acid but with different
unsaponifiable fractions on the fatty acid composition and lipid peroxidation in plasma and low-density
lipoprotein (LDL) in rabbits.
METHODS: Thirty-two rabbits were randomly assigned to four groups of eight animals. For 8 wk each
group was fed a semisynthetic isoenergetic diet that differed by lipid source (Picual virgin olive oil, Picual
virgin olive oil that had been subjected to an exhaustive process of washing, Arbequina virgin olive oil,
and sunflower oil high in oleic acid). We analyzed the fatty acid profile, thiobarbituric acid reactive
substances, -tocopherol, coenzyme Q, and retinol in plasma and the fatty acid profile, hydroperoxides,
-tocopherol, and coenzyme Q in LDL.
RESULTS: The two varieties of virgin olive oil behaved differently from the high-oleic sunflower oil, and
the effect of the different ratios of oleic acid to linoleic acid in the lipid sources on fatty acid composition
in plasma and LDL was significant. With regard to oxidative stress, LDL in the group that ingested the
lipid sources with the greatest amount of phenolic compounds showed the highest level of antioxidants
(-tocopherol and coenzyme Q; P 0.05) and the lowest susceptibility to lipid peroxidation (P 0.05).
CONCLUSION: This study provides evidence in vivo of the considerable antioxidant capacity of the
phenolic fraction of virgin olive oil in rabbit LDL and the important role that this unsaponifiable fraction
can play in the overall antioxidant benefit attributed to these oils. However, these effects depend on the
phenolic content of the oil. Nutrition 2002;18:60 – 65. ©Elsevier Science Inc. 2002
KEY WORDS: unsaponifiable fraction, oleic acid, fatty acid composition, lipid peroxidation, low-density
lipoproteins, rabbits
INTRODUCTION
Atherosclerosis is the principal cause of cardiovascular disease in
the Western world. Many epidemiologic studies have correlated
the state and composition of low-density lipoproteins (LDLs) with
the development of atherosclerotic plaque and, hence, with the
higher and lower incidences of cardiovascular disease.
1,2
Chemical
and physical alterations of LDL as a result of oxidation increase
the atherogenic properties of these lipoproteins.
3–5
Nutritional and
biochemical studies have suggested that diet can change suscepti-
bility to LDL oxidation by the influence the lipid profile of the
lipid source ingested exerts on the lipid profile of these particles
and by changing their antioxidant content.
3,5
Thus, several studies
have shown that enrichment of lipoproteins with oleic acid, present
in olive oil, boosts resistance to oxidation more than does enrich-
ment with linoleic acid, present in sunflower oil.
3,5,6
These results in part have given rise to a consumer market for
the new vegetable oils enriched with this monounsaturated fatty
acid, e.g., sunflower oil high in oleic acid. However, although the
composition of fatty acids in these new oils is quite similar to that
found in virgin olive oil, significant differences exist, especially in
the unsaponifiable fraction (also called non-glyceride). Thus, it
should be borne in mind that these oils require refining, a process
that brings about, among other effects, a significant loss of the
antioxidants in the unsaponifiable fraction.
6–8
This has a signifi-
cant effect on oxidative stress and has received little attention to
date.
Virgin olive oil, a monounsaturated fat widely used in the
Mediterranean diet, apart from its high oleic acid content, has an
unsaponifiable fraction rich in antioxidant compounds, including
phenolic compounds. In fact, this is the only dietary oil that
contains these compounds, which contribute considerably to the
oxidative stability of this oil.
9
In addition, numerous studies have
shown the antioxidative capacity of phenolics, which reduce the
susceptibility of LDL and erythrocyte membranes to lipid
peroxidation.
10 –12
However, most of those studies have been per-
formed in vitro and have used individual phenolic compounds.
Virgin olive oil has a wide range of variation in saponifiable
This study was supported by the Fundacio ´ n para la Promocio ´ n y Desarrollo
del Aceite de Oliva y del Olivar, Jae ´n, Spain. Dietary oils were kindly
supplied by COOSUR, S.A., Jaen, Spain.
Correspondence to: Julio J. Ochoa-Herrera, PhD, Institute of Nutrition and
Food Technology, C/Ramon y Cajal, 4, 18071, Granada, Spain. E-mail:
aging@goliat.ugr.es
Nutrition 18:60 – 65, 2002 0899-9007/02/$22.00
©Elsevier Science Inc., 2002. Printed in the United States. All rights reserved. PII S0899-9007(01)00732-8